Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 March 2013

Battle for Dell highlights Microsoft’s post-PC desperation

Significance: Microsoft has agreed to invest $2bn in Dell as part of a proposed buy-out led by founder Michael Dell. That deal is now being challenged by two counter-offers, and the saga has highlighted the problems facing the PC industry. Dell needs to move into enterprise products, having failed in mobile, but Microsoft needs to prop up its partner’s declining PC business to provide a home for Windows. As with its own Surface line, it is increasing its hardware control to fend off the decline of Windows ‘ particularly RT, the most important of the trio of operating systems, because it represents the bid for the ARM-based post-PC sector. However, acrimony with OEMs, including the powerful Samsung, and user confusion over RT’s role, are limiting the new OS’s progress, making Microsoft’s Dell and Surface tactics look desperate.

The future of Dell may not seem keenly pertinent to the mobile industry, given that the PC maker has repeatedly failed to make an impact on the cellular world. But the various options ahead of the firm, and the role of Microsoft, highlight broader issues about the ‘post-PC’ world. It may be that Microsoft and the PC vendors have the biggest hurdles to jump, to succeed once their traditional products converge with those of the mobile specialists. But those companies, too, need to start planning for life after the desktop. Apple may have lost ground to Samsung in smartphones, but it is gaining it back in broader connected device categories, and the rise of tablets, ultrabooks and other form factors could spark another shake-up in the balance of power, as seen after the iPhone’s debut.

Last month, Microsoft announced a plan to invest $2bn in Dell, a loan to support a buy-out plan led by founder and CEO Michael Dell plus Silver Lake Partners. While the logic for Dell is to move towards enterprise and cloud infrastructure, to address the decline of the PC, not towards new devices, Microsoft’s involvement could obstruct that strategy. The software giant’s involvement looks like a rather desperate attempt to ensure a key PC maker does not abandon the ship prematurely, and continues to support Windows 8. Taking a significant stake in Dell fits with Microsoft’s attempts to control its OS platform even more tightly than before, emulating Google in creating an inner circle of close OEMs, and launching its own devices too. Of course, both strategies have caused friction with other hardware makers, but Microsoft has managed to keep Dell (and Hewlett-Packard) loyal amid the chorus of disapproval from other OEM partners, criticizing both the Surface launches and the new Windows operating systems themselves.

So investing in its most loyal partner could certainly be a way to shore up its traditional business, if Microsoft does not yet feel the trio of Windows operating systems (Windows Phone, Windows RT and W8 Pro) are yet able to compete on their own feet against Android, iOS, Chrome OS and the emerging breed of browser-based Linux systems, which span all kinds of devices by centering on HTML5.

For Dell, the Microsoft support might bring a comforting cushion during a difficult transition away from the PC, but it should not allow that to slow it down. Having failed several times in smartphones and tablets, and seeing a decline of the market scale on which its model relies in PCs, it needs to transform its corporate culture as well as its product line. Dell has invested in cloud data center platforms for years, and has the elements in place to major on this business, bringing its execution excellence and its mass market mentality to an enterprise sector which is increasingly commoditizing at the lower level. However, while cloud servers and storage may be becoming volume items, they will never go as far as to suit Dell’s ‘stack ’em high sell ’em cheap’ model, so it needs to undergo a major change of approach, which would be simpler to achieve without Microsoft insisting that the firm retains its PC unit and its Windows 8 activities for longer than necessary.

It probably also needs a change of leadership and indeed, alternative offers to those led by Michael Dell has emerged from Blackstone Group and from the billionaire activist investor Carl Icahn. Both bids would not involve retaining Dell as CEO but could top the $24.4bn Silver Lake proposal ‘ which some shareholders have criticized for being too low, and an attempt by Michael Dell to regain full control of his firm on the cheap. As it is, he owns 15.6% of the shares so will be important in any bid negotiations, but some believe the PC maker needs new thinking at the top, and blame the CEO for not responding quickly or effectively enough to changes in the market. Erik Gordon, a business professor at the University of Michigan, told Bloomberg: ‘Michael is no longer essential to Dell. His attractiveness as a partner to a buyer is the size of his ownership stake. If you are willing to take less than total control, you don’t need him as much.’

Sources say Blackstone invited Michael Dell to use his equity to participate in the transaction, which it describes as a leveraged recapitalization, but not to remain as chief executive. Blackstone’s offer values Dell at more than $14.25 a share, while Icahn would pay $15 a share in cash for as much as 58.1% of the stock. Icahn’s offer assumes that Southeastern Asset Management and T Rowe Price Group, the largest investors after Michael Dell, would contribute their stakes and not receive a cash payment. Under both plans, some shares could continue to be publicly traded. The original $13.65-a-share Silver Lake plan gives Michael Dell majority control, and he claims he is still the best person to push through the schemes to transform Dell into a provider of enterprise products and services. It is not clear whether Microsoft would still offer the loan if the other bids succeed.

Microsoft’s eagerness to prop up Dell is an indicator of its broader crisis ‘ uncertainty over whether it has done enough, with Windows 8, to ensure its platform remains a powerhouse in the post-PC world. Unfortunately, clinging to a favored friend like Dell ‘ but one which is clearly a success story from another era ‘ smacks of desperation. And it sees Microsoft alienating just those partners which are succeeding in the post-PC world, and have the devices and brands to straddle the PC and cellular spaces.

Acer was vocal in condemning Microsoft’s decision to pip its OEMs to the post with the first RT tablets, and Samsung has joined in the criticism. Recently, the Korean giant was reported to be backtracking from Windows Phone, and now Jun Dong-soo, president of the company’s chip division, has hit out at Windows 8, blaming it for some of the woes of the PC space. He told Korea Times: ‘The global PC industry is steadily shrinking despite the launch of Windows 8. I think the Windows 8 system is no better than the previous Windows Vista platform.” He added that the Surface had seen ‘lackluster demand’ and that ultrabooks were failing ‘mostly because of the less competitive Windows platform’.

Asus, Acer and Fujitsu have also publicly criticized Windows 8, leaving HP and Dell as the main loyalists, though HP ‘ like Samsung and Toshiba ‘ has pulled back from supporting RT. Samsung is less important than HP or Dell in the PC market, but of course it has massive influence on the overall post-PC space, with products from desktop to TV to pocket. However, its power is increasingly built on non-Windows platforms, such as Android and its own Tizen, and it is gaining in confidence in creating its own distinctive user experiences. The de-Googled nature of the new Galaxy S4 may have concerned the search giant, but there isn’t much it can do without compromising Android’s open source identity. By contrast, Microsoft has full control of its platform, but if Samsung cannot run its own user interfaces on top of Windows Phone and Windows RT, it is unlikely to show much enthusiasm.

Microsoft can weather the anger of OEMs about the new competition from its Surface launches, but only if those partners see that Windows 8 is too successful to ignore. It is far from clear that this is the case. Windows 8 Pro has no realistic challengers in the traditional PC space, but that is on the start of its long decline. Its biggest attempt at a post-PC success story has been the Intel-backed ultrabook design, but this form factor has so far been squeezed between tablets and the emergence of low cost cloudbooks, notably Google’s Chromebook. The Chromebook, especially in its new touch-based Pixel iteration, has had a slow start too, but it represents a viable alternative to the notebook for those who can achieve constant connectivity, and the first time Wintel has really been under pressure in the laptop-like form factor and target market.

Windows RT has the biggest challenges because it is coming in as the outsider, trying to take on Android, iOS, Chrome and others in all kinds of hybrid PC/mobile devices. That has been tough so far because the dominant form factor in this converged space is the tablet, led and heavily defined by Apple. That may give way to other device types or evolved tablet experiences, and perhaps Microsoft will be able to seize the reins from Apple in steering those, but Surface has certainly not achieved that yet. As the highest profile vehicle for RT, Surface is being closely watched, and often heavily criticized.

Some are even calling on Microsoft to abandon RT altogether (and there are strong indications it will be merged back into the main OS in the next generation release, codenamed Blue). Last week, Microsoft’s corporate VP of Windows planning, hardware and PC ecosystem, Michael Angiulo, defended the ARM-based OS. In an interview with CNet he said: “It was a ton of work for us and we didn’t do the work and endure the disruption for any reason other than the fact that there’s a strategy there that just gets stronger over time.’ He said the ARM architecture had enabled a Windows product to be competitive with an iPad in power consumption terms and added: “People are talking about legacy desktop software not running, but they don’t think about the customer benefit of only running modern apps. The only apps that you install from the Windows store are the kind, that as a customer, you can manage your rights to.’

However, many of the benefits of RT are shared by Android and iOS, so like Windows Phone, it needs to appeal to users on the basis of its user experience and apps, since it does not support legacy Windows products. And that is a tough job, especially without major OEMs like Acer and HP to help. IDC predicts that RT will have less than 2% of tablet market share this year and only 2.7% by 2017. Alex Gauna, an analyst at JMP Securities, told Bloomberg: “It’s pretty clear that things were bad entering the year, and at least for the moment they’re getting worse. The path to a successful Surface, in the same way that they were successful with Xbox, is not very clear to me right now.”

And then there is Windows Phone. Microsoft needs to accelerate moves to converge this with Windows RT, not just to ease the lives of developers and support multiscreen usage, but to prevent WP becoming an orphan, confined to a niche in a handset world where there is limited high margin growth.

Microsoft’s next bold move to keep Windows relevant from server to handset in the post-PC world will come with ‘Blue’, a broad reimagining of its various platforms ‘ not just the main OS but Windows Server, Windows Phone, Windows Services and Office. As well as a series of OS updates, Blue is a new approach to building and delivering OSs and applications, with a stream of changes rather than periodic massive upgrades (Windows Server will reduce its cycle from three years to one year for instance). The developer base and Metro user interface will become more unified, and in the case of Office, there will be more support for non-Microsoft platforms like Android and iOS at the front end, supported by Office365 at the back. The UI will focus on personalization ‘ customized tiles and so on ‘ a hallmark of Windows Phone 8.

Blue is about more than product refresh ‘ its real agenda is about turning Microsoft into a devices and services company. VP of corporate communications Frank Shaw wrote in a corporate blog post: “Our product groups are also taking a unified planning approach so people get what they want ‘ all of their devices, apps and services working together wherever they are and for whatever they are doing,” Shaw noted.

It seems that there will be a first preview build of the core Windows Blue OS in late June, and it could be released to manufacturing by August this year. Other Blue products, including Windows Phone and several variants of Windows Server, will come later.

So far, Blue is short on details, and much of the discussion has been speculative ‘ notably that it will kill off the Windows desktop and move business apps to the cloud, which would be a hugely symbolic nail in the traditional PC’s coffin (though we must not forget how slowly the PC will die ‘ there are 4m desktop programs for Windows 7, and one of W8 Pro’s big selling points is the backwards compatibility which RT lacks. Eliminating the desktop and all the enterprise custom apps that run on it will be the work of more than one OS update).

Whether Blue moves away from the Windows desktop altogether or not, this is clearly not the key battlefield any more. Browser interfaces to cloud services, touch-based apps and creative user interfaces are the key and to be fair, Windows Phone and Windows RT have many of those qualities ‘ but so do their rivals, and Microsoft is coming from behind. If Google does bring Android application downloads to Chrome’s think client experience, as suggested by the touch-based Chromebook Pixel, that could be a killer threat to Windows in the post-PC landscape.

Fortunately for Microsoft, it seems that convergence is not immediately on the cards. Google’s executive chairman Eric Schmidt told Google’s recent Big Tent event in India that the two operating systems will remain separate. There has been intense speculation that the search giant would unite its two platforms soon since Android chief Andy Rubin moved out of that role, bringing the mobile OS under Sundar Pichai, who also runs Chrome.

There is plenty of logic to bringing the two systems together, uniting the current download/native model dominant on smartphones, with the emerging cloud/browser approach epitomized by Chrome. That could be a powerful way to fend off new challengers like Firefox Mobile and make iOS look old-fashioned and Windows irrelevant. But despite all these indications, Schmidt insists that, though there will be more ‘commonality’ between the two operating systems going forward, they will remain separate products. Microsoft must pray that his thinking is shared by the rest of the company, and that Pichai will keep his two children apart for some while to come.