Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

10 July 2014

Gowex goes down in flames amid false accounting

Spain’s Gowex, which appeared to be leading a new-look municipal WiFi charge, has filed for bankruptcy, admitting that at least its last four years of accounts were falsified. Its founder and CEO has resigned and its shares remain suspended.

There have been whispers about Gowex for a while, particularly about the scale of revenues it claimed, at €183m last year, despite a tough business model.

In October, the company announced a deal with the City of New York to launch hotspots and to share them with the public and with street level businesses. This network was called ‘We2’, and relied both on Gowex’s 2,000 hotspots and on plans to turn closed access points in shops and restaurants into public ones. The firm said We2 was a cooperative platform based on hotspots from multiple operators and that 500 New York merchants had contributed their access points.

At that time, Gowex claimed to run 80 ‘smart cities’ (basically, city WiFi networks) and to be targeting 300 by 2020, but there was no available list of all the locations. Some were announced – San Francisco, Miami, Dubai, Paris and Macedonian capital Skopje, for instance. Gowex also claimed to have deals with AT&T, Deutsche Telekom, Oi Brazil, PCCW and Boingo (DT said, in the wake of the scandal, that it would evaluate alternative partners in Germany but had not made a decision yet). Some initiatives, such as one in the UK city of Newcastle, were partly funded by city or national government schemes.

Given the failure of most muni-WiFi schemes, on similar lines to these, to deliver profits during the bubble of 10 years ago, it was certainly hard to see where Gowex was getting its good figures. And finally, the scheme seemed to come to the end when a research house specializing in short selling, called Gotham City Research, decided to look into Gowex. It began calling customers and in particular spoke at length to the New York project. Gotham City reported that this involved just €200,000 of orders, although it was reported initially as €7.5m (and then reduced to €2m by Gowex founder Jenaro Martin, when challenged). The researchers concluded that the WiFi provider was
worth nothing, and that over 90% of its reported revenues do not exist, bringing its real figure down to about €10m. The number of owned hotspots was closer to 5,000 rather than the 100,000 it often cited.

The big weakness here was not the nature of the business. WiFi businesses are not inherently crooked or weak. Indeed public WiFi is on the rise and many WiFi monetization businesses have recently landed funding. Instead, if anything is to blame here beyond the founder himself (who is trying to shoulder the blame entirely), it is the lack of financial reporting requirements on the Spanish MAB alternative market. The annual report was signed off by a single accountant, likely a friend of the CEO’s, and the CEO himself. The CEO’s wife was said to have signed off the annual report.

The assets of the company could eventually be sold, but there is such a taint on a business that ceases trading in these circumstances, that it is more likely that the hard assets, such as live hotspots, will be sold off cheaply and the business contracts will have to be reallocated – leaving a sour taste in the mouth of the municipalities that selected Gowex as a partner, and a shortfall in their internal budgets.