A tale of two carriers ‘ moves by Deutsche Telekom and Saudi Telecom illustrate contrasting approaches to the dilemma of how cellcos should deal with over-the-top suppliers.
The German giant has signed a deal with popular web productivity tool provider Evernote to offer the service as added value for its customers. Rather than fighting against web providers, or trying to outdo them with initiatives like RCS (Rich Communications Services), the operator is embracing a well recognized internet brand to enhance the appeal of its own services. Users get free access to the $45-a-year premium version of Evernote as part of their mobile or wireline contract.
This shows how carriers are looking to provide services, at last, as the way to offset voice decline and avoid being dumb pipes. Rather than Evernote going completely over-the-top, it will be tied into the DT offering ‘ an approach which is becoming increasingly common since it was pioneered several years ago by the likes of Hutchison 3. DT itself recently announced a similar deal with music streaming app Spotify while Orange has one with a French equivalent, Deezer. Evernote also has agreements with Taiwan Mobile, Orange France and NTT Docomo. In India, Aircel says data usage has increased by 25% in areas where it has partnered with free messaging app Nimbuzz, while Facebook has signed deals with Airtel and Reliance, and WhatsApp also has a relationship with Reliance.
‘In 2012, operators were essentially fighting the rising popularity of free messaging apps, but towards the end of the year they realized that they cannot compete so they might as well tie up and offer subscription packages,’ Ovum analyst Neha Dharia told The Economic Times.
Lyn Cantor, CEO of Tektronix Communications, commented: ‘Operators need to leverage their data assets. Doing nothing is not an option. Smarter subscribers want OTT services. Deutsche Telecom’s new deal with Evernote is a prime example of how telecoms operators can position themselves to actively exploit the OTT opportunity, showing how they can wrest the initiative from OTT players and monetise the services they have.
By complete contrast, in Saudi Arabia, telcos are accused of being behind government demands to restrict over-the-top messaging applications. The country’s authorities are demanding censorship rights to Skype, Viber, WhatsApp and similar services. The apps face being banned in the country, an action that could spark similar action elsewhere in the region. According to regulator sources, local telcos have been told to request a means of control from providers of the OTT services.
Another source at incumbent operator Saudi Telecom (STC) told local reporters that telcos had only been given until this Saturday to respond, and that failure to comply could result in a ban. However, some critics accused the operators ‘ STC, Mobily and Zain ‘ of being behind the move, because of the damage to their revenues from OTT services. And Ahmed Omran, a Saudi blogger who runs the Riyadh Bureau website, said telcos may risk the anger of customers, who use Skype heavily to keep in touch with friends and family, to reduce loss of voice and text revenues.
In neighboring United Arab Emirates, most Skype applications and Viber are already blocked but WhatsApp messenger remains accessible. Both countries threatened to ban BlackBerry instant messaging in 2010 and demanded local servers to censor the service, a request also made in India, Indonesia and elsewhere. The BlackBerry services remain intact though it has never been clear what concessions their Canadian vendor was forced to make.