Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 May 2015

Hutchison hunts Italian, as well as UK, prey

Hutchison Whampoa has been on a turbulent journey with Three, its ambitious attempt to play a major role in Europe’s mobile broadband market. Since it was founded amid the bursting of Europe’s 3G bubble in 2002, it is moving quickly on to 4G, and seeking mergers to bring it the scale it has never achieved through organic growth alone, despite a string of disruptive tactics which have certainly helped boost competition, and squeeze prices, in the region.

The Hong Kong parent company has already achieved mergers with former rivals in Ireland (Telefonica O2) and Austria (Orange), and a network sharing joint venture with Telenor in Sweden, called Hi3G. It is now looking to join forces with O2 (again) in the UK and with VimpelCom’s Wind in Italy. (It also has operations under the Three brand in Denmark and outside Europe in Australia and Indonesia. The Danish unit may soon see its market position under pressure, as Telenor and TeliaSonera are proposing to merge their operations in that country.)

In all cases, the deals would rescue Three from being considerably overshadowed by a larger incumbent, and in the UK, if the regulators allow Whampoa to acquire most of Telefonica’s O2 arm, it would move from being the smallest to the largest player.

And last week, the company confirmed it was in exploratory talks with VimpelCom to merge their respective Italian mobile units into a joint venture, uniting the third and fourth players and adding scale to Three, already the largest unit within the group in terms of subscribers. As in the proposed UK deal, this would reduce the number of MNOs from four to three, something which until recently would probably have prompted regulatory blocks or at least stringent conditions.

However, amid price wars and the rise of quad play operators in Europe, EC and national antitrust agencies have become more tolerant of reducing the number of MNOs in order to maintain robust players, capable of investing in new mobile infrastructure. That was seen in Germany (where O2 merged with KPN’s E-Plus) and in Ireland, where the main conditions were that the merged carrier should be more open to new MVNOs, and also in Austria.

Both companies in the Italy talks stress that any transaction would be subject to achieving satisfactory debt levels as well as corporate and regulatory approvals. As Reuters pointed out, Wind’s debt level has been an obstacle in previous talks with Whampoa, although those focused on a full acquisition, so the new JV plan may be a compromise option. At the end of last year Wind reported total debt of €9.65bn ($11bn).

“Hutchison has been disciplined in only doing deals that are accretive to earnings and cashflow, and we would expect that to be the case if a deal gets done with Wind,” analyst Joe Morrison of Moody’s told Reuters.

In the UK, Whampoa is in the process of acquiring Telefonica’s O2 UK unit for up to £10.25bn. Now the parent firm says, assuming that deal passes muster with UK and EC competition regulators, it plans to sell a 33% stake in the combined business to five institutional investors for a total of up to £3.1bn ($4.7bn). The investments will help fund the purchase and are conditional on its being completed. Hutchison has already secured a £6bn bank facility for the deal too.

The investors are Canada Pension Plan Investment Board (CPPIB – also the largest shareholder in UK mobile infrastructure firm Arqiva; GIC of Singapore; a subsidiary of the Abu Dhabi Investment Authority, Limpart Holdings; CDPQ of Canada; and BTG Pactual of Brazil. CPPIB and GIC confirmed they would each invest £1.1bn.