The pressures on the smartphone industry continue to mount, affecting all the former stars of the sector, even Apple. The next iPhone may experience flat sales, warn analysts, while HTC has slashed its sales forecast by as much as 35% despite its high profile launches earlier this year. The market is commoditizing and up-and-coming Chinese vendors are squeezing the established players.
This sees all the traditional mobile powerhouses looking for new growth markets, mainly in the internet of things (IoT). Apple’s WWDC event (see separate items) was looking to enhance the iPhone’s position in the smart home and car, as well as music; HTC promised wearables from action cameras to virtual reality headsets at this year’s Mobile World Congress. Samsung has diverted developer resources from handsets to the IoT. And Sony is taking a rather different route, planning a smart home hub which is the result of an internal venture capital competition and crowdfunding.
According to Bloomberg sources, the hub will be the first device from the new process to hit the market, and will be closely followed by a smartwatch.
The Japanese firm has suffered a string of disastrous financial quarters because of the pressures on its TV and mobile businesses, among other factors, and like rivals such as HTC and Samsung, aims to tap into the rise of consumer IoT devices to inject new growth into its famous brand.
According to the sources, Sony has been running a series of contests between internal divisions and individuals, investing internal venture funds in the best ideas. This is the aim of the Seed Acceleration Program, set up by CEO Kazuo Hirai last year as part of a campaign to create a more innovative culture.
The scheme allows any employee to submit an idea for internal VC backing, and the first round of auditions attracted 187 ideas. The aim is to accelerate the development tof new products, outside Sony’s traditional and convoluted R&D processes, and to encourage innovation.
The Bloomberg sources said the hub, the first of the successful ideas to be commercialized, would control home appliances as well as environmental conditions like temperature, and would go on sale next month, initially in Japan.
Hirai took the helm in 2012 with a pledge to harness mobility, plus multiplay content and applications, to revive Sony’s fortunes. Like Samsung, it is also investing in some of its other activities, such as wearables-related chips, to offset handset and TV problems.
But as well as those high-capex businesses, Sony wants to behave more like a start-up, getting products to market rapidly, in response to key trends, and with limited upfront cost involved. Of course, beleaguered companies have often tried to adopt this approach – Nokia’s Linux platforms come to mind – but have rarely magicked themselves from slow-moving juggernauts into flexible innovators. However, Sony does have the advantage of a still-potent brand, and a structure geared to launching a variety of devices under a common umbrella, which should help to get new ideas off the ground.
When an idea is chosen in the first round, the originator works in a team of up to five people, which can include external contributors, and once a quarter these teams compete for funding, going through incubation and implementation stages. The resulting product could be incorporated into a mainstream Sony division or be run as an autonomous internal start-up. Sony has supported internal start-ups before, but this is the first offering to emerge from a competitive process.
The firm is also adopting new methods to finance its successful ideas, looking to supplement its own funding with an online crowdfunding campaign to help reduce upfront costs and accelerate actual production. This approach also helps raise awareness and encourage developer support, vital to the success of any consumer IoT platform, said the source.
Two other products from the Seed Acceleration Program are also seeking crowdfunding and are likely to enter mass production this month, the report said. These are a fashion watch with an e-paper face and a wristband that acts as an extension of the display; adn MESH, a family of buttons, lights and sensors which can be easily mixed and matched by developers or even consumers to create new devices and applications in the smart home. These two products have raised about $65,000 and $22,000 respectively from online crowd sources, indicating sufficient interest to get them the green light for production.
However, while such initiatives show that the handset giants will not go down quietly, they will need more than a few eye-catching IoT gadgets to offset the rapid decline in their share in handsets, which will stay the key driver of the consumer devices industry for many years to come – and if Apple has its way, will remain the controller of the IoT.
The question for companies like HTC is how quickly their core smartphone business will deteriorate, and so, whether they can possibly compensate for that with new revenue streams. The outlook remains bleak for the Taiwanese vendor, which saw its share price fall to the lowest in a decade (NT$83.60) in Taipei after it announced the reduced outlook, and said it would be forced to write off NT$2.9bn ($94m) in impaired assets.
Its second quarter revenue could now be as low as NT$33bn, compared with an earlier prediction, made on April 28, of between NT$46bn and NT$51bn. The lower sales and writedown mean HTC will post a loss for the current quarter of NT$9.70 to NT$9.94 per share, the firm said, far worse than previous analyst expectations of small positive earnings per share (NT$0.347).
HTC is suffering from the same problems which have afflicted it for the past few years, and which a series of remedies – launching the well-received HTC One superphones, reorganizing sales and other teams, engaging in heavy-duty marketing campaigns – have failed to address. It said slower demand for high end models was hitting its results, as the market shifts towards midrange devices; and that its sales in the vital China market had declined.
HTC, like Sony and others, has become a second tier player in a sector which demands massive scale, in order to achieve economies as prices and margins fall, and in order to keep carriers loyal. Apple and Samsung have those economies of scale, though even they are under pressure, and some Chinese players are acquiring them, notably Xiaomi and Lenovo. HTC and its close rivals are squeezed between the two,
“The magnitude and timing should disappoint the market and deepen investors’ concerns over rapidly deteriorating fundamentals and management credibility,” Jasmine Lu, an analyst at Morgan Stanley, wrote in client note.
Meanwhile, the smartphone market is not all smooth sailing for Apple either. Wells Fargo analysts Maynard Um, Munjal Shah and Jason Ng believe that the company has few new channels to tap for its next iPhone, since most major operators round the world are already selling its handsets, reducing growth opportunities. In addition, the analysts believe the next iPhone, expected this autumn, will be less radical than the iPhone 6 and 6 Plus and will not generate a significant increase in sales compared to that highly successful duo.
“Growth will have to come from deeper penetration at existing carriers as its current carriers account for almost 95% of the world’s total mobile subscriptions,” wrote the commentators – and of course, that is an increasing challenge, given the large numbers of models which operators – particularly the hugely important Chinese trio – have to choose from.
“Based on our research, Apple currently has deals with 414 operators globally,” said the Wells Fargo research not. “This compares with BlackBerry, which had reported 665 carriers globally at the end of 2013. However, while this suggests Apple has a significant number of carriers still left to add, we note that the remaining carriers only account for 5% of the world’s total mobile subscriptions and believe they may not all be addressable without a less expensive iPhone (approx. $250 wholesale or less).”
Apple has been under pressure for several years to launch a low cost iPhone to address the prepaid market in emerging economies, but although it did move to a two-tiered approach, the lower cost smartphones remain too expensive for the mass market in many countries, especially when those users are being targeted with increasingly functional and well-designed models from low cost vendors like Xiaomi.
Of course, Apple may choose to preserve the exclusive nature of its brand by sacrificing market share for margins, and seeking growth in other types of devices, rather than smartphones, and in generating more revenue from existing iPhone users, through innovations like the HomeKit and HealthKit frameworks, Apple Pay, and the upcoming music streaming service – expected to debut at this month’s WWDC developer event.
However, Apple may also benefit from changing distribution structures. In some markets, like India, the biggest sellers of handsets are retailers rather than operators. Wells Fargo noted: “Indian market is driven more by retail partners. We believe this is, in part, due to the multilayer distribution model that adds cost to the iPhone. As such, Apple hired a new national distributor, Brightstar, whereas prior to this, Redington was the sole distributor.”
Apple sold 74.5m iPhones in the holiday quarter and 61.2m in the first quarter of 2015, and for April, according to Counterpoint Research, the iPhone 6 and 6 Plus were the best-selling smartphones globally by units, partly because of the 6 Plus’s larger screen, which has driven new sales and upgrades. However, the Wells Fargo team think the ‘iPhone 7’ will not have the same impact and “may see deceleration given we believe the S-cycle may be cyclically weaker”. They are predicting lower sales per carrier for the next devices, one of which is expected to be called the iPhone 6S. They say that historically, the ‘iPhone xS’ models are less significant in terms of new features and so experience less dramatic adoption rates, and predict that, in the December quarter, Apple will sell about 75m iPhones – about the same as in 2014.