The cellular industry’s traditional, fiercely protected approach to licensing patents has been under attack in recent years from several quarters – the rise of new mobile giants with their own IPR, such as Apple; the increasing importance of standards from the IEEE or MPEG LA, which have different licensing approaches and are insisting on new rules; the impact of open source; weariness with patent litigation and trolls; antitrust investigations into standards-essential patent (SEP) practices by the European Commission and other agencies.
The latest development which may force the giants of cellular patents to adjust their licensing models comes from South Korea and China. Both countries are in the process of adopting antitrust policies which would require vendors to license their patents and technologies more openly and at lower cost, if they wish to trade in these two markets. Both are too important to ignore – China for its sheer size and the number of manufacturers and operators it houses; Korea for its advanced technology base and the weight of Samsung and LG.
And where China goes, others follow, with Brazil and India said to be considering similar actions to reduce reliance on western companies’ technologies, and the licensing fees paid to them, while safeguarding against unfair business practices by major IPR players. In particular, Korea and China are introducing two important laws – set values for standards-essential patents (SEP), and the requirement that, if a unique feature (such as Apple’s slide-to-unlock) is considered “essential” or “dominant”, it must be licensed to others.
The former stipulation may well become the norm in other parts of the world, as authorities grapple with the vagueness and complexity of the current system, which insists on Frand (fair reasonable and non-discriminatory) licensing of patents which are essential to standards. Stronger definition of what those terms mean, and how high a fee would be considered ‘fair’, is badly needed, and the Asian countries could set a useful precedent.
The second area is far more problematic in that it seems to insist that Chinese and Korean companies should have access, for a fee, to any technology seen as dominant, even if it is not included in a standard, which could severely harm the ability for vendors to differentiate themselves, and deter them from investing in innovations for the Chinese and Korean markets. However, like all broad rules, these will be subject to interpretation, and some experts argue they are just allowing inventors to insist that third parties pay to use their technologies.
These new rules are no doubt related to the antitrust probes which China and Korea periodically mount against US firms such as Qualcomm, but are separate attacks on the entrenched power of western technologies. South Korea’s new restrictions on patent licensing have already gone into effect (in December), while China’s rules are expected to be published by August 1. The Korea Fair Trade Commission says it aims to “improve consistency” in how antitrust law is enforced and to guard against trolls, while “effectively regulating global companies’ abuse of monopoly with patents” in order to protect domestic firms such as Samsung. Samsung, of course, is still embroiled in some cases in its multi-headed global legal battle with Apple over technology and design patents.
“We’re going back to the Cold War and the domino theory,” Bradley Lui, an antitrust lawyer with Morrison & Foerster in Washington DC, told Bloomberg.
Qualcomm – which stands to lose even more ground, if such rules come into force, than it already has following its settlement of a major antitrust suit in China – believes debates in US Congress about patent reform has influenced the Asian developments. “The domestic debate that is supposed to be specific to our country is being latched on to by foreign governments,” said Sean Murphy, Qualcomm’s international government affairs counsel, in the same article. “It’s giving them justification to take action.”
Of course, Qualcomm and other cellular giants want to protect a secretive system of bilateral deals which has served them well for many years, in terms of revenues and power over standards. “The system that is in place is a system which has been going on for many years and it is working,” said Kasim Alfalahi, Ericsson’s chief intellectual property officer. “It is built on contribution and global agreements to cover products sold around the world with patents that are being issued all the time to companies like Ericsson.” Ericsson recently engaged in litigation against Apple and offered to take the case to arbitration with the aim of getting a court precedent on Frand definitions – but Apple refused and the case continues.