In the two years since Facebook’s IPO, the social networking giant has made significant progress in building a mobile business model. That public offering was blighted by uncertainty about how to turn its vast mobile traffic into gold, but its second quarter results show how far it has come in meeting the challenge. The growth in mobile advertising was credited as the primary factor in a 61% year-on-year leap in second quarter revenue, hitting $2.91bn, well ahead of analyst expectations.
Other web players also need to act urgently to adjust to the shift in their users and traffic from PCs to mobile devices. Google has had the most long term and radical strategy, of course, creating a whole platform around Android, but in mobile advertising terms it is losing some ground to Facebook. In particular, it is showing less progress in rebalancing its advertising business from high volumes to high price-per-ad ‘ a transition which is essential in the mobile world, where there are fewer ad impressions to sell, and which Facebook is addressing well so far.
The other big competitive edge for mobile advertising platforms will come from the depth of personalization they can offer in targeting their users with relevant promotions, and the detailed analytics they can provide to customers. Here, Google is investing heavily in deep learning platforms and context-aware tools, and Facebook is embarking on a similar journey. Others will need to emulate, or partner. Yahoo, whose mobile-first transformation is not yet showing through in tangible financial improvement, this week acquired mobile analytics firm Flurry, in a sign that it, too, will be trying to add value to its platform and bind together its services with rich data.
At Facebook, second quarter net income rose 137% on the year-ago quarter, to $791m or 30 cents a share. Profit excluding one-off items was 42 cents, well ahead of Wall Street forecasts.
Advertising and promotions on mobile devices now account for 62% of total advertising revenues, up from 59% a year earlier and almost nothing at the time of the IPO in May 2012. Facebook has been stoking the growth by introducing new options such as video and mobile-specific applications, as well as improving the quality of promotions and analytics.
‘Facebook just has a better advertising offering now,’ Shyam Patil, an analyst at Wedbush Securities, told Bloomberg. ‘It’s a higher return on investment for the advertiser and so they’re able to pay more money, increasing Facebook’s revenue, and much of that is on mobile.’ The average advert price has more than doubled over the past 12 months and Facebook is working on new value-added choices. Its Creative Labs initiative focuses on experimental apps and has already produced Paper, which makes a magazine-like experience for the social network, and Slingshot.
It is vital that advertising platforms focus on quality and differentiated options in mobile markets, because actual volume of ad impressions is significantly lower than on PCs, so higher fees are critical. Ad impressions for Facebook were down 25% year-on-year, because of the shift of usage towards mobile devices.
There are warning signs for Google here ‘ the search giant is still driving its revenue growth via high volumes of online ads, while the average price of its adverts fell by 6%. That ratio may be hard to sustain as the shift to mobile usage continues, though of course, Google has massive mobile properties to leverage via Android, Chrome and its many search-related services. Facebook has also been diversifying its business, adding features which do not relate directly to social networking, and acquiring the WhatsApp messaging giant.
Facebook is expected to account for more than 22% of mobile advertising dollars worldwide this year, according to estimates by eMarketer, up from 5.4% in 2012. Google is expected to lose a little share, ending up with just over half the market, down from 52.6% in 2012, while Twitter could reach 3% this year. Google’s share of mobile search ad revenue dropped to 68.5% in 2013, from 82.8% the year before, according to the same analysts, as users increasingly tend to go to specific apps (like Amazon to shop) rather than ‘Googling’ an item or topic first.
This is driving Google to invest even more heavily in its own apps and ecommerce systems, as well as longer term gambles like fiber and drones. ‘Other revenue,” which includes Google Play sales, accounted for 10% of the total and was up 53% year-on-year to $1.6bn.
But it will be keeping its eye on Facebook, even though it still has a massive 31% share of the overall digital ad space, while the social company’s remains in single digits. ‘Our tools and the products we’re building are working,’ said Facebook COO Sheryl Sandberg, adding that the network now has 1.5m advertisers ‘ though the costs of supporting and expanding that platform, with a focus on mobile quality, are rising too. Overall expenses were up 22% year-on-year.
Facebook said it now has 1.32bn monthly active users, up from 1.28bn in the prior quarter, with 654m using the product daily on mobile phones. Revenue per user in the quarter was $2.24, up from $2 in the prior quarter and $1.60 a year earlier.
However, CEO Mark Zuckerberg said on a the analyst call that there is still plenty of work to do on mobile. US customers spend an average of 40 minutes a day on mobile Facebook, which is more than any other application, but is still a small proportion of their total time interacting with websites, computers, phones and TVs ‘ nine hours a day.
Google agrees. Chief business officer Nikesh Arora ‘ soon to depart to head up internet activities at Softbank ‘ said on the earnings call that the revenue opportunity for mobile is ‘phenomenally high’, and that ‘businesses and other websites take mobile very, very seriously’.
However, he acknowledged that mobile ‘does not monetize as well as certain other forms’ with the current platforms ‘ Google has often been criticized by investors for the apparent gap between the massive penetration of Android and the revenues directly generated from Android-based services (though it never breaks out mobile figures). This is why it is important to reinvent the user experience to optimize it for mobile devices of increasingly diverse shapes and sizes, says Google, and when that is done successfully, this market ‘should be monetizing even better than desktops’, said Arora.
In the second quarter, Google’s sales were up 22% year-on-year to $15.96bn while profits were up 5.8% to $3.42bn or $6.08 a share, excluding some costs. Both figures were below Wall Street estimates of $15.61bn and $6.25 a share.
The comments by both web majors highlight how the competitive landscape is changing ‘ from ad volumes, impressions and clicks, to creating a full experience in which ads and promotions will be more useful, more embedded, more varied, and more profitable.
“I really can’t underscore this enough that we have a lot of work to do and we could take the cheap and easy approach and put ads in and do payments and make money in the short term, but we’re not going to do that,” Zuckerberg said. “We’re going to take the time to do this in the way that is going to be right over multiple years.” That means making some long term bets, such as the recently concluded acquisition of virtual reality headset maker Oculus VR, which could contribute to next generation mobile and search user experiences. Zuckerberg added: “I cared really deeply about the 10-year arc of the company’, and said he wants Facebook to ‘help define the next generation of computing’.
Yahoo is not being as ambitious as that, but it does have a mobile strategy in place which, if successful, will completely change the shape of the company.Despite persistent rumors that Yahoo might acquire AOL, CEO Marissa Mayer has more sense, and is staying focused on buying useful mobile start-ups, rather than buying into the old myth that two rocks tied together can possibly float. Her latest prey is Flurry, the mobile advertising and analytics company, which the company hopes will accelerate results from its mobile-first strategy. It will be especially important to demonstrate such progress soon, given a recent disappointing quarterly results report.
While most investors have applauded Mayer’s emphatic repositioning of the ageing internet firm around mobility, she can be criticized for a scattergun approach to M&A, snapping up a long list of standalone businesses, often with no significant integration opportunities. That has enriched the content and applications base, and is helping to build a more distinctive user experience, but in the era of big data and personalized ads and content, Yahoo needs to invest more heavily in the analytics which will tie all its purchases together, and help monetize them more effectively.
Flurry, a nine-year old company, started life as an apps developer but then moved into tracking mobile applications in order to support customers’ big data and monetization activities. It monitors 500,000 apps and 1.4bn devices a month, and its software is present in an average of seven applications on each of those devices. Its platform is used by 8,000 publishers and 170,000 developers, who are able to gain insights into how their software is being used, and by whom, in order to enhance and monetize it.
This could give Yahoo the kind of analytics to help develop its goal of a streamlined advertising platform with heavy emphasis on personalization, thus tying together some of its other purchases (and enabling it to see which of its various apps are working best).
Interestingly, Mayer has also been talking recently about mobile search, an area where Google and Apple are battling to take the lead in redefining the experience around fine-grained personalization, voice and gesture interaction, and deep contextual awareness. Analytics engines like Flurry’s could feed into similar activity at Yahoo, and Mayer recognizes that mobile search needs to be a new experience, and that the firm which captures users’ imaginations, as Google did with desktop search, will have huge power in the next generation mobile world. She recently said in a briefing: ‘We really believe the mobile search experience to be completely different than that of traditional desktop search. There is a clear opportunity here and we are continuing to look at ways to deliver more innovative, more intuitive search experiences on mobile phones.’
Financial details of the takeover were not revealed, though reports indicate Flurry went for a nine-figure sum. It has raised about $74m so far in funding and was considered an IPO candidate.
The latest acquisition came just days after Yahoo announced it would buy mobile video start-up RayV, whose technology improves the quality of video streamed to mobile and other online devices.
Since Mayer took over the CEOship nearly two years ago, she has created a new mobile organization and overseen the redesign of most of Yahoo’s mobile services, such as Mail and Finance. The aim is to transform the company into a content and applications portal with a heavy focus on streamlining the smartphone web experience.
However, investors’ patience is starting to wear thin as the big mobile-first vision fails to translate into quick, tangible impact on the overall business. Yahoo does not break out its mobile revenues, just insisting they are ‘meaningful’, but that indicates that this activity, while strategic, remains a small percentage of the total. The company remains mainly reliant on conventional display advertising, but revenue from that business fell by 7% year-on-year in the second quarter, in results which generally disappointed Wall Street.
Tools like Flurry’s may help to speed up progress in delivering results from the mobile strategy. “By joining Yahoo, Flurry will have resources to speed up the delivery of platforms that can help developers build better apps, reach the right users, and explore new revenue opportunities,” Scott Burke, Yahoo’s advertising technology chief, wrote in a blog post.
Flurry will also help with one of the key objectives set out by Mayer in her keynote address at this year’s Consumer Electronics Show. She stressed that Yahoo was in the process of unifying tools to offer advertisers a streamlined and coherent platform, as well as focusing heavily on exclusive content and capabilities for consumers. ‘A common theme across a lot of what you’ve seen today is us simplifying our business,’ Mayer said in her speech. ‘Simplification has been a guiding force in our approach in reimagining our products, our advertising systems and our future plans.’
Her challenge remains a significant one, given Yahoo’s lateness in grasping the opportunities of mobile personalization and targeting. Although it has made a string of neat acquisitions ‘ including paying $1bn for Tumblr – the history of the web indicates how difficult it is to differentiate on the basis of content and apps, which are highly susceptible to consumer fashion ‘ there is always a ‘next big thing’, and Google is better resourced for M&A and product development.
A mobile apps arms race will benefit nobody but the lucky start-ups if the new consumer offerings are not closely tied into an appealing platform for advertisers and other commercial partners, and Google is well ahead in that respect. We can expect Yahoo’s mobile shopping spree to continue, but perhaps with more focus on monetization. It has acquired over 30 firms in this process so far, handily listed by TechCrunch (http://techcrunch.com/2014/07/21/yahoo-is-buying-mobile-analytics-firm-flurry-for-north-of-200m/).