If Google is gnawing away at the foundations of mobile operators’ power with activities like Fi, Verizon is determined to fight fire with fire. It will accelerate its reinvention as a content and over-the-top provider by acquiring AOL, and try to undermine YouTube in the mobile world by combining OTT video with the superior quality of LTE (and even LTE-Broadcast).
AOL and its CEO Tim Armstrong have got their reward for years of under-the-radar efforts to strengthen content and mobile services, and try to bring the once-mighty internet player back from the brink. The $4.4bn price which Verizon will pay to acquire AOL would have been laughable in the internet firm’s heyday at the turn of the century, but now looks like a windfall for its investors (a 17% premium on its Monday closing price), as seen in a 19% surge in the share price when the deal was announced on Tuesday.
Verizon is making several U-turns here – on not wanting to be a content provider, on not planning to buy AOL – but its strategy is logical nonetheless. It seems it will make AOL the home for a beefed-up over-the-top content offering, heavily focused on mobile services and on harnessing its market leading LTE network.
Having invested heavily to leap ahead of AT&T in deploying national LTE, Verizon now needs to differentiate its mobile proposition and keep itself in the premium market, rather than joining the price war which is breaking out in 4G access tariffs. That means taking a share of the high value services which leverage the speed and capacity of 4G, not just owning the pipe.
This is dangerous ground of course. Mobile history is littered with the corpses of mobile operators’ content brands. But while the mobile business is Verizon’s chief growth driver, its future direction is all about quad play and delivering common content and applications over fixed and mobile lines, and to a growing number of screens from handsets to TVs, in-car systems to wearables. Building such a platform requires considerable investment in connectivity and user experience, and Verizon will not want to be relegated to bit-pipe revenue streams for its fiber/wireless platform.
“Verizon’s vision is to provide customers with a premium digital experience based on a global multiscreen network platform,” said Verizon CEO Lowell McAdam in a statement. “This acquisition supports our strategy to provide a cross-screen connection for consumers, creators and advertisers to deliver that premium customer experience.”
Among AOL’s content assets are its subscription business plus brands such as The Huffington Post, TechCrunch and AOL.com. It has the third largest US online video content network after Google and Facebook, and the fourth largest US online video advertising reach after Yahoo’s BrightRoll, Specific Media, and Facebook’s LiveRail.
Speaking to investors at the Jeffries TMT 2015 conference, John Stratton, operations president for Verizon’s wireless and wireline division, said AOL would help the carrier generate more revenue “above the network layer”. This will increasingly differentiate it from AT&T, which is showing more interest in controlling more underlying network and deliver assets, both in wireless and with its own major acquisition, of DirecTV. It will differentiate Verizon even more, of course, from Sprint and T-Mobile, which have no significant content activities.
Overlap with the existing FiOS linear video business will be limited, Stratton argued, because the new mobile-first OTT offering will be aimed a younger consumers with different usage patterns which may make the home TV and its fiber line less significant. “Triple play still matters a lot, but there’s a shift in how consumers consume video. That is why we are doing this OTT stuff,” he told the event. It is also why LTE-Broadcast has become strategic and is now being embedded in many Verizon devices.
Analysts are divided over whether it is a good strategy for Verizon, which has proven its capabilities as a network operator with its LTE build-out, to seek to monetize that network via its own content activities.
Craig Moffett of MoffettNathanson said Verizon was being modern while AT&T’s DirecTV purchase showed it was stuck in the same old rut. “AOL has successfully built a robust ad tech stack with assets across mobile, social, video, and programmatic for both advertisers and publishers. It has premium audience measurement and attribution capabilities, as well as content creation and distribution technologies,” he said.
Others were less convinced. In a client note, New Street Research analysts wrote: “We are not convinced the OTT business is a great business and we are certainly not assuming VZ will put together the killer offering in the space.” Nor do they see “much synergy from combining content and a network. We don’t doubt the value of good content and AOL may have good content (but no killer content), but we would rather VZ focus on the business they know – they may have built the best wireless business on the planet – and let investors figure out where to invest in content separately.”
Even more damningly, Macquarie Capital analysts judged that Verizon was “showing signs of desperation as its core wireless business comes under pressure and it scrambles to find new growth drivers. While $4.4bln isn’t a huge deal for VZ, it’s a bet on an unproven ad-tech platform in what is still a nascent industry.”
The other important aspect to the deal is advertising. Verizon said that AOL would “further drive” its LTE and over-the-top video strategy as well as another important revenue stream which carriers are keen to wrest from Google – mobile advertising. This is another powerful reason to acquire one of the internet companies which has succeeded in building an alternative platform to those of Google, Facebook, Yahoo and Twitter (though Verizon will need to think up some creative strategies to achieve any significant market share, with Google and Facebook controlling 55% between them).
“AOL’s advertising model aligns with our approach, and the advertising platform provides a key tool for us to develop future revenue streams,” McAdam said. AOL is advanced in its ability to target ads automatically in a highly personalized way.
The company’s advertising platform, ONE by AOL, combines assets such as Ad.com, a digital display advertising network; Be On for content production and syndication; Adtech for ad management and serving; and Gravity, for personalization.
Armstrong said in an internal memo: “The deal means we will be a division of Verizon and we will oversee AOL’s current assets plus additional assets from Verizon that are targeted at the mobile and video media space. The deal will not change our strategy – it will expand it greatly. The deal will give our content businesses more distribution and it will give our advertisers more distribution and mobile-first features. The deal will add scale and it will add a mobile lens to everything we do inside of our content, video, and ads strategy.”
The timing is important for Verizon, which is on the point of launching its mobile video streaming service, reportedly next month. Having made several acquisitions on the video technology side, including upLynk, EdgeCast and OnCue, the carrier was still perceived to be missing a strong advertising component. This led Verizon, insiders said, actively to seek a joint venture or acquisition with AOL.
The transaction will take the form of a tender offer followed by a merger, said Verizon, with AOL becoming a wholly owned subsidiary upon completion, which is subject to regulatory approval. Nobody is expecting significant hurdles in that area, and Verizon expects the deal to close this summer. Armstrong will continue to lead AOL’s operations after the deal is completed.
Roger Entner, an analyst with Recon Analytics, told Bloomberg: “Verizon had the early lead in mobile advertising with the right vision and good assets behind it. Then Google came in and bought AdMob and completely upended the market. With this deal, Verizon is trying to turn back the clock and get control of the mobile value stream.”