Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 May 2015

From hysteria to common sense: the many faces of shared spectrum

Supplemental downlink (SDL) is one of the many emerging approaches to using spectrum more efficiently and opening up more mobile capacity. This week has seen two interesting developments around SDL, one sensible (the European Commission opening up the 1.4 GHz band to augment mobile downlink), the other political and tinged with hysteria (the 3GPP apparently insisting that LTE-Unlicensed must only ever provide SDL for licensed carriers, and not be allowed to live by itself in 5 GHz).

The sensible step forward first. The European Commission is moving ahead with plans to open up more spectrum for mobile broadband, opening up a further 40 MHz, mainly to boost downlink capacity.

The frequencies are in the 1452 MHz-1492 MHz band, where mobile operators will have to share with incumbent satellite or terrestrial DAB (digital audio broadcasting) users. This will not be a major challenge in many areas, since very few services have launched in the spectrum. The range between 1452 MHz and 1479.5 MHz was harmonized for T-DAB back in 2002.

While this looks, on the surface, like a relatively minor move in the EC’s broader goal of freeing up large amounts of new mobile broadband capacity, it highlights several important approaches which will increasingly inform spectrum policy in Europe and elsewhere.

It sees the increasing use of sharing with existing incumbents, as a way to open up new airwaves as virgin spectrum in the coveted sub-6 GHz bands becomes scarce. It shows authorities being increasingly eager to identify bands which are underused, in order to maximize spectrum usage across all services.

And it is an example of the use of supplemental downlink (SDL) to augment existing mobile services – an approach which has also been trialled in the US in the unpaired 700 MHz spectrum, now owned by AT&T.

The same technique has been tested over the past couple of years in Europe’s 1.4 GHz band, notably by Orange in France. “SDL in the 1452 MHz-1492 MHz band can be used in conjunction with the aggregation of several frequency bands for their simultaneous use by operators,” the Commission said in its statement.

In a study last year, the EC found that the 1.4 GHz band was not being used efficiently across member states and recommended that it be harmonized for mobile broadband, in this case through SDL to boost download data speeds. Member states have six months to make the spectrum available.

“The 1.4GHz band can be the perfect complement to a mobile operator’s existing frequency assets. A supplemental downlink band, combining extended bandwidth and favorable coverage properties, will be a precious resource in the near future, given the significant rise of data traffic on mobile broadband networks,” said Lasse Wieweg, director of government and industry relations at Ericsson, during the EC workshop to examine the topic back in 2011. At the same event, Plum Consulting presented calculations that using the 1.4 GHz band for SDL could generate as much as $78bn in economic benefit for the EU over a 10-year period, by freeing up additional spectrum for new services.

By far the most controversial example of SDL is, of course, LTE-LAA (Licensed Assisted Access), a proposed standard which would see LTE running in licence-exempt 5 GHz spectrum, alongside WiFi, and augmenting the downlink capacity of an ‘anchor’ LTE network in licensed bands.

This is causing all kinds of storms because it comes laden with all the politics of two ecosystems – 3GPP and WiFi – which are competing for equipment sales and to drive new markets. Many MNOs may see the sense in harnessing both LTE and WiFi, though some are worried by the potential for new rivals to use WiFi-first to disrupt them. But the real tensions are between the 3GPP equipment and device community, and the WiFi camp whose more open market would up-end cellular pricing and lock-ins.

Rational discussion of the pros and cons of LTE in the 5 GHz ‘WiFi band’ is, therefore, rare and hard to achieve. Wilder claims on both sides can be discounted – it is unlikely that, given power and usage constraints in licence-exempt bands, LTE-LAA will achieve quite the superiority of performance which Ericsson and other early triallists claim over WiFi; nor, on the other hand, will regulators allow LTE to get away with the levels of interference which WiFi supporters are claiming, should the rival technology be allowed into ‘their’ frequencies.

It may well be a better idea for the LTE community to focus its TDD, SDL activities on the 3.5 GHz band, which is lightly licensed and largely unused, and so would provide the benefits of augmented downlink capacity and low cost spectrum, without the coexistence challenges, whether related to politics or radio waves. However, it is likely that 5 GHz LTE-LAA will be sufficiently refined to come into mainstream use, particularly to support small cells acting as an additional layer of capacity for established LTE ‘anchor networks’.

This would follow the pattern which many operators envisage, of adding a new, dense layer of cells beneath the macro network, and interworking with it, HetNet-style. It would also fit with the timings for that second layer (which could also be operated by a third party such as an enterprise) – most are planning such roll-outs for 2017 or later, which is when LTE-LAA will be commercially available in standard form as part of 3GPP Release 13.

Until then, it will continue to be a matter of half-truths, disputes and ‘pre-standard’ implementations, none of which will stop the WiFi juggernaut from adding to its ecosystem and its installed base.

The bigger question is whether there will be a full LTE-Unlicensed standard in future, which would allow the 4G standard to operate in 5 GHz (or other bands) without being tied to a licensed-band host network. That would be far more in keeping with the spirit of licence-exempt spectrum, because the technology would be open to any firm to use, not just to operators already in possession of a licensed-band network, or at least able to access one via an MVNO deal. However, the 3GPP community is broadly hostile to that option, since it would allow its precious LTE technology to fall out of the control of its own close-knit circle of operators and their supply chains.

This week saw Dave Burstein, editor of DSL Prime, uncovering an internal 3GPP memo which appeared to be insisting that LTE-U must not be made available in future for use by non-LTE operators, without a ‘real’ LTE signal to control it. The paper says that the 3GPP should take standalone LTE usage out of its emerging standard for Release 13 (it could come in later in another release).

The document was circulated among 11 carriers – including AT&T, T-Mobile USA, Sprint, China Mobile, KT, Telefonica and Orange – which took part in a 3GPP working group meeting in Serbia last month. The document has a provocative title – ‘Precluding standalone access of LTE on unlicensed carriers’. It proposes to revise the 3GPP’s former ruling that LTE-U could be used by any carriers (including those operating on the unlicensed spectrums), and to prohibit non-LTE carriers from using it.

Since that would hardly get past antitrust regulators, what they really mean is to keep the standard focused only on SDL, which requires an anchor network in licensed-band LTE, and so is, in effect confined to the operators of those networks, or their partners.

If the next logical step, to develop a standard for LTE to run in 5 GHz without an anchor, proceeded, the document said: “Standalone deployment in unlicensed spectrum implies drastically different business models from nowadays and might impact the value chain.”

In reality, that would actually affect a fairly small number of companies. For most non-MNOs, there is no realistic option to use unlicensed LTE because the structure of its ecosystem would make it far too expensive (a new standard does not a new ecosystem make, as WiMAX discovered). There are a few firms, notably Google, which have the resources to invest in LTE (if they saw performance advantages over WiFi in future). Google could then expand its Fi service, for instance, supporting a mixture of WiFi and LTE small cells (with LTE providing the true mobility which WiFi lacks), without any need to rely on MVNO deals with Sprint and T-Mobile.

We can be sure that, as ‘5G’ approaches, Google will find more creative ways to squeeze the MNOs than that, and indeed, many of the current debates about licensed versus unlicensed spectrum and technology will start to look hopelessly quaint by the end of the decade. For now, it seems that the 3GPP is being protectionist about its own technologies, keeping its members cosily within the castle walls even though there aren’t very many barbarians outside which are actually interested in LTE – they will be busily making sure they drive the next generation technologies that will eventually sweep the status quo away.

FCC wades into LTE-LAA debate:

The FCC has opened up a new proceeding to look specifically at LTE-LAA and LTE-U, which formally started work last week with a comment period. The topic has been prominent in debates over the regulator’s current process of opening up the 3.5 GHz band for tiered, shared usage, as these frequencies are seen as a possible home for LTE-LAA small cells, as well as 5 GHz.

As with everything connected to LTE-U, the FCC’s decision to conduct a separate examination has been divisive. While it is backed by chairman Tom Wheeler, commissioner Michael O’Rielly said in a statement: “Today’s public notice walks a fine line between reasonable oversight and inappropriate interference with the standards setting process.”

He added: “The decision to jump into this space rather casually causes me great concern. In particular, any step that could insert the Commission into the standards work for LTE-U comes with great risk. I will be vigilant in ensuring that the Commission’s involvement does not result in taking sides with various stakeholders, hindering technological innovation, or having any say about what technologies should or should not be deployed.”

The FCC insisted it was not straying from its historical policy of remaining technology neutral, but wanted to help enable a “fully participatory and transparent discussion about LTE-U and LAA technologies” and how they would coexist with WiFi. It has listed about a dozen questions for public comment, covering topics such as coordination between 3GPP and IEEE, and the status of coexistence tests. Comments are due by June 11.

“We are aware that some companies have formed the LTE-U Forum, which is considering deployment of LTE-U/LAA using a ‘pre-standard’ version,” the FCC’s notice said.

One of the organizations pushing for more testing and evaluation before anybody can deploy LTE in 5 GHz is CableLabs, the main technology and standards group for the US cable industry. It has petitioned the FCC for a two-year experimental licence to use Sprint’s 2.5 GHz spectrum, to test how LTE-U and LTE-LAA coexist with WiFi. Sprint is supporting the plan.

Ian MacMillan, principal architect at CableLabs, wrote on the organization’s website that LTE-U was “a potential competitor on the horizon” for WiFi. His concern is the MNOs’ ability to use carrier aggregation, which “is intended to allow mobile operators to combine the various licensed spectrum bands they own into a single data connection between user and network. More spectrum equals more and faster data.” However, he wrote, they might “not only combine licensed spectrum but also add in the unlicensed spectrum primarily used by WiFi today”, which would go beyond WiFi/cellular integration and be “all LTE”.