Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 March 2013

Apple pushes for new Samsung trial; Microsoft scores against Google

Apple CEO Tim Cook was making conciliatory noises about the patent wars last fall, but now the company has gone hardline again, seeking yet another trial in its interminable battle with Samsung. Apple has asked for a new trial which would derail its rival’s bid to win an appeal against the previous landmark case in San Jose, California.

That trial, the most significant of the score of proceedings between the two firms in various countries, ended with a jury awarding $1.05bn in damages to Apple. However, Judge Lucy Koh reduced that amount by $450.5m, saying the jury had set the amount based on faulty understanding of the legal and IPR issues involved. She left the door open for both companies to appeal her ruling. Samsung wants the case to be put on hold and Apple thinks an appeals court case would ‘”likely lead to a remand without a substantive decision’.

Instead, it wants a new trial with a new jury and has added some new items. For instance, it has filed a motion to show that Samsung sold two products within the period permissible for design infringement, contrary to Koh’s original findings. If those claims, which relate to the Galaxy S II AT&T and Infuse 4G, are correct, that could add tens of millions of dollars to the original damages award, potentially reaching a total of $685m, according to patents expert Florian Mueller of FOSS Patents.

Apple is also requesting that, if Koh wants to put the combatants through the appeals process before a new trial takes place, she should consider reinstating this compensation.

Of course, the real issue for Apple is not the money but the ability to hurt Samsung’s sales by creating uncertainty around key devices and even achieving sales bans in key markets ‘ though most of those, where awarded (mainly in some European countries and in Australia) have been reversed or have applied to products which are already outdated.

In another long running dispute, Microsoft has won an important patent victory against Google’s Motorola Mobility unit, with the US International Trade Commission ruling that Xbox does not violate Motorola IPR.

The Google unit has been the only major handset maker to resist licensing the patents Microsoft holds in Android, leading to court action, and has also hurled its own lawsuits at the Windows giant, attacking key products like Windows, Exchange and Xbox on both sides of the Atlantic.

ITC Judge David Shaw took Microsoft’s side, though his preliminary judgement will be subject to review by a full panel of the six-member body. If that panel confirms his opinion, the ITC has the power to impose injunctions against offending products.

The patent at issue concerns a way to establish communication between the Xbox and accessories. It is the only item left standing in a case that originally included five patents, including two related to H.264 and video encoding. That led to accusations by Microsoft and regulators that Motorola Mobility was using standards-essential IPR to compete unfairly.

Motorola dropped the two decoding patents from the case after Google reached an agreement with the US Federal Trade Commission in January, regarding how it handles standards-essential IPR. The other two that were dropped expire this year.

‘We are pleased with the Administrative Law Judge’s finding that Microsoft did not violate Motorola’s patent and are confident that this determination will be affirmed by the Commission,’ David Howard, Microsoft’s deputy general counsel, said in a statement.

Google can petition the ITC to overrule the judge’s findings and impose an import ban.
‘We are disappointed with today’s determination and look forward to the full Commission’s review,’ the search giant said in a statement.

Motorola Mobility, then an independent company, filed the ITC complaint in November 2010. Microsoft has previously won an exclusion order against Motorola phones using ActiveSync.