T-Mobile USA is already well behind the big three in LTE, despite its best efforts to market HSPA+ services as ‘4G’. As Verizon, AT&T and even Sprint expand and upgrade their LTE networks, those claims are sounding increasingly hollow, and the fourth cellco badly needs to cement its merger with MetroPCS ‘ the US’s first LTE carrier and the owner of valuable spectrum for boosting TMo’s capacity. However, the deal continues to hang in the balance amid shareholder opposition, and this week TMo owner Deutsche Telekom improved its offer to try to get the transaction finalized.
The German giant said the new proposal was its ‘best and final offer’. It would sweeten the deal by reducing the amount of debt it would impose on the newly merged entity, by a total of $3.8bn, and would also lower the interest rate it would charge on the loan by half a percentage point. The loans would be reduced to $11.2bn from $15bn.
A heavy debt burden was one of the chief concerns of opponents of the deal, including several influential investor advisory companies and some major shareholders in MetroPCS. The smaller carrier agreed to delay a shareholder vote, scheduled for tomorrow, until April 24 to consider the new terms.
‘This puts the new company under less pressure and gives them more strategic flexibility,’ Jonathan Chaplin, an analyst with New Street Research, told Bloomberg. Less burdened by debt, the new unit would more easily be able to make acquisitions or purchase spectrum to boost its competitive challenge to the big three cellcos. Chaplin had been one analyst urging DT to up its bid, saying recently: ‘DT has to sweeten. It would be crazy to let it go to a vote. There’s no way they will win. They don’t have enough votes to get a deal done.’
Deutsche Telekom also extended the lock-up period, during which it would be prevented from selling shares in the combined company on the public market, from six to 18 months, presumably to reassure shareholders that the German giant would not sell out of the new firm too quickly.
The proposed merger has passed all regulatory hurdles, with the FCC and Department of Justice taking the view that it will strengthen competition by creating a more viable fourth player. The deal gives MetroPCS investors $1.5bn in cash and a 26% stake in the combined entity, terms which have not been changed in the revised offer.
‘This improved offer underlines Deutsche Telekom’s commitment to establishing a new, stronger competitor in the US mobile communications market that will offer customers a greater selection of attractively priced products and services on a best-in-class wireless network,’ DT said in a statement, adding that it expected the merger to make cost savings of $6bn to $7bn.
P. Schoenfeld Asset Management, the MetroPCS shareholder which kicked off the campaign to improve the offer, said in a statement that it welcomed the DT move and will review the proposal.
‘PSAM is pleased that Deutsche Telekom – in response to strong opposition to the deal from shareholders – has taken steps to improve the terms,’ it said. It had criticized DT for trying to impose an interest rate of 7%.
Other major investment advisors have been split – Institutional Shareholder Services and Glass, Lewis & Co, as well as PSAM, have come out against the deal, while Egan-Jones Proxy Services was in favor. MetroPCS’s top shareholder, Paulson & Co, is against the deal, while Madison Dearborn Partners, the second biggest, backs it.
MetroPCS said in a letter to investors last week that the merger offers ‘both immediate and long term compelling economic value’ to investors, adding: ‘The combined company will be the leading value carrier in the US wireless marketplace and will be able to compete more effectively against the other national wireless competitors’ and in ‘a better position to participate in future industry growth and consolidation’. The last comment raised speculation that DT has its eye on a bigger deal in future, perhaps with Sprint.
This may become necessary as US mobile broadband shifts from a premium market to one of volume. For now, the main game is catch-up with Verizon, and AT&T and Sprint are both playing that one hard.
Sprint could announce a score of new LTE markets today, according to a leaked memo, with 21 new 4G markets in 10 states. Cities would include Los Angeles, Charlotte, Memphis and Virginia Beach, Va. That would take Sprint’s total to just under 100 LTE markets. It has started construction in more than 450 locations and expects LTE will be available in nearly 170 additional cities over the coming months.
Meanwhile, AT&T launched six new LTE markets this week and plans at least another 77 to go live by the end of the summer. The new group includes smaller territories – Jackson, TN; Kalamazoo, MI; Napa, CA; Orangeburg, SC; Rocky Mount-Wilson, NC; and Santa Rosa-Petaluma, CA. The operator is also expanding LTE coverage in parts of Connecticut, South Carolina and elsewhere. With the further 77 switch-ons, AT&T says it will have 4G in at least 250 markets by the end of the summer.
AT&T is also rolling out HSPA+ metrocells to improve capacity in usage hotspots, though it does not expect to add dual-mode 3G/LTE small cells until next year. AVP of small cell solutions, Gordon Mansfield (who is also chair of the Small Cell Forum) said at Mobile World Congress that the carrier has already successfully tested and deployed indoor and outoor metrocells in three different environments – a neighborhood in St Louis, Missouri.; a high rise apartment block in New York City; and an enterprise in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. In all three, near-100% coverage was delivered to locations with a previously poor quality of experience.
The cellco is working on LTE/HSPA+/Wi-Fi metrocells but Mansfield told LightReading it would be ‘foolish to think less than a year” for these roll-outs, though he expects them in less than two years. However, John Donovan, senior EVP of AT&T’s technology and network operations, told a recent Citi conference: “Our objective for 2014 is that we won’t do any small cell or in-building systems that don’t include Wi-Fi.’ AT&T plans to roll out more than 40,000 small cells, 10,000 macrocells and 1,000 DAS systems as part of its Project VIP network modernization program. It has used Alcatel-Lucent lightRadio in trials but will secure small cells from multiple vendors.
Sprint, of course, can accelerate its roll-out once it gains the capital infusion it expects if Softbank’s deal to acquire a 70% stake goes through. It also has the potential to unleash massive 4G capacity if it can get full control of its Clearwire joint venture and support that firm’s migration from WiMAX to TD-LTE and later, LTE-Advanced. However, there are other options emerging for Clearwire. This week, Aurelius Capital Management joined Clearwire minority shareholder Crest Financial in offering the provider new funding to entice it away from Sprint.
In a letter to Clearwire’s board, Aurelius said its financing offer would be on similar terms to that of Sprint, except that its notes would be exchangeable for Clearwire stock at $2 per share as opposed to the $1.50 offered by the cellco. Its sum of $80m would be a supplement to the $240m Crest Financial offered last week. Aurelius suggests the remaining $160m needed to equal Sprint’s $480m bid would come from other investment sources. ‘Sprint has had its chance; it is time to see what the capital markets are prepared to do,’ wrote Aurelius Chairman Mark Brodsky.
However, Sprint has a slight majority in Clearwire stock ownership and the smaller firm has already drawn $160m in funding from its largest investor, receiving $80m for both March and April after declining the draws for January and February. The company previously turned down the funding as it fulfilled its fiduciary duty to its shareholders by reviewing an offer of $3.30 per share for Dish Network.