Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 March 2013

Bharti wins reprieve against ban on 3G services

India’s mobile market continues to be in turmoil. As the fall-out from last year’s failed re-auction of 2G licences continues, now there is a new controversy over roaming.

Bharti Airtel, the country’s largest cellco, has won a reprieve against an order to end its 3G roaming services. After the Department of Telecommunications had ruled that it broke the terms of the 3G licences to offer services where the cellco did not own spectrum, the High Court said Bharti can continue with those plans, at least until May 8.

Bharti had petitioned the High Court, arguing that 30% of its 6.8m 3G customers would be affected if it had to close down the services. Last week, the DoT ordered Bharti to stop offering 3G in seven operating circles where it does not hold spectrum, and where it is relying on roaming deals. No operator won licences in all of India’s 22 operating regions, so national coverage will rely on partnerships with rivals, and some carriers have already come to such agreements despite uncertainties over the legal position.

However, the DoT says these pacts are not roaming, but amount to spectrum sharing or leasing, which is currently not permitted under Indian law. Therefore the DoT had rejected Bharti’s roaming deals with Idea Cellular and Vodafone, and ordered it to pay a fine of INR3.5bn ($65m) as well as suspending the services in Haryana, Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh (East), Kolkata, Gujarat and Kerala.

Bharti, Idea and Vodafone signed their pact in July 2011, allowing their customer to use 3G services in areas where at least one of the operators had a network. In December 2011, the DoT asked the companies to stop the services, ruling that the terms of their 3G licences precluded roaming deals. The three players appealed to the Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal, which initially stayed the ban. Then a two-member bench of the tribunal gave a split verdict in July, but the DoT continued to insist the services must shut down.

Bharti paid $2.3bn for its 3G spectrum and Vodafone around $2.2bn, and they need to build momentum behind the networks ‘ so far only 30m of India’s 600m mobile phone subscribers have upgraded to the 3G.