Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 April 2013

Wi-Fi coming of age for home automation

The battle for ownership of the home has been raging for almost two decades within the pay-TV and telco sectors, but until recently as separate silos with only limited in-home connectivity. Now it is all joining up to bring the battle to a new intensity, with the prize for the winners being control of the burgeoning smart home market. This will include automation with control of connected devices ranging from heating systems to security cameras as well as small embedded systems, but also in time extend into remote healthcare, which is likely to be a huge business.

Despite efforts by some telcos like Deutsche Telekom and TeliaSonera to drag set-top box functionality into the cloud, this smart home market is likely to be controlled by a fat gateway. This will work in tandem with the cloud, or perhaps several clouds, but the gateway will be needed to control local communications within the home network, which will vary between households and crucially require local servers to mediate with low powered devices.

This raises firstly two question – who will control the gateway, and will this really confer full ownership of the digital home? Both questions have yet to be settled and it is not certain that ownership of the first will lead to full control of the digital home. Automation will, after all, bring in new players such as security companies, energy utilities and healthcare agencies, that may have their own ideas and want to plant dedicated boxes within the home that in turn may communicate with the gateway, but not be dependent on it. Alternatively broadband providers may collaborate with these agencies to provide the service and therefore derive revenue from them indirectly.

However it works out, the provider of the gateway and broadband connection to it will be well placed to be more than just the dumb pipe because all these services from HDTV to low bandwidth M2M (Machine to Machine) communications have very different quality of service (QoS) needs. Video conferencing will require guaranteed bandwidth with perhaps some scope for variation, but absolutely zero tolerance of excessive latency. For M2M applications the main elements of QoS will be low demand for electrical or computational power, or memory. But the gateway will be the place to ensure that all services receive the optimum QoS within the overall bandwidth budget and that devices are configured correctly, at least at the physical level.

This plays into the debate over smart home technologies, where some consensus is emerging both at the level of physical communications as well as higher level configuration and interaction. For wired communications, MoCA and HomePlug are the likely winners, but as nearly all the devices will be wireless the greater significance lies over the protocols there. At one time it looked certain that the future digital home would require at least two wireless protocols and possibly three to meet the conflicting requirements of different services. Wi-Fi of course was the winner for broadband data and TV with its high capacity once we retrofit QoS capability, but other lighter protocols have been designed specifically for signaling for home control applications, consuming much less bandwidth but in turn requiring lower power consumption.

Of these the two main contenders are Zigbee and Zwave. ZigBee was conceived as an alternative to Wi-Fi and Bluetooth (which was designed more as an alternative to infrared for very short range communications) in the late 1990s for self-organizing networks, avoiding the need to designate a single point of control, as well as having low power requirements. ZigBee operates in the 2.4GHz range, although with the option of sub-1GHz operation, with a range of 70 meters indoors and up to 400 meters outdoors, depending on conditions. It has already been deployed in a number of home automation products such as centralized lighting control systems.

Z-Wave was conceived at a similar time by Zen-Sys, founded in 1999 and then setting up the Z-Wave Alliance in 2005, before being acquired by Sigma Designs in 2008. It operates only in the 900MHz spectrum and unlike ZigBee is seen as a proprietary standard not enshrined by one of the industry standards bodies, but has gained ground with Sigma’s strong backing and implementation in its chips. Sigma has just launched its ‘Z-Wave Next Gen’ portfolio, aimed both at service providers and also original equipment makers (OEMs) looking to develop home control products and services. Here we mean OEMs in the sense of manufacturers incorporating products made by others, in this case Sigma, in their systems, rather than the old and opposite definition of being a supplier of sub systems. This platform comprises Z-Wave middleware for home control, a customizable user interface, a reference design called ZIPR to handle translation between Z-Wave, IP and the Z-Wave mesh network, and the Z/IP Gateway to transform IP commands to Z-Wave.

This highlights the main difference between the two, which are fundamentally quite similar except for the operating frequencies, both operating in mesh configurations rather than point to multipoint. Z-Wave is more highly integrated, but is confined to Sigma based products. Members of the Z Wave alliance are mostly either security companies such as ADT, or makers of control systems like 2GIG Technologies formed by ex-Honeywell employees, although there are also some makers of the end products being controlled, such as roof window company Fakro.

There is a growing chance that these efforts will be swept aside by the ever strengthening Wi-Fi tide, and this will help the cause of incumbent broadband operators that already provide Wi-Fi routers, giving them the opportunity to get in there and exert control of the home network. Of course they could engage devices which speak to say a Z-Wave network and speak to the outside world through Wi-Fi, but the control amounts to the same.

Wi-Fi has expanded on the two main fronts, both upwards in terms of QoS and coverage and more recently downwards to support low power applications. It is still evolving on both these fronts, with 802.11ac coming along to provide high throughout in the upper 5GHz band, hitherto less used than the 2.4GHz band. This will enable a maximum single link throughput of at least 500Mbps by using wider RF bandwidth of 80MHz or 160MHz as well as doubling the number of MIMO streams that can be supported to eight.

The very latest emerging standard, 802.11ad or WiGig, goes right up to 60GHz and increases modulation bandwidth 100 times to achieve a theoretical maximum throughput of up to 7Gbps. This brings even greater challenges for guaranteeing QoS, but these are addressed in large part through a combination of new beam forming technology and the ability to switch seamlessly between the three bands, 2.4GHz, 5GHz and 60GHz, to maintain communications when interference or fading causes signals in one to be lost temporarily.

The recent expansion by Wi-Fi in the other direction leading to its increased use for home automation has been driven by the fact that most existing IP connected devices in the home, including increasingly TVs as well as PCs, come already Wi-Fi enabled, accentuated by the proliferation of smartphones and tablets. The latter means that users now have a mobile device that can readily become a portable controller not just of the TV but of all connected devices in the home, which is a trend we are already seeing.

Now that Wi-Fi is almost ubiquitous in home devices one of the objections to using it for home automation, which was relatively high cost, has been eroded. It has huge economies of scale and is now effectively free for companies deploying home automation systems, as it is embedded into the devices. However power consumption within the remote devices themselves is still a major stumbling block, as to some extent is reliability over the full range of the network for small devices.

But the IEEE 802.11 Group is now working on a completely new version of Wi-Fi, 802.11ah, optimized specifically for low power home automation devices and the Internet of Things, operating below 1GHz. This means that when 802.11ah is ratified, expected around May 2015, Wi-Fi will have expanded into four frequency bands, from the initial two with only one being widely used. It will also mean Wi-Fi will overlap with Zigbee and Z-Wave in function, raising the question of why to bother deploying them as well.

Apart from reducing power consumption, 802.11ah addresses the QoS question for home automation by ensuring guaranteed access to bandwidth for short burst low bit rate data transmissions, such as meter data. It is a common misconception that QoS is only an issue for high bit rate real time video, for without special provision the multitude of signaling and metering data could get squeezed out. Even a low bit rate application needs to be sure of access to the network although precise timing may not be important. The function of 801.11ah will be to ensure that home automation applications get access to the network in a reasonably timely manner without jeopardizing the QoS for the bandwidth hungry HDTV content being consumed on second TVs and mobile devices.

Qualcomm, the world’s largest maker of chips for mobile devices, has decided home automation is so important it will not wait for 802.11ah and that in any case further optimization is required to accommodate sensors, control systems and all the devices that will be communicating at low bandwidth but often frequently. We discussed last week how Qualcomm has launched its Streamboost software to administer QoS for a large number of applications. This requires identifying the different activities on the home network so that it can apply policies to allocate bandwidth to each as required. This can be done by DPI (deep packet inspection), but the computation required would make this prohibitively expensive to execute quickly enough in a home router.

So instead Qualcomm’s detection engine examines packet attributes within two second snatches of traffic to sift out the different processes, to decide how many MHz of bandwidth each one requires. It then uses a stacking process to accommodate all services within the bandwidth limit, typically around 10Mbps in practice, which could include a couple of HD movies, and SD channel, one or two YouTube videos, a Skype session and a game.

All this though only really addresses the network-level side, while home automation also involves functions higher up the stack. The crucial ability to conserve power and operate with the minimum of hardware resources depends on efficient higher level interaction among connected devices. This is where the IETF’s (Internet Engineering Task Force) emerging Constrained Application Protocol (CoAP) comes in, aiming to replace HTTP for small devices connected to the Internet, especially via Wi-Fi.

Still under development it is an application layer protocol for small low power sensors, switches, valves and similar components or M2M devices that need to be controlled or supervised remotely, but which cannot have much onboard CPU or memory. It is designed to interoperate with HTTP for integration with the web but to avoid its significant processing overhead. Currently devices such as Wi-Fi access points and routers are typically configured from the user’s laptop, tablet or smartphone via a web browser, but that will not be possible for these smaller devices, which is where CoAP comes in.

The idea is to create as slimmed down a client as possible to implement on the device, which means assuming that the home will have some device at hand with a suitable user interface and the power to act as a configuration server. Now that it is known such a device almost always exists, typically a smartphone or tablet, the IETF can get on with the job of finishing CoAP, which we think will play a major role in future home networks.

This analysis, by Philip Hunter, originally appeared inWireless Watch’s sister publication, Faultline, a weekly research note examining key issues in digital media, video and IPTV.