China does things on a wholly different scale to any other country. While other nations fiddle around with national broadband projects worth a fewbn dollars, the Chinese government is pledging no less than $182bn for fiber and LTE expansion (for comparison, the US broadband incentive plan of 2009 was worth about $7bn.) In its scale and ambition, the three-year project can be viewed as a digital equivalent of the construction of the Great Wall of China (which would have cost a paltry $65bn in today’s money). Though there is a great deal of fiber involved, LTE will also play an important role, with 1.3m 4G base stations expected to be added this year.
The Chinese package is $140 for every person in the country – the US stimulus was closer to $24 people per person, though of course in very different economic conditions.
The rationalization given by Beijing is that this will move China from a manufacturing to a service-driven economy, helping to enable the country’s pushes into advanced global industries such as space, e-commerce, green energy and bioengineering – all on the roadmap for 2025.
This will accelerate the 4G moves already underway by the three national carriers, and will give equipment suppliers round the world high hopes of a windfall of orders. It remains to be seen whether the roll-out is a Great Wall in terms of keeping the technologies and equipment tenders within China’s own growing ecosystem, though to date, although Huawei and ZTE have won the largest shares of the 3G and 4G contracts, the big western suppliers have also received major awards. Nokia, for instance, gets around 15% of its revenue from China.
The scale may be unprecendented, but the motivations behind the plan announced last week by China’s State Council mirror those of other government broadband initiatives round the world – to increase high speed access, with the social and economic benefits of that, and to boost competition. The Council said in its statement: “There is still a huge gap between China’s network speed and international standards as well as the expectations of the Chinese people. There are also issues such as high network fees and unbalanced development in rural and urban areas, and limited quality of service.”
Among the statistics of the bid to address this challenge – 80m homes and 10,000 villages will be connected to fiber this year, and another 14,000 villages will get broadband via LTE or copper. The target is 300m LTE subscribers by year end. The cost in 2015 alone will be $69bn, followed by $112bn spread over 2016 and 2017.
“By the end of 2017, all households in locations above prefecture level will have access to 100Mbps fiber optic networks, over 80% of villages will be covered by fiber optic networks, all cities and villages will be covered by 4G networks, and broadband speeds in municipalities and provincial capitals will reach 30Mbps,” the Council pledged.
Meanwhile, the State Information Center commented: “There is still not enough competition, which has led to telecoms fees being relatively high while there is still a lot of room to improve the quality of service.” In recent months, the Chinese operators have been reducing 4G data fees to boost uptake and fend off newly introduced MVNO services. They are also seeking to reduce costs by placing their towers and some other infrastructure into a joint venture.
With MNOs’ profits being squeezed, not boosted, by its huge roll-out of TD-LTE, there are big question marks over how the LTE portion of the government’s plan will be funded, and how the operators will reap the rewards when they are being pushed to cut prices and roaming fees further. China Mobile, for instance, suffered a 10% year-on-year decline in net profits in its 2014 fiscal year, and six successive quarters of net income reduction, because of high investment in 4G and declining service revenues.
Such figures have raised urgent questions about how China Mobile will secure the payback for its massive investment in TD-LTE, if the new networks failed to boost profits even in their ‘honeymoon period’, in which Mobile had virtually all the commercially operating LTE systems in China. Now that its rivals, China Telecom and China Unicom, are also engaged in extensive LTE roll-outs, in TDD and FDD spectrum, the pressure on prices will only increase.
Like its peers everywhere, China Mobile is being hurt by the web services which its 3G and 4G build-outs enable – conventional texting volumes dropped by over 20% in the year, while over-the-top messaging, using applications like Tencent’s Weixin, saw a 12% increase in volume in 2014, with no real payback for the cellco, unless the customer incurs higher data fees.
China Mobile is relying on overall data growth to justify its investments in its networks, but it also needs to accelerate the pace in attracting non-consumer clients, for enterprise and IoT services, and in moving away from the handset subsidies which have persistently eaten into its profits.
These considerations seem mundane when set against the lofty ambitions of the national broadband plan, and the wider expansion that could drive in China’s industries and services. However, they are important. The Chinese operators are stuck in a strange limbo between being market-driven, profit-making companies and being state-controlled, and in many ways, they get the worst of both worlds. They are handed targets which may not be achievable if they have to operate in a commercial environment. However, in the past, the response has been to invest in new revenue streams to start to rebalance the equation. We can expect significant new moves in the internet of things, digital commerce and cloud services to emerge from the Chinese carriers, with impact for the international competitive landscape too.