Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 March 2013

Operators and developers grow weary of Apple’s games

As Apple comes under the kind of competitive pressure it has not seen since the mid-1990s, it will have to start tempering some of its more arrogant behavior towards its supporters, whether developers or operators. Along with the shaken confidence among investors, it is facing increasingly vocal criticism from the mobile ecosystem.

Apple was able to trade on the revolutionary success of the original iPhone to negotiate extremely tough terms with early carriers of its handset, and although these have been watered down since, the vendor still demands high sales targets and insists on approving each LTE network individually before it allows the iPhone 5’s 4G facilities to be activated (ironic given the iPhone’s history of causing problems for cellular networks, thanks to its users’ data hunger, but also a failure by Apple to learn how mobile systems really worked in the early days).

On the developer side, there have been successive spat over high-handed rules in the App Store; the barring of products Apple saw as competitive to its own; and of course the long feud with Adobe, whose mobile Flash platform Apple refused to support. That was a battle the iDevice maker convincingly won, and Adobe has now transferred its mobile and multiscreen efforts to HTML5. But would the pattern be the same now, with Apple in a weaker position to dictate terms to the whole industry, thanks to the rise of Android in general, and Samsung in particular?

If HTML5 became Apple’s sword against Adobe, it could also be used to slash iOS. Mozilla, basking in the attention lavished on its forthcoming Firefox Mobile OS at Mobile World Congress, may be the one to take up the weapons dropped by Adobe, and defeat Apple in a platform battle. The not-for-profit organization has developed one of the new breed of OSs which could make Apple and Android, with their downloads and native apps, look old hat. Firefox Mobile, like offerings from Jolla, Ubuntu, Alibaba and others ‘ and Google’s Chrome OS ‘ are heavily centered on the browser and HTML5, with just a stripped-down Linux kernel and few or no local apps.

These platforms, and the always-online usage patterns on which they rely, are undeveloped as yet, and so this is largely a battle for the future ‘ though one for which Apple should prepare now. More immediately, Mozilla could score points and dent Apple’s fortress walls with its browser strategy. It says it will refuse to bring its Firefox browser to iOS unless Apple changes its hard line attitude to third parties.

Jay Sullivan, VP of product at the non-profit organization, told the SXSW (South by Southwest) conference that no iOS version of Firefox is currently under development. Speaking on a panel about mobile browsers, Sullivan said the main problem was that Mozilla was not allowed to not run its sophisticated rendering and Javascript engines on iOS. That prevented it from creating an acceptable user experience on iDevices.

Mozilla first took a stand against Apple in 2010, when it said it did not plan to create a standalone browser for the iPhone, citing technical and logistical restrictions imposed by Apple. However, it did then develop the shortlived Firefox Home, which allowed users to sync Firefox history and bookmarks with a web viewer powered by Webkit, Apple’s preferred engine. It pulled Firefox Home from the iOS App Store in September.

Apple’s own Safari browser only supports the Nitro Javascript engine while restricting third party browsers to UIWebView. This gives it a significant performance advantage over other browsers, one of the ways in which critics claim Apple gives its own products an unfair position in the iOS user experience ‘ something Google has failed to achieve in the more open Android, where vendors increasingly create alternative overlays and default to third party search engines and browsers. By contrast, Apple prevents its users from making a non-Safari product their default browser.

Of course, refusing to work with Apple at all carries the risk of being sidelined in the smartphone world. Apple holds about 55% of the mobile browser market with Safari while Mozilla, which has never repeated its effectiveness on the PC in the mobile world, has about 1%. It hopes that will change, and it will disrupt the whole mobile OS market, with the arrival of its Firefox Mobile browser-oriented operating system. This targets two growing trends ‘ the shift of smartphone growth to entry level models, and the rise of cloud-based HTML5 OSs rather than hefty native platforms like iOS and Android.

Other browser makers do continue to play in Apple’s garden, including Opera with the iOS version of Mini, and Google with the new release of Chrome.

One worrying thing about Mozilla expanding from the browser to a full HTML5 OS, for Apple and Google, is that it is winning significant support from operators, which see the platform as a way to bring a sophisticated web experience to entry level smartphones, and to stamp their own brand upon it. That is one change which will embolden carriers to be more assertive against Apple. We have seen carriers refusing to carry the iPhone because of the heavy subsidy bill it brings with it (China Mobile), or ‘unacceptable’ contract terms (US Cellular).

And cellcos have been vocal in criticizing Apple’s restrictions on its LTE iPhone 5. First it was launched supporting only a subset of commercial 4G bands ‘ primarily the main US frequencies and the 1.8GHz band, but not the 2.6GHz and 800MHz held by many European operators. And then cellcos in possession of the right spectrum were not always allowed to offer the 4G facility. In recent months, it has emerged that Apple’s vetting of LTE networks is apparently commonplace, and smaller operators complain that it discriminates against them.

An unlikely Apple critic, Tajikistan’s leading operator Babilon-Mobile, told Telecoms.com recently that it had refarmed its 1.8GHz GSM spectrum for LTE in October, but has been unable to activate the new iPhones for that frequency. “There is no information available about activating LTE,” said an executive. “We got no help and no response from Apple on this.” It is widely thought that Apple insists on a network going through its own approval process before the operator is added to its LTE whitelist.

The iPhone 5 talks to a server at Apple, which keeps a list of approved PLMN (public land mobile network) codes and if the code for any given operator is on the whitelist, LTE is activated on devices on that network.

Swisscom was the first cellco to go public with allegations of this practice. It launched LTE at the end of November in the 800MHz, 1.8GHz and 2.6GHz bands. This month, Telenor joined the chorus of disapproval, though this was quickly followed by the news that it had secured 4G support for its iPhone 5 this week.

When it released the iOS 6.1 update at the end of January, Apple announced 36 additional LTE carriers that it now supports, which included Telia and 3 in Denmark, but not cellcos in Norway and Sweden (though TeliaSonera turned on the world’s first LTE network in the latter country back in 2009).

Berit Svendsen, EVP of Telenor Group and CEO at Telenor Norway, had vented frustration about the situation, telling ZDnet: ‘I don’t think there are many operators in Europe that have started to support LTE on the iPhone 5, and we are still waiting for Apple to make some small changes to the iOS so that the phone works on our 1800MHz frequency up in Troms’. They are not ready; we have been asking them for a long time. They have been saying that they are going to fix it, but they haven’t. We asked them half a year ago.’

In future, Apple may have to think twice before pursuing practices which could alienate smaller operators. Dimitris Mavrakis, an analyst at Informa, said in an interview: ‘Apple would not do this to the tier one players. But for smaller operators, or European players with a limited subscriber base, Apple has the audacity to do this and I’m not sure all operators will even make it to the testing phase.’

As Nokia, once famous for its high-handedness to operators, well knows, pride comes before a fall, Apple needs to woo its carriers and developers in future, not alienate them, in order to build its support base to fend off Samsung.