While India’s recent auctions fell apart because operators would not pay the reserve prices, the Czech regulator has suspended its own spectrum sale because cellcos were paying too much.
The agency, CTU, took the action because the bids were going too far above the base price of CZK7.4bn ($377m) for the three bands on offer ‘ 800MHz, 1.8GHz and 2.6GHz, all suitable for LTE. Total bidding rose to CZK20bn before the regulator called a halt. It fears that, if the prices are too high, cellcos will pass on those costs to their customers, which could restrict uptake of 4G services.
‘When announcing the conditions in the first half of last year, we stressed that the main motivation of the auction was the quick availability of a 4G network for Czech citizens and the possible entry of a fourth operator ‘ never about profits for the state,’ CTU chief Pavel Dvorak said in a statement. Dvorak still hopes to sell the licences this year, but will have to restructure the auction.
Four operators were in the running – the local subsidiaries of T-Mobile, Telefonica and Vodafone, as well as PPF, one of the largest private equity firms in the central/eastern Europe region. None would have been allowed to end up with more than 2 x 22.5MHz of spectrum in sub-1GHz bands (800MHz and existing 900MHz combined), while a block in 1.8GHz was reserved for a new entrant. All licence winners would have been required to open up their LTE networks to MVNOs and to launch commercial services within two years.
The turn of events highlights how unpredictable LTE auction results have been in Europe so far. The recent UK sale brought in far less money than expected and came in 30% below the price per MHz/pop in Czech Republic at the point when the regulator pulled the plug (though the UK did not include 1.8GHz). However, last year’s Dutch auction outdid all expectations and delivered a windfall to its treasury.
However, analysts at Analysys Mason questioned whether the Czech regulator may have been hasty in cancelling its sale, arguing that the prices seem reasonable. The consultancy’s senior manager Mark Colville noted that the prices reached at the point where the auction was cancelled equate to about €75 per head of population, or €0.25 per MHz/pop.
He said: ‘These prices are undoubtedly high, but are they excessive? For comparison, the recent UK auction raised around €2.7bn or €0.17/MHz/pop. In contrast, the Netherlands auction of late 2012 raised around €0.63/MHz/pop. This auction included 900MHz spectrum, but the prices paid are considerably higher than those reached in the Czech Republic at the time of cancellation of the auction.’