Significance: T-Mobile USA took a bold step to differentiate itself from its rivals, having come to market well behind its main rivals both in LTE and an iPhone launch. Despite being behind the pack, it has drawn attention to itself by proclaiming a break with contracts and subsidies and offering unlimited data plans to customers who bring their own devices. It is more likely that most users will not pay upfront for expensive smartphones, but will take advantage of TMo’s financing schemes for handsets such as the iPhone 5, which the operator will launch next month. This is the kind of move which, while portrayed as a break with subsidies and therefore a blow to Apple’s profit model, many actually provide the iOS vendor with a helpful way to navigate the prepaid segments, especially in emerging economies. It is under pressure to develop a low cost iPhone for these bases, but that risks damaging its brand value. An alternative will be for Apple to offer financing ‘ as it does in China ‘ but the TMo approach sees the burden, as well as the customer tie-in, passing to the carrier.
T-Mobile hasn’t done anything fundamentally new with its ‘Uncarrier’ announcements this week. Customers who don’t want to pay the full cost of a device upfront will still be locked into the carrier, even if this is via a financing deal rather than a subsidy. Other operators round the world have already reduced their reliance on subsidized smartphones, introduced instalment plans, and other changes introduced this week by the US’s fourth cellco. But TMo’s changes hit the headlines, partly because of the markets’ interest in the US market, but also because they coincided with the cellco’s first launch of an iPhone. This threw into sharp perspective some of the lurking questions about how Apple will adapt to the slow but steady rise of a breed of carrier with no intention of bowing to its traditional demands. Subsidy-free markets are tough for Apple, whose deals with cellcos and consumers are coming under increasing scrutiny. In fact, though, TMo may have thrown it a lifeline, providing a way for contract-free users to pay for an iPhone, but without Apple having to create a cheap model, potentially damaging its brand.
Apple has famously been accustomed to getting its own way when negotiating deals with carriers. These may have been watered down since the initial agreement with AT&T, in which the US cellco handed Apple an incredible pile of concessions in return for the market-changing exclusive, but operators still agree to minimum sales targets and high handset costs, which they then have to subsidize.
TMo is just the latest to change the rules a little with regard to Apple. Some operators like US Cellular have refused to carry the handset because, as its CEO said a couple of years ago, the contract terms were ‘unacceptable’. More concerning for the vendor, it has repeatedly failed to get an iPhone to China Mobile, partly because, according to the huge cellco, the terms of a deal would not fit with its business case.
The toughest element of iPhone contracts, especially for smaller players, is the inclusion of sales quotas, which make any unsold units the responsibility of the operator, according to the report. Leap Wireless recently revealed in a filing that it is likely to have met only 50% of its iPhone sales commitment when its annual contract ends in June, leaving it with a bill for about $100m worth of unsold devices, according to The Wall Street Journal. Most famously, Sprint committed to huge targets in its 2011, five-year agreement with Apple, which reportedly sets a level of 30.5m iPhones.
Greater competition to the iPhone, and cellcos’ weariness of the impact of high subsidies on their profits, will force Apple to take a softer line in future, and so may regulatory authorities. The European Union’s antitrust authorities are to scrutinize the terms imposed on iPhone carriers in case they restrict competition. No formal complaints have been filed by Apple rivals ‘ usually the sparking point for EU investigations ‘ but a group of European operators has submitted details of the Apple deals to the European Commission, the EU’s executive body, an unnamed source told The New York Times.
The EC confirmed that it was examining the deals but said that it had not begun an official antitrust investigation. “We have been contacted by industry participants and we are monitoring the situation, but no antitrust case has been opened,” a spokesman for Joaqu’n Almunia, EU competition commissioner, told the NYT. It seems that French operators, already suffering their worst price war ever since the entry of fourth player Free Mobile, have initiated the action. The report says the probes centered initially on French carriers but cellcos in other countries may be involved also, and would almost certainly be asked for information.
An Apple representative told the NYT that the company’s “contracts fully comply with local laws wherever we do business’.
The bigger issues for Apple concern how to adjust its model when it is in markets where carriers are rethinking contracts, like TMo; offering ‘bucket deals’ where a data plan is shared between several connected products, some of which could be iDevices; or entirely prepaid, like most major emerging economies such as India. There has, of course, been much talk recently of a low cost iPhone for prepaid markets where only a tiny percentage of the population could pay for an iPhone upfront ‘ but to make such a product profitable could involve compromises in quality that would affect the overall brand.
In that respect, carriers’ transformation into financing houses for devices could rescue Apple from some of its dilemmas in important growth markets, allowing more people to afford an iPhone without having to release a significantly cheaper one. Apple itself has even taken steps into providing financing to encourage uptake of fully fledged iDevices, in countries like Brazil, China and Singapore.
In China, it offers instalment payments on iPhones and iPads. From the start of this year, it has allowed customers to pay CNY300 ($48) or more upfront and then spread the rest of the cost over 12 months interest-free. For longer payment terms, interest charges will apply ‘ 6.5% for 18 months and 8.5% for 24 months. The plans are supported by the Merchants Bank credit card provider. Such strategies could be powerful in a country where the iPhone 5’s prices start at CNY5288 ($850) ‘ equivalent to about six weeks’ pay for the average urban worker – and the iPad at CNY3688. Apple’s operator partners, China Unicom and China Telecom, do subsidize the iPhone for contract users, but the majority of users are on prepaid deals.
Financing is a way for operators to keep customers tied to their apron strings, and add a new element to their changing role in the mobile value chain. They may even compete with Apple to offer the best deals ‘ T-Mobile’s iPhone plan undercuts the price of buying from the vendor itself, for instance. More broadly, financing is a central part of TMo’s ‘Uncarrier’ strategy, unveiled after much build-up this week, and there is particular focus on how that will affect TMo’s iPhone sales when it launches the handset next month.
With the new deals, TMo is making the break with subsidies and contracts, though it is still locking in those customers who do not want to pay the full price of a smartphone upfront. Under the ‘Simple Choice’plan, they will be able to pay for their device in instalments ‘ in the case of the iPhone, the product could be purchased for $99.99 plus monthly payments of $20 for two years. That totals $579, still a saving on the $650 full retail price. The iPhone 5 sells at the postpaid carriers for $199, but the operators claw back the subsidy with extra data charges during the life of a two-year contract.
T-Mobile USA’s CEO John Legere said: “This is an important day for people who love their iPhone but can’t stand the pain other carriers put them through to own one.’ The operator, which has famously lacked an Apple handset until now, finally has its 3G and 4G networks in bands supported by the iconic device. The iPhone 5 will launch at TMo on April 12.
Under the T-Mobile plan, the Samsung Galaxy Note II would cost about $680 total upfront or $20 a month for two years with a $200 down payment. At AT&T, that handset is about $300 with a two-year contract.
The cellco also unveiled a tariff including unlimited talk, text and web with 500Mbytes of data for $50, including a second phone line for $30 and each additional line for $10. Customers can also add 2Gbytes of data for $10 a month per line.
T-Mobile’s plans do generally work out more cheaply than its rivals’ and there is the flexibility to pay off the cost of the phone early and get a lower monthly bill. Customers can also bring over unlocked handsets, or those from AT&T, and the survival of unlimited data plans ‘ which are being phased out at Verizon and AT&T ‘ will be attractive to many. A calculation by Associated Press finds that a 16Gbytes iPhone 5 with unlimited calling and SMS, and 2.5Gbytes of data per month, works out at $2,020 over two years. At Verizon and AT&T, which have more LTE coverage and reliability, the same phone with unlimited calls and texts, and 2Gbytes to 3Gbytes of data per month, totals $2,635. Sprint still offers unlimited data as well as calls and text, but its iPhone 5 costs the most over two years, at $2,840, and it has limited LTE coverage.
The changes see TMo trying to win back customers after losing more than 4m lucrative postpaid subscribers over the past two years to its rivals. Although not unique, they are innovative in the US, helping to differentiate TMo’s offerings in the eyes of consumers. This is particularly important for the iPhone launch. This could have gone barely noticed, coming long after its rivals’ Apple launches, and in a market where even small cellcos now have the iconic handset. But the attention the Uncarrier strategy has gained – and the prospect of combining low upfront device costs with affordable data plans ‘ will help TMo stand out from the crowd, as well as helping Apple by bringing the iPhone to a prepaid base where the device generally does not shine because of its cost. One analyst, Shaw Wu of Sterne Agee, believes the deal will be a ‘big win’ for Apple and help it gain incremental customers in the saturated US. In a client note, he wrote: “We believe this will help AAPL capture incremental customers and strengthen its position against Google’s Android, which got its start on T-Mobile USA.”
They will also cushion TMo from handset subsidy bills. It is in a less risky position to make these changes than AT&T and Verizon because it relies so heavily on the prepaid, unsubsidized market already ‘ and that balance will increase if it completes its merger with prepaid-only regional operator MetroPCS. However, if that gains shareholder approval next month, the combined entity will become a publicly traded company, stepping up the pressure on TMo to reverse subscriber declines and boost profits.
However, Uncarrier should not be confused with a real break with lock-ins. The complete break with subsidies, forcing users to buy or bring their own devices, has been attempted by a few operators round the world, notably in Spain, but at the cost of a sharp drop, at least in the short term, in postpaid sign-ups. These operators know that customer behavior may change over time, and users are getting wise to the hidden costs of the ‘free smartphone’, but in times of low consumer credit, the subsidy is still an alluring thing.
For many users, TMo’s offer will seem like swapping one tie-in for another, with little financial gain. When Optus of Australia said this week it was considering plans similar to T-Mobile’s, the country’s Communications Consumer Action Network told ZDnet that they really only amounted to clever marketing. Spokesperson Elise Davidson echoed the reactions of many round the world, saying: “These new T-mobile plans are essentially the same as locking a customer into a postpaid contract as the handset is paid off over two years. If you choose to switch from T-mobile during that two years, you have to pay for the handset anyway, which is more or less the same as a break-contract fee. We wish this were the solution to those who want prepaid prices and flexibility and the latest smartphone, but, unfortunately, it’s just another iteration of the ‘confusopoly’ that is telecommunications marketing.”