Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 May 2015

Google Fi eclipses Voice but has the same disruptive agenda

Google may have worked closely with mobile network operators, a necessity to get broad distribution for Android devices and all its mobile services. However, it has always been working towards a new world, in which wireless networks would be open access bitpipes, and a host of web service providers would use those pipes to deliver their applications and monetize their users’ connections.

Building its own networks, whether powered by fiber, WiFi homespots or balloons, is largely a red herring in terms of the real strategy. Google has the money to create some of the open access networks it wants, and so accelerate the process of disrupting the status quo in which a few carriers control spectrum and networks, and impose rigid relationships that govern both end user connectivity and MVNOs.

But its real disruption will come from services that bypass the carrier’s brand and even its ability to charge for a connection. Google Wallet is a good example (though Apple may do more to sideline the MNO when it comes to payments). And voice remains a key element of this battle for control of the mobile user’s experience and the mobile user’s spend on services. The ‘killer app’ that just refuses to die, voice has been deemed irrelevant (because the new generation uses messaging not calls), and unprofitable (because of the decline of traditional cellular voice plans and technologies).

But it has survived, gaining new value through integration into unified messaging services or enterprise-class conferencing platforms. And most importantly, the phone number remains a powerful way to tie together all a user’s different activities, applications and identities. It has been a vital weapon for mobile operators as they seek to keep customers tied to their brand and billing system, not to over-the-top providers. And it is one Google has persistently tried to appropriate, first with Google Voice and now with Google Fi.

Google Fi, the MVNO service the search giant launched recently, is not interesting in its current form – confined to one handset and one country, offering WiFi-first options and mobile pricing which are similar to many others. FreedomPop and Cablevision Freewheel both offer superior deals on a larger number of devices (and both look set to come to Europe sooner than Fi), as do start-ups like Scratch Wireless or Republic Wireless.

Indeed, Cablevision is being more radical in the break with the MNO network than Google, insisting that WiFi can do most of the job – even for a QoS-sensitive application like voice – on its own, with no need to pay fees to cellular operators. COO Kristin Dolan said, on the US cableco’s recent earnings call: “WiFi is the technology of the future. All new products are assuming a WiFi presence.” Dolan has previously said that Cablevision rejected the MVNO route because it wanted its subscribers to realize how often they were using the WiFi network. “If we just did an app with an MVNO backfill solution, they wouldn’t realize what they got,” she said.

Fi is interesting for two reasons. One is the way it moves the user dynamically between WiFi and cellular, an ‘always best connected’ designed to maximise quality of experience while reducing the cost of delivery by making use of WiFi when it is available and providing sufficient QoS. This is a small step towards Google’s vision of a world where all cellular and WiFi networks provide a seamless pool of connectivity and capacity, which does not belong to one operator but is tapped on an on-demand basis by service providers or end users, and paid-for on a marketplace basis.

All that flexibility will mean little to the customer if they do not have a single identity which follows them over any connection and application. Some of that identity is bound up in security settings, credit card details and online profiles, but an important element is the phone number, still the simplest way to be contacted by anyone, regardless of device or network.

When Google Voice launched in 2009, the fact that users could bring across their existing phone numbers was one of its most disruptive elements as it took on both Skype and the traditional mobile services. This element remains important six years on in Google Fi, though the technology has moved on. Google has developed seamless access technology which keeps customers’ phone numbers in the cloud, so that they can move between WiFi and cellular with just one number, and use that same ID on “just about any phone, tablet or laptop”. Google Fi can issue a new number or an existing one can be transferred.

This is where the disruptiveness comes in. TMo and Sprint may be providing the LTE network, but Google has control of the connection and of the MNO’s trump card against over-the-top communications, the phone number. This takes forward some of the ideas seen in Google Voice, even though that was heavily PC-based and could not yet tap into important enablers like the cloud platform or integrated cellular/WiFi.

However, over the years it has been a vehicle for Google to introduce various developments with which it hoped to chip away at the carriers’ control of the mobile subscriber – integrating real time communications, including Voice, into the browser, for instance. It has helped integrate the voice experience tightly into Android, rather than the MNO platform, and more than justified Google’s acquisition of GrandCentral, which provided the initial software, in 2007.

Many of its principles will carry on and evolve in Fi, as well as rival offerings which look to improve on the QoS of purely over-the-top services, while cutting the ties with a single network or carrier. By working at the upper levels of the control plane rather than on the media plane, like Skype, Voice provided that all-important single phone number and the ability to forward calls based on rules the user established. That saw sees Google sitting right at the heart of the call flow, a move that would relegate operators to the dreaded bitpipe role. Google Voice, and its successor within Fi, reside on the network and run presence and availability functions, allowing users to initiate calls, set up conference calls and so on, via a simple web interface.

Fi, not Voice, will be the main offering to take these development forward, especially if the search giant replicates the offering in other markets, as it is reported to be discussing with Hutchison Whampoa, which could host an international MVNO on its various European and Asian networks.

Indeed, Fi looks set to eclipse Voice in strategic terms. There has been concern over whether the two services are compatible – Google, on its help pages, leads with advice on “switching from Google Voice to Project Fi”, which sums up its priorities. If a user activates a Fi number, Google Voice is automatically discontinued (though features such as voicemail and call history, as well as credits, are all carried over).

But the contribution of Voice will live on, and it will be left to the MNOs to try to fight back . Their main weapons are currently Voice over WiFi (VoWiFi) and Voice over LTE (VoLTE), sometimes deployed in tandem with the former filling in coverage gaps for the latter. Because both are powered by the carrier’s IMS (IP Multimedia Subsystem), the operators argue that they will be able to offer a wide range of enhanced communications services as well as the guaranteed QoS of a controlled, licensed spectrum network. They will win some supporters in the enterprise with the quality argument, especially if they offer SLAs, but in terms of offering superior functionality to the web players, their track record is poor. The GSMA’s RCS (Rich Communications Services) platform was supposed to be the basis of a highly differentiated experience which users could only get from mobile carriers, and which would be fully interoperable.

However, adoption by MNOs has been slow and patchy, and the services launched do not shine brightly against those of the higher quality web solutions like Google Voice or Skype. Google Fi’s underlying access and telephony software, regardless of the MVNO connectivity, may be just another nail in the road for the mobile carriers’ voice services gravy train.