Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

10 July 2014

Apple hires Tag Heuer exec as smartwatch space looks to get crowded

Apple is adding more grist to the iWatch rumor mill, after hiring the sales director of the luxury Swiss watch brand TAG Heuer. While the industry increasingly assumes October will see the launch of the first new Apple device family since 2010, rumors are also swirling about a Microsoft wristband.

News of Apple’s hiring of Patrick Pruniaux was confirmed by Tag Heuer’s parent company LVMH. Of course, there is a considerable overlap between the marketing strategies for luxury Swiss watches and Apple products and so the news doesn’t necessarily confirm Apple’s plans for a smartwatch (the company appointed a retail chief from another luxury goods brand, Burberry, last year). Nor has the company revealed what role Pruniaux will take. However, the constant drip of leaks and rumors do suggest that the iWatch’s debut really will come in the autumn.

Most of the rumors surrounding the iWatch specify an iOS device with a curved screen that will collect biometric data to feeds into the HealthKit features of the upcoming iOS 8. After Nike shut its FuelBand project down in May, Apple has picked up a few of the developers in what many believe to be proof of the health-centric focus of the putative iWatch. Though Nike surprised most observers when it closed FuelBand, it continues to work closely with Apple on the HealthKit initiative ‘ suggesting a similar ‘Made for iPhone’ certification for future Nike products, or even a cooperation around iWatch, as
HealthKit needs to include third party sensors to thrive as a standalone platform.

The industry hasn’t quite decided on the approach Apple will take, and the company is skilled at keeping the precise details secret until the last minute. Whether there will be one size or multiple versions; if it will be a standalone device or inextricably linked to the iPhone ecosystem; whether it contains a SIM, and which communication protocols ‘ none of these details has been revealed.

Microsoft is also rumored to be diving into the wearables space with a fitness band, apparently more in the vein of the Samsung Gear Fit rather than a full size smartwatch. The thinner screen of the Gear Fit gives it a form factor closer to the dedicated wearables such as the FuelBand, Fitbit or Jawbone Up ‘ thin and tall rather than thick and square. In terms of its branding, the device could feasibly be a Microsoft, Nokia, Lumia, Surface or even an Xbox device.

A major benefit of the smaller wristband form factor is the reduced chance of damaging the device while working out or being active, something that many designers appear not to be considering with devices that aim to be both mini-smartphone and workout companion ‘ combining a large price tag, large screen and integrated biometric sensors. If a customer won’t wear the watch while being active for fear of breaking it, the product makes no sense.

The Microsoft device is rumored to work with both Android and iOS, as well as the Windows Phone platform, allowing it to use the firm’s own Bing Health app but also most third party programs. This open approach should boost the potential market for the device ‘ perhaps even going so far as to undercut the more costly watches from the likes of Samsung and LG or the iWatch itself.

Many fitness enthusiasts are already investing in personal trackers, but there is a huge market out there that an affordable Microsoft device could disrupt if it can draw in those consumers who are interested in accessing data on their personal habits ‘ as part of the larger ‘quantified self’ craze. Being tri-platform and likely cheaper than the iWatch and flagship Android Wear devices should put Microsoft in a strong position to attack the smartwatch and wearable segments ‘ assuming, of course, that it gets the design right.

And this is a handy segue into the wider issue with smart watches in general ‘ that they currently aren’t very attractive customer propositions. Consumer review sites bemoan the poor battery life, the limited functionality and the high price tags of the Samsung offerings, and all-in-one smartwatches never seem to achieve all of the targets they try to hit ‘ perhaps because there are too many, so inevitably there are compromises.

Their small size means the watches aren’t very useful for anything other than screening notifications from the phone, so to respond to that email or SMS, the user needs to get out the handset anyway. For many people, a $300 price tag is outrageous given the smidgen of usefulness that the watch’s small screen provides.

So it seems obvious that trying to fit as many features into the device as possible is the way to go, trying to tick as many of the functionality boxes as possible. If you admit to the fact that the form factor is the greatest limitation, it then pays to try and add things like biometric sensors to make the smartwatch package more enticing. But this approach can quickly become a case of the watch being a jack-of-all-trades but master-of-none; and that’s before you consider the added bill of materials cost of integrating all of the sensors needed to become a device that can quantify the self, interface with a phone and even tell the time.

Most smartwatches end up being $300 devices that don’t do any one thing well, at an uncompetitive price point and tied to a single ecosystem. Nonetheless, Google is trying to make the smartwatch a more easily navigable device with Android Wear, hoping that strict user interface rules for manufacturers will lead to a more cohesive platform.

Two Android Wear watches have launched in the last week; the LG G Watch ($230) and the Samsung Gear Live ($200). Both can be used to receive Google Now notification cards from the phone, letting users see and manage the notifications that the apps generate. Voice control is also moved to the wrist, and gestures on the touchscreen allow users to dismiss or act upon a notification tile. Other features such as controlling music playing on the phone from the wrist are also available.

There are reported issues with Android Wear that are either early teething problems or potentially massive stumbling blocks. The small-sized UI of the watch face constrains the interactions that can be had with the app, and multiple notifications only worsen the problem. Reviewers frequently complain that more than three Twitter notifications will render the Google Now tile unreadable ‘ defeating the point of the easy-to-navigate watch entirely.

Apple will undoubtedly run into the same limitations as Android Wear, inherent to the watch form factor. It remains to be seen if there is a better way of doing things, or if Android Wear is updated to improve its functionality. But it looks like Microsoft is taking the safer approach, of focusing on doing fewer things better, rather than the jack-of-all-trades approach that Samsung, LG and possibly Apple have adopted.