Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 July 2014

Subsidies out, non-handsets in, for the US’s big two carriers

As usual, Verizon and AT&T announced their quarterly results within a day of one another. There were no big shocks, but some interesting general trends can be seen at work, particularly with regards to the devices on their networks, and how those are financed. With their first wave of LTE roll-outs almost complete, the big two carriers are using the lure of the new speeds and services to gain consumer acceptance of new ways of charging.

The shift away from all-you-can-eat has been going on for a couple of years, though 10m AT&T customers are still on those unlimited plans. A newer trend has been away from subsidized smartphones and towards financing, sparked by T-Mobile’s disruptive UnCarrier initiative and now having a heavy impact on AT&T’s results too. And as in the device ecosystem, the carriers need to look beyond smartphones for customer growth and, in particular, the improved margins and new revenues streams which will justify their investment in LTE.

In Verizon’s results, non-handsets were more prominent than ever, and both operators are investing heavily in bringing their 4G connections to a wide range of new endpoints, from cars to smart home products. In fact, Verizon added a net figure of only 304,000 smartphones with postpaid contracts during the quarter, but a total of 1.15m connected tablets (making a postpaid tablet base of 5.4m). That certainly bucks a long term trend for most tablets to be WiFi-only, and shows carriers where they can seek out new contracts ‘ or higher fees for deals which provide a pool of data for use by several devices. These ‘bucket deals’ have been an important driver of cellular tablet uptake as consumers no longer need to take out a separate contract for each product.

Verizon said that it added a million new LTE smartphones, but these were offset by losses in featurephones and 3G smartphones. The company ended the quarter with 63.5m smartphones and about 69% of those were 4G.

Overall, the Verizon numbers showed revenue rising 5.7% to $31.483bn, as usual much of the growth, and virtually all of the profit, coming from cellular. Net income fell by 16.8% year-on-year, $4.3bn, but this was down to interest expense and provision for income taxes, and the overall trend at the operating level was up.

Verizon still has $6.4bn in cash and short term investments, compared to the $54bn it had before the $130bn transaction to buy Vodafone out of its US wireless business. Its long term debt has leapt to $107.7bn from $89.6bn.

But there is a definite feeling that the carrier has given up a little in its fixed line network ‘ capex was down by $219m to just $1.3bn in the quarter, and the FiOS headcount has fallen away, down 4,100 to 80,600. Instead, it was wireless all the way with a lift in revenues of 7.5% to $21.5bn. Verizon now has 104.6m wireless customers, of which 98.6m are postpaid, up 4.5% and adding 1.4m in the quarter.

Over at AT&T, overall revenue was up 1.6% year-on-year to $32.6bn but earnings per share dropped from $0.71 to $0.68, and net income from $3.8bn to $3.5bn ‘ all figures were below Wall Street expectations.

The most interesting factor was that a majority of new sign-ups are choosing financing plans rather than subsidies, said the company. This will help it to escape the dilemma which subsidies have always imposed on operators, and which have driven many cellcos round the world to seek alternatives in recent years, with varying degrees of success. Subsidies help with customer acquisition and drive uptake of new, higher-priced services, because they enable consumers to avoid a hefty upfront payment for a sophisticated handset. But they have increasingly eaten into the profits of carriers from AT&T to China Mobile, with the iPhone a particular culprit.

AT&T introduced its Next plan a year ago, allowing subscribers to make monthly payments and can upgrade to a new phone model once a year. Next now accounts for more than 50% of the operator’s additions and upgrades, and saves it from subsidies. Another important growth driver, as at Verizon, is rising interest in multiple device, shared data plans ‘ just over half of the postpaid base is now on an AT&T Mobile Share tariff, and 49% of those accounts have signed up for 10Gbytes a month or more.

These changes are creating shifts in the pattern of AT&T’s revenues, with less coming in from mobile services during the second quarter, but far more from device sales, and it expects the move away from subsidized devices to continue for the rest of the year. The downside of the financing plans is that they eat into revenue levels, because the carriers have to account for smartphone installment payments separately.

However, while AT&T’s accountants wrestle with the structure of the financial report, the positive impact of the new plans is clear to see in the subscriber figures. The operator gained a net total of over one million postpaid wireless subscribers in Q2, its biggest gain in almost five years, and postpaid churn was just 0.86%, which AT&T Mobility’s CEO, Ralph de la Vega, said was the second lowest figure ever reported by a US cellco.

These numbers are a real achievement given the high profile and impact of T-Mobile’s UnCarrier campaign. That is mainly geared to customers who traditionally stay in the prepaid sector, which is TMo’s heartland now, but it threatened to lure lower end subscribers away from the big two and even from the postpaid environment. Next and the shared data plans have helped AT&T ‘ which was far more vulnerable than Verizon, with its greater exposure to budget customers since buying Leap Wireless ‘ to fend off TMo.

Just as importantly, they help encourage users to add extra devices, at a time when these will drive new growth. De la Vega commented in an interview: ‘The best thing to do in this environment is keep the most valuable customers we have. Our smartphone customers are crucial. If you lose them, you lose growth opportunities in areas like connected cars and smart home services.’

AT&T’s Digital Life program, and its in-car offerings are very important elements of its strategy to push its wireless, wireline and converged networks into more aspects of its customers’ lives, increasing their overall spending even if charges for individual services fall. That was the thinking behind operators’ quad plays, and now the same idea is extending beyond home and mobile connections to cars, wearables and the broader internet of things. Verizon is also highly active in connected cars and IoT, though in the former, it has focused more on safety and on deals with the auto industry itself, while AT&T is heavily focused on consumer services.

As de la Vega indicated, it will be crucial to hang onto high value customers, and indeed, AT&T saw a mass exodus of its prepaid users. Having acquired Leap, the users of that firm’s Cricket service are defecting in droves ‘ AT&T lost 405,000 pay-as-you-go subscribers. It said this pattern had been expected as the carrier started to transition Leap’s old CDMA network and devices to GSM, but that defections were slowing. But no former Leap customers upgraded to postpaid ‘ which raises the worrying specter, for rivals, that all AT&T’s substantial smartphone gains were from other operators, the sort of pattern not seen since the early iPhone exclusives.

However, AT&T is in a position to tolerate, and even welcome, the loss of the former Leap users. It acquired Leap for its AWS and other spectrum, not to get into the prepaid business in a big way (though it is more active there than Verizon). As de la Vega’s comments indicate, as long as the carrier can hold onto high value smartphone and connected device users, it will happily sacrifice customer numbers for higher profits and lower churn.

The same cannot be said for Sprint, which, like AT&T’s Leap unit, is suffering from CDMA defection ‘ but without the same ability to be blas’ about the loss of low end subscribers. Sprint has spent years waging a losing battle against the loss of postpaid, premium customers and has seen most of its growth coming in the prepaid area, where it has several effective brands, but where price wars eat into margins. Its ambitious Network Vision and Spark programs, to build an impressively fast 4G and multimode infrastructure in its plentiful spectrum, are not yet anywhere near as broad in coverage as the LTE build-outs of the big two, and have suffered repeated delays. That, in turn, has restricted its ability to upgrade the data spending of its remaining postpaid customers, or to attract new ones from other carriers.

When the Softbank-controlled operator, which is said to be close to announcing a formal proposal to merge with T-Mobile USA, reports its own quarterly results next week, it is expected to show dramatic subscriber losses. These will be mainly the result of its CDMA network upgrade ‘ a process with which Sprint is painfully familiar, since many of its churn issues of recent years have been connected to its acquisition of Nextel and its iDEN network, which was subsequently downgraded and eventually shut down.

As the CDMA network is being transitioned to LTE, there have been temporary degradations of coverage, call quality and network speeds for some customers, and to hold onto the users, Sprint will not only have to make its LTE promises sound convincing, but probably cut prices in the near term. This is the view of analysts at Jefferies, who wrote in a client note that they expect Sprint to report a net loss of 879,000 handset subscribers in its Q2, which would be “one of the worst in the company’s history’.

The impact of LTE roll-out on short term quality of experience has been heavier at Sprint, which took full ‘rip and replace’ approach with Network Vision, than at operators which overlaid existing networks with 4G, leaving the 2G/3G infrastructure virtually unchanged. Such operators, which include the US big two, will have more work to do in future to optimize multimode networks and increase spectral efficiency, but they suffer less disruption, and somewhat less cost, in the short term. Sprint’s upgrade is due to be largely finished this summer and the carrier says that, in markets where the process is over 70% complete, churn has returned to its usual levels, while in those which are 100% complete, churn is lower than before. Therefore, Sprint insists it will return to subscriber growth in the second half of 2014, though it remains to be seen whether that growth will, at last, be coming from premium, smartphone or tablet contracts rather than prepaid.

Jefferies is not optimistic. In the note, the analysts commented: “While network issues are likely to abate, leading to better churn, we believe it will take years and intense marketing to fix brand perception, pressuring gross add share for a prolonged period. Pricing changes will almost certainly have to be adopted as Sprint remains relatively uncompetitive. ‘

And they echoed the weariness of many investors at the long wait for a shiny new network which can prove itself able to tempt high end customers away from AT&T and Verizon. ‘Over the past couple of years, the fundamental investment thesis for Sprint shares has hinged on future operational improvements. We believe investors are growing increasingly fatigued with the network improvement story,’ they wrote.

Verizon plans wireless video attack in 2015:

Verizon is planning a video offensive in early 2015, and will rely heavily on LTE Broadcast (or Multicast). This will not be ready for prime time until well into next year, but in preparation, Verizon will launch multicast compatible devices during the next quarter.

This reflects a rising interest in this once-dismissed technology, which allows video to be multicast over the standard LTE network to supporting devices, rather than forcing the carrier to build a dedicated system, as previous mobile TV attempts like DVB-H and Qualcomm’s MediaFLO did. In the UK, the BBC is partnering with the largest cellco, EE, plus Huawei and Qualcomm, to demonstrate LTE Broadcast.

LTE Broadcast flexibly shares the same spectrum as unicast content delivery, as required, but unlike unicast it maintains the same quality as the number of users rises, without additional network or spectrum capacity.

Meanwhile, Verizon CFO Fran Shammo, on the quarterly earnings call, pointed out two highlights of the forthcoming video service ‘ multicast and a new device called Quantum TV, which will be part of the FiOS service. This is wireless home gateway that enables whole-home digital video recording for any device.