The satellite industry is gearing up for a battle with the mobile sector as this year’s ITU World Radio Conference (WRC-15) comes closer. Michel de Rosen, CEO of satellite operator Eutelsat, is the latest to weigh in, claiming that cellular carriers already has plenty of unused capacity, and that the satellite firms must “fight invasion” by mobile broadband.
At events earlier this year, such as Mobile World Congress, there were efforts by mobile and satellite bodies – including the GSMA and the Satellite Industry Association (SIA) – to portray their WRC-15 goals as complementary, and to insist that both sectors need one another and will be ready to share and compromise. With the crucial conference less than five months away, however, more confrontational voices are being heard, with satellite chiefs speaking out against sharing spectrum with mobile broadband providers.
De Rosen said this week that his industry must redouble its efforts to contest the mobile industry’s bid to secure new IMT spectrum in satellite bands, at WRC-15 and also at the ensuing conference in 2019. The critical issue in 2015 will be the extended C-band, but the meeting will also look to identify new candidate bands for ‘5G’ in higher frequencies, which could then be submitted for approval at WRC-19.
“There is the battle for C-band, but behind that battle, there is the battle for all our spectrum, which the IMT industry will gladly take away from us,” de Rosen told this week’s CommunicAsia conference, reiterating themes he has plugged all year in the run-up to WRC-15. He claimed the GSMA’s calculation of the extra spectrum it needs for future mobile broadband traffic is overblown.
“In most of the world, less than 50% of the spectrum already identified by the ITU for IMT services has actually been licensed,” he said. “We are talking about hundreds of megahertz of unlicensed spectrum that is just sitting there, not being used”, and even regarding frequencies which have been licensed, much remains unused or underused. “In other words, IMT still has plenty of room to grow before it starts lobbying for more spectrum,” he said.
The GSMA says that mobile operators, which it represents, will need a further 600 MHz to 800 MHz of spectrum by 2020 to cope with the growth in traffic over the coming 5-10 years. Among the bands it is targeting, in which satellite services currently sit, are the extended C-band (3.4 GHz-4.2 GHz), and the 470 MHz-698 MHz spectrum. It is also looking at frequencies in the S-band (2.7 GHz-2.9 GHz) and the L-band (1300 MHz-1518 MHz).
At the same event, Intelsat’s CEO, Stephen Spengler, said that the responsibility also lies with the satellite industry to prove its worth, in order to justify keeping its spectrum, especially when battling with a far larger sector. “The satellite industry is a $200bn a year business, compared to the global telecoms industry, which is a $5.4 trillion business,” he told the CommunicAsia event, as quoted by TelecomAsia. “This is the reality we face when we fight for spectrum or talk about growth.”
He thinks satellite has many new opportunities in emerging markets like the internet of things, rural broadband and over-the-top content distribution, which could enhance the business model – but to achieve that, satellite players will have to protect their spectrum, and also change general perceptions that their services are “slow, expensive and complicated”, and even a “last resort option for connectivity”.
On the spectrum side, the most immediate concern for the satellite sector is the C-band. The mobile operators are calling for a global allocation of some or all of this spectrum (3.4 GHz-4.2 GHz), which so far has been regulated on a fragmented basis. Based on provisions at WRC-07, which allowed countries to make their own decisions on the band, some regions have allocated the lower portion, from 3.4 GHz to 3.8 GHz, for IMT services, while others have protected it.
Francois Rancy, director of the ITU Radiocommunication Bureau, said during a recent press conference that a regional solution might be adopted for the C-band at WRC-2015 too. That is partly because of varying practicalities in different geographies – for instance, the C-band is less easily attenuated by weather than some bands, and so is important for critical communications in tropical countries with high rainfall, a factor which could limit sharing with cellular.
Rancy said: “There was a regulatory provision to protect C-band satellite use by applying power limits to transmissions of the mobile service. That’s the regulatory solution that was found at WRC-07. It is obviously one possible option for increasing the allocation to the mobile service at the upcoming conference, or to increase the number of countries, but this, of course, is going to be the subject of difficult discussions.”
At the 2019 conference, there is expected to be far more intense focus on bands above 6 GHz, as the 5G technologies are likely to be more reliant on these frequencies for their high capacity potential. However, satellite players, and Rancy himself, caution that it will be important to look at mobile services as a whole for the 5G era, not just in terms of access – a key satellite argument against sharing or reallocation is that the C, Ku and Ka bands are used for mobile backhaul. In the Ku and Ka bands, which could be examined for sharing with cellular at WRC-19, “you will have to take into account mobile services as a whole, and not only the part relating to the link between the base stations and the user terminals – holistically how a global mobile network can build development on a sustainable basis by looking both at the infrastructure and the distribution network,” said Rancy.