Regulators round the world face the challenge of balancing two sometimes incompatible goals ‘ to encourage competition and guard against monopolies; and to ensure rapid roll-out of the best services for consumers. The challenge gets harder with mobile broadband ‘ the services everyone wants to support their rising data addiction require hugely expensive networks, and the cost of the infrastructure can rarely be borne by a new entrant, as seen at the well-funded Clearwire, let alone the kind of agile new operators which appear in most visions of the new mobile economy. One solution is to split the infrastructure from the service providers, and this may well be the end game ‘ steps along the way, like MVNOs and RAN sharing, are gradually being approved by the world’s telecoms watchdogs, while other steps, such as over-the-top services, are happening without any real regulation at all. But in the short term, most countries still have a system of several competing carriers which have to invest in their own infrastructure, which requires the kind of scale that may work against innovation and entrepreneurialism.
The difficult balance has always plagued US mobile telecoms, where there have been successive disasters surrounding the bid to support counterweights to AT&T and Verizon (NextWave, LightSquared and so on, not to mention MVNOs like Helio). Scale is everything, and while the combination of AT&T and T-Mobile was too big to get past the antitrust authorities, the merger of T-Mobile and MetroPCS creates, the regulators hope, a body which will be, competitively speaking, more than the sum of its parts.
Despite shareholder complaints and hostile filings from rivals, the merger has cleared its main regulatory hurdles, winning approval from the FCC and the antitrust agency of the Department of Justice. The telecoms body announced its decision on Tuesday, following in the footsteps of the DoJ. FCC chairman Julius Genachowski said in a statement that the combining of the US’s fourth and fifth cellcos would benefit consumers by strengthening their ability to roll out new high speed services rapidly. Bolstering these two players is also seen as a way to enhance competition to Verizon and AT&T. The latter’s own bid for T-Mobile collapsed amid regulatory disapproval in 2011, and in recent months TMo has become increasingly aggressive against its former acquirer as it prepares to launch its own LTE offerings.
Merger with MetroPCS will bring it existing 4G services, but also the complexities of aligning its GSM and HSPA networks and spectrum with the flat rate carrier’s CDMA systems. TMo is already going through a complex spectrum refarming effort, moving 3G into the PCS band to live alongside GSM, and thus freeing up the AWS frequencies for LTE. MetroPCS will bring its new parent additional AWS capacity as well as an intensified focus on the prepaid market, a direction in which TMo has been shifting over the past couple of years as the big two carriers tighten their hold on the postpaid, premium segments.
The deal will leave TMo’s parent, Deutsche Telekom, with 74% of the combined entity after paying MetroPCS shareholders $1.5bn in cash. However, the latter’s biggest investor, Paulson & Co, has opposed the terms of the merger and threatened legal action. The MetroPCS shareholder vote is set for April 12. Trade union CWA (Communications Workers of America) has also opposed the deal because of fears of job losses.
The FCC ruling said that, although the merger plan ‘raises horizontal competition issues because it would result in the combination of overlapping mobile wireless coverage and services in various markets, as well as the transfer of customers of two current competitors’, those concerns are outweighed by the benefits, which include expanded LTE deployments, ‘the expansion of the MetroPCS brand into new geographical markets, the development of a more robust, national network, improved quality of service and the strengthening of the fourth largest nationwide service providers’ ability to compete in the mobile broadband services market’.
When the merger goes ahead, the new operator will hold up to 110MHz of spectrum covering 141m POPs, or 46% of the mainland US population, in 248 markets. Most of the spectrum will be in the PCS and AWS bands, plus one lower 700MHz licence. Most importantly, it will be ableto deploy 2 x 20MHz LTE channels ‘ the amount needed for true broadband ‘ in 90% of the top 25 markets. The firm will have a total of 42m customers but will not overtake Sprint to be the number three cellco.
The FCC added: ‘Both T-Mobile USA and MetroPCS have a history of being disruptive influences or ‘mavericks’, and moreover, Newco would have an economic incentive to continue to play this role. As the smallest of the nationwide service providers, it would benefit less from coordination than its significant rivals and it can expand output relatively inexpensively.’
Other countries are only at the start of creating an environment where ‘mavericks’ can thrive, and they have to tread carefully if they are relying on huge incumbents to foot the bill to bring broadband to the masses. This is seen in Mexico, where proposed new legislation would curb monopoly behavior and encourage foreign investment in smaller players. But that means America Movil, Latin America’s dominant mobile group, could face a break-up reminiscent of AT&T’s 30 years ago.
The proposed laws would create an agency with the power to regulate competition in the telecoms and broadcasting industries, said Gerardo Ruiz Esparza, communications and transport minister. They were backed by Mexican president Enrique Pena Nieto.
America Movil, which is controlled by the world’s richest man, Carlos Slim, controls 70% of the mobile base in Mexico and 80% of landlines, so would stand to lose most from rules to boost competition. The company operates throughout the region and its main challenger is another multinational group, Spain’s Telefonica. Also on the defensive will be Grupo Televisa, which has 70% of the broadcast TV market in Mexico.
Movil’s stock fell to its lowest level in almost four years on news of the proposals, which would, among other things, help smaller carriers to win foreign investment or takeovers. A new agency, to be called the Federal Telecommunications Institute, would also be able to ‘mandate the divestiture of assets of market participants to the extent necessary to eliminate anti-competitive effects’.
‘This is one of the bigger threats we’ve seen for America Movil from a regulatory standpoint,’ Chris King, an analyst at Stifel Nicolaus, told Bloomberg. ‘It certainly could be the beginning of some type of significant change for the industry itself, particularly if you get regulators with real teeth.’
President Nieto said that a low level of telecoms competition ‘reduces productivity in Mexico, limiting its capacity to grow and generate better-paying jobs. This reform allows growth possibilities. But to achieve this, companies will have to invest and innovate, offer better prices and improve their quality of service.’
America Movil said in a statement that it welcomed an increased focus on ‘greater investments and innovation’, and added: ‘We support the opening of foreign investment in telecommunications services. We compete in 18 countries where we benefit from this type of policy of openness to investment, and we’ve always supported such openness.’
However, critics say that removing the ban on foreign firms owning more than 49% of Mexican telcos will not support independent players, but make it easier for Telefonica to build its armory in Mexico by targeting smaller players like Axtel and Maxcom. There’s that difficult balance again, mirroring earlier moves in the US which have apparently encouraged small players, only to see them snapped up by the big two,
Over the Atlantic, France has traditionally been one of the slowest moving mobile markets, but its regulator, Arcep, galvanized it when it granted a 3G licence to broadband player Free. This led to the launch of Free Mobile, which has been highly disruptive and sparked a price war and dire warnings of disaster from the three existing players ‘ Orange, SFR and Bouygues. However, the regulator now faces accusations that those older cellcos have been critically disadvantaged, even though they have invested most in the country’s push into mobile broadband.
This has seen the antitrust agency, the Autorite de la Concurrence, taking the cellcos’ side against Free and Arcep’s earlier actions. The MVNO and roaming deal between Orange and Free Mobile has been highly controversial with the other two operators hitting out at the incumbent for enabling the unwelcome new competition. Free has its own 3G spectrum, but while it builds out its network, it relies on Orange’s systems to fill in the gaps. This has provided welcome revenue for the leading operator, as prices have fallen in the mobile sector, but has aroused anger at the other two players. The government has also questioned whether Free is meeting the build-out targets in its licence.
Now the competition authority reiterates that Free should see its national roaming agreement with Orange brought to an end within the time limits already agreed, with no extensions. It insists that the roaming deal should be merely a stopgap to enable the new entrant to offer services even before its own network is complete. The current arrangement last until 2018, with a break clause at 2016. Free is said to be paying Orange over €1bn a year, a cost similar to that of rolling out its own network.
The statement from the Autorite came after an investigation into broader issues in the mobile market, including a review of policies on telco M&A or investment/network sharing. The probe also looked into whether roaming deals give new entrants an unfair advantage that could break competition laws and unbalance the market. The three cellcos would argue that Free has done this, with its cut-price, flat rate plans, its free Wi-Fi and its bundling of mobile services with its existing broadband and IPTV offerings.
However, the French regulator has already said that Free’s entry has been ‘an effective instrument for the creation of jobs, growth and improving the country’s competitiveness’ in the long term, and said it would oppose any merger with a larger player. Free was rumored last year to be considering a merger with SFR.
The roaming issue will also rear its ugly head in 4G. In the French LTE spectrum auction, Free won 2.6GHz spectrum but none of the 800MHz licences considered essential for national coverage. The Autorite said the smallest player as the right to sign a roaming deal with SFR, but it is ‘not desirable that it is used to compensate for an inadequate frequency allocation strategy’. It also conceded that, with regard to 2G roaming, there would be no ‘economic logic’ to Free building a GSM network but a roaming agreement could allow the newcomer to support users with 2G-only devices. Any deal for GSM roaming in place after 2016 should be limited to that dwindling band of consumers, it suggested.