A challenge for the mobile processor industry is that the two largest smartphone makers, Samsung and Apple, are effectively a closed door because they rely on their own chip designs. Well, not as closed as once thought, perhaps. Both majors are likely to pursue multivendor processor strategies to differentiate various models and to ensure they do not run into supply shortages ‘ and most importantly, to integrate LTE modems with their CPUs. Qualcomm has stolen a hugely valuable march on rivals with all-in-one LTE handset platforms and is cashing in now.
Although Samsung has been relying increasingly heavily on its Exynos platform for its flagship Galaxy models, it uses third party processors in some other lines, and even in some Galaxies. Meanwhile, Apple is reported to be planning to introduce Qualcomm Snapdragon to a rumored ‘iPhone mini’.
Last week Apple was reported to be readying a foundry deal with Intel, to reduce its reliance on Samsung for making its A-Series iPhone processors. The latest twist is it might also bring back third party silicon to the iPhones, reversing the recent strategy of using only its own-designed A-Series CPUs.
Apple could use Qualcomm Snapdragon in rumored low end iPhones, says a report in China Times, citing unnamed sources. That would give the US chip provider an even greater strategic relationship with Apple ‘ it has already squeezed out other modem suppliers because of its expertise in CDMA and LTE.
It would also be a surprise move for Apple, presumably designed to differentiate a potential entry level iPhone from the premium models, in terms of cost and perhaps battery life (an iPhone weakness). Qualcomm can provide an integrated system-on-chip combining the processor and modem, which cuts power consumption, cost and device size, all important for an entry level device that would need to be priced below $200 unsubsidized to capture mass adoption in emerging economies. Currently, the iPhone uses a separate CPU, the Apple A6, and modem, while some Snapdragon configurations also provide tight integration of Wi-Fi and Bluetooth.
Analysts think Apple could cut up to $30 from the iPhone 5 bill of materials (which is about $200) by introducing lower cost processor, display driver and memory, and another $10 from a cheaper case and other reductions.
Other companies are expected to be introduced to Apple’s supply chain to support a lower cost device and so prevent too much erosion of the vendor’s margins. Renesas is said to be lined up to manufacture LCD drivers for the new handset, while NAND flash memory could be sourced from Toshiba, Micron Technology and SanDisk.
The diversification of Apple’s suppliers, which is seen across all its iDevices, is designed to increase its negotiating position, ensure availability of critical components, and reduce its dependence on Samsung for memory, displays and processor manufacture. Samsung also originally designed the iPhone CPU, but that has now come under full Apple control. The smartphone maker is asserting rising control of the design of competitive elements like the processor and the RetinaDisplay screen technology.
Of course, there is no firm confirmation that Apple is even planning an entry level iPhone, though it is widely assumed that it needs to target a model at the growth in emerging markets and featurephone upgraders, and avoid ceding this growth market to Android. In future, it may assert full control of its platform again by acquiring a modem maker, or creating an exclusive relationship with one, to deliver the much-needed integrated Ax/baseband combination. Of course, there are two modem suppliers on the market right now ‘ ST-Ericsson and Renesas Mobile ‘ but both would likely come with too much baggage and legacy product to suit Apple.
In the meantime, Apple will be hard at work on the next generation of its own processor. This will mark its first project with Taiwanese foundry TSMC, which will take some of the manufacturing work away from Samsung (the potential Intel deal would be for the following generation). TSMC is expected to tape out the A7 chip this month, according to Taiwan’s Digitimes. That would lead to commercial production in the first quarter of 2014, by which time the foundry’s 20nm process is scheduled to be ready. Apple is designing chips based on that 20nm process now but could well look to Intel’s upcoming 14nm process, which will enable even greater size and power reductions, from 2014. Some analysts, however, think Apple will sign Intel earlier than that and split the A7 line between TSMC and Intel’s new 22nm platform.
Meanwhile, Samsung is reported to be taking the same line for its new Galaxy S4 as it did for the current S3 ‘ making two variants, one based on Exynos and one on Qualcomm Snapdragon. That enables the Korean firm to provide an LTE version for the US market with an integrated processor/modem, to reduce cost, size and power consumption. However, that brings some compromises on the performance side ‘ the top end four-core Snapdragons do not yet come with integrated modems, though the Snapdragon 800 will offer that capability late this year. That would confine Samsung to a two-core Snapdragon if it wants an all-in-one chipset.
By contrast, the international S4 may include the newest Exynos model, the Exynos 5 Octa with eight cores ‘ a first for a smartphone. In fact, the eight cores are based on the ARM big.Little design, which pairs four high performance cores for tasks like gaming, with four power efficient ones for routine handset activities, to balance heavy duty processing with battery life.