Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 April 2013

Nokia risks missing large-screen boat as device sizes proliferate

The range of shapes and sizes of mobile devices is becoming bewildering, as Samsung prepares to add 5.8-inch and 6.3-inch phablets to its range, slotting between a 7-inch tablet and a smartphone of around 5-inches. Meanwhile Microsoft may join the 7-inch tablet game and Google, Amazon and others are said to be planning products of the iPad mini’s size (7.9-inches). As smartphones and tablets collide in the space between 5-inches and 7-inches, the high end mobile devices are gaining sufficient volume to justify vendors investing in many variants and price points ‘ that is, the vendors which have the scale and supply chain control to do this.

This is another area where Samsung can shine ‘ it has unparalleled ability to turn out large numbers of device variations without, these days, blurring its brand recognition. As the tablet moves away from just two or three standard sizes to a huge array of choices, the Korean vendor will gain yet another advantage, particularly over Nokia, once itself the king of the mobile supply chain, but now risking missing the large-screen boat altogether.

Nokia’s days of spotting what phone users wanted before they knew it themselves are long over. The Finnish firm has missed a string of key developments in handset design, from clamshells to touchscreens themselves, and the latest is the large 5-inch display for handsets, not to mention anything larger. Growth at the mobile high end lies in tablets and in handsets of 5-inches or above, as well as phablets ‘ all purchases geared to easier web viewing on larger displays. But Nokia remains outside these categories, restricting growth potential for its Lumia line among high value customers.

‘This is a trend that can’t be missed,’ Francisco Jeronimo, an analyst at IDC, told Bloomberg. ‘People are using smartphones in different ways now, consuming media by streaming over faster mobile networks. A 5-inch screen for a smartphone just feels right in the hand.’ Sales of handsets of 5-inches or above rose to 29.7m units last year from 1.2m in 2011, according to IDC, while 4-inch devices are seeing their margins squeezed as they shift to the midmarket.

Nokia has been reported to be readying a tablet and/or large-screen smartphone for months now, but nothing materialized at its usual launchpad, Mobile World Congress. A Nokia spokesman said that the company was still assessing consumer interest in such devices. One issue has reportedly been the launch of Microsoft’s own Surface tablet, which would compete with Nokia’s own Windows devices.

As well as monitoring the performance of Surface ‘ lacklustre so far ‘ Nokia will be keen not to run into head-on conflict with its main partner. Also, since Windows Phone is confined to smaller screens, it would have to support a second Windows OS, RT, in order to launch a tablet ‘ a more complex move than for Apple or Android OEMs, which have the same OS for tablets as for handsets. Nokia has hinted it could adopt a different OS for future slate launches, but in reality, this looks unlikely, at least until some medium term date when it could choose one of the emerging browser-oriented platforms like Firefox Mobile. The benchmark is for a larger screen and Nokia isn’t there yet,’ said Ben Wood of CCS Insight. ‘Nokia needs to make sure they don’t miss the boat.’

Meanwhile, Nokia’s partner Microsoft has no such qualms about the tablet space, though it has so far stopped short of launching a smartphone ‘ perhaps partly to preserve the Nokia alliance. The Windows giant is said to be planning a 7-inch model to join its Windows 8 Surface range, to pitch against the iPad mini, Google Nexus and Amazon Kindle Fire, sources say.

The Wall Street Journal’s contacts said the smaller version of the Windows RT slate would go into production later this year and be ready well in time for the holiday buying season. Like Apple before it, Microsoft had not intended to include a smaller tablet in its strategy, the sources said, but had realized that the form factor was gathering pace and it needed to have an offering to compete with Nexus and others. According to IDC, half the tablets which shipped in the last quarter of 2012 were under 8-inches (most are 7-inches but the iPad mini is 7.9-inches), and DisplaySearch believes smaller slates will be the biggest category this year. Sources say Apple had planned to sell 40m iPad minis and 60m 9.7-inch iPads in 2013, but has now revised its forecasts to 55m minis and 33m larger models.

Also like its arch-rivals ‘ and other Android majors like Samsung ‘ a smaller device gives Microsoft the flexibility to appeal to the mass market with a cheaper product which is also likely to cut some corners on components, in order to reduce cost.

Microsoft’s intentions were signalled last month when it said it would relax the minimum resolution for Windows 8 devices ‘ to gain W8 certification, a device must now support at least 1024 x 768 pixels, down from the previous floor of 1366 x 768.

Samsung’s own new size variants come under the Mega label, and are in 5.8-inch and 6.3-inch versions, both running Android Jelly Bean on a dual-core processor. The larger option runs at 1.7GHz and the smaller one has a 1.4GHz chip. They will launch in Europe in May but other markets have not been confirmed.

It is becoming increasingly urgent for phonemakers to succeed in high end devices and new form factors, since the profits are disappearing from conventional smartphones ‘ hence the concerns for Nokia. The segment has hit the peak of its profit potential, and price squeezes will be the pattern of the future, says analyst Peter Misek of Jefferies, who believes overall profitability hit its apex in 2012. Market saturation and a lack of differentiation among high end models will drive down prices, even of the next iPhone (Apple takes home the lion’s share of profits in the smartphone segment).

Apple faces higher competition than ever before and will be forced to reduce average prices as it seeks to broaden the iPhone’s availability still further. Misek estimates that the handset is currently available to about two-thirds of the world’s mobile subscribers, but Apple will expand that reach. He says in his report: “This summer we believe Apple will add China Mobile (710m total subs; 88m 3G subs) and NTT Docomo (62m subs). While this raises Apple’s served market to 76%, we note that 88% of China Mobile’s subs are still on 2G.’

Driving down prices, or releasing a cheaper iPhone ‘ as many believe will be necessary to target emerging economies more effectively ‘ could weaken Apple’s premium brand just as the glossy brand image is becoming somewhat less shiny anyway. Misek says a Jefferies survey recently found that the company’s customer satisfaction rating was identical to that of arch-rival Samsung for the first time.

In the key Chinese market, Apple managed to come third in the smartphone space last year, despite the lack of a China Mobile deal, but as the smartphone population in the country grows, it risks losing out to local or lower cost brands, or those with a wider range of models and price points. Currently, Samsung is the market leader followed by Lenovo, while Apple is followed by Huawei and the midrange specialist Coolpad. Chinese vendors like Coolpad and Xiaomi are also starting to make an impact in another key market for future smartphone growth, India, where local brands are also moving from featurephones to higher end devices.

Overall, Misek thinks iPhone profitability will fall in 2013, and though there may be a rebound in 2014, it will not get back to 2012 levels again. “As the most profitable smartphone OEM we also believe this means that global smartphone profits likely have peaked,” he added.

That will push it towards the much vaunted affordable iPhone. Apple is used to being told it needs a cheaper iPhone to expand its presence in emerging markets, but now the same calls are coming from Europe. France Telecom’s CEO, Stephane Richard, said in an interview that the smartphone was becoming too expensive for the bulk of consumers in the current economic crisis.

“Customers are more focused on price,” Richard told Bloomberg. “Except for a few hundred thousand people who will buy the latest iPhone – except for that category of people – the majority of the market will be difficult.”

He said that the average European consumer was becoming far more price sensitive when it comes to mobile devices and contracts, keeping the same handsets for longer and shopping around for carrier deals.

This is partly because of the eurozone recession, but also because there are more alternatives (good looking Android handsets squeeze Apple, and of course, France Telecom Orange has suffered its own new challenger in the form of French low cost operator Free Mobile).

“We are in a period of changing consumer behavior,” Richard said. “There are fewer early adopters, and probably with the next release of the iPhone this will be evident. Selling a phone for $600 is getting more and more difficult.”