Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

2 July 2015

‘VoLTE Plus’ needed to address shortcomings of VoLTE, says Huawei

Voice over LTE may be just another packet of data in the IP world, but voice services remain uniquely challenging to deploy and will force operators to invest more in infrastructure from base stations to Diameter signalling routers, if they are to deliver a noticeably superior quality of service compared to Skype – which is essential if they are to have any voice-based business case at all.

Even the case they have is a thin one. For most carriers it is defensive, enabling them to cling to users who default, out of habit or loyalty, to cellular voice and messaging once they are mobile. Some argue that they will be able to add so many added-value services on top of an IMS-powered platform that they will differentiate easily from the over-the-top alternatives, but even where this proves true, only certain classes of users with business-critical requirements will be prepared to pay extra.

While the operators grapple with the ROI, as most LTE providers start to roll out or at least plan VoLTE, it will be unhelpful to hear Huawei say that, actually, they should soon be upgrading to ‘VoLTE Plus’. Ying Weimin, the Chinese firm’s president of wireless network R&D, told the recent LTE World Summit that coverage was a massive challenge for VoLTE, as well as other applications that require an unbroken connection, such as streamed video. Therefore, the company is “putting our efforts into VoLTE Plus,” he said. “In 2016 we want to input an additional 2dB gain for the uplink to improve the performance of VoLTE.”

Like a cuckoo in the nest, VoLTE threatens to divert resources from the more profitable data services with its never-ending demands for greater quality and coverage. It is driving carriers like Sprint to densify their access networks to avoid dropped calls, and at the other end of the network, it will force them to extend their IP infrastructure to ward off signalling storms, of the kind which hit the headlines when they caused 3G network outages at several major carriers, including Verizon and NTT Docomo, in 2011-12.

These incidents highlighted that signalling traffic ‘ created by ‘chatty’ applications like social network updates, which constantly poll the network, can be as burdensome as data traffic. As networks transition from legacy SS7 signalling protocols to Diameter, operators have had to invest in Diameter signalling routers to handle this new kind of traffic efficiently. VoLTE will significantly increase that burden, since any traffic that calls for advanced policy and charging rules, such as personalized QoS levels or tariffs, will add to the signalling load – and many carriers’ dreams of monetizing VoLTE rely on these tailored approaches.

In 3G, voice was handled by simpler charging and rating systems but as voice becomes another data service, and as operators look to differentiate themselves with more and more personalized customer plans, there will be a rise in signalling.

The DSR replaces huge numbers of point-to-point signals with a centralized routing hub approach, which reflects a broader shift towards centralized routing and signalling in the 4G network. However, it is imperative to the economics of VoLTE, and IP services in general, that centralization is accompanied by simplification. This was argued by several operators at LTE World Summit, as well as Pieter Veenstra, lead solutions architect and product manager at NetNumber, who proclaimed: “Complexity is your enemy … Operators need to radically simplify the network core, and that’s what we’re working on.” Without this rationalization, and a high degree of virtualization, it will be hard to manage VoLTE, with its increased signalling load, let alone the vast number of signals which the internet of things will generate.

Wendy Ooms, a senior architect of voice and mobile signaling at The Netherlands’ KPN, was open about the challenges of deploying VoLTE, telling the same audience: “On various interfaces you’ll be seeing at least a twofold growth in signaling traffic, because of VoLTE, and its need to have multiple bearers of voice and video per call. All of this traffic will be doubled again on the Diameter Routing Agent.”

In a pilot with 100 participants, KPN found that “SIP signaling can have a massive effect on the load on the mobile network if you’re not doing it right. During our trial, someone changed the IMS registration time from 50 minutes to five minutes, and the load generated absolutely exploded. SIP registration storms can occur on mobile when users lose their connection, and multiple users come flooding back when the service becomes available again.”

Where VoLTE is well implemented on a dense network, superior voice quality is generally reported compared to legacy circuit switched systems or the vagaries of OTT services. However, for most MNOs, it will be years before they achieve that kind of density over a majority of their coverage areas, and so they will have to maintain dual systems – and their customers will have to tolerate fallback to 2G/3G – for a long time, adding to cost and to QoS issues.

In some scenarios, VoWiFi is being seen as a way to fill gaps in VoLTE coverage while retaining the same IMS-delivered services and functions for the end users. Ooms, echoing similar sentiments from the UK’s EE, T-Mobile USA and others, said VoWiFi could be valuable to reach users who are not well covered by VoLTE. EE launched a native VoWiFi client last year and Vodafone UK is doing the same, while Orange recently added the function to its Libon application, allowing customers still to use their handsets for voice calls when they have no cellular connection.

All this seems to add to, rather than address, the gap between the likely revenue growth VoLTE will generate, and the rising cost of deploying it effectively. Something that may help close the gap is virtualization, since it supports more flexible targeting of network resources as well as lower reliance on expensive appliances. AT&T said a year ago that it was virtualizing the IMS to support VoLTE and running it in the cloud. Another early adopter was MTS or Russia, which has been trialling a hosted, virtualized VoLTE system run by Nokia on its telco cloud infrastructure. This offers a full virtualized voice core with IMS, Telephony Application Server and HSS.

The main players in the SIP space are taking note and bringing out NFV-enabled versions of their previously dedicated hardware products. Last year, Oracle updated its Communications Core Session Manager to support virtualization, helping to coordinate signaling between applications, policy servers and subscriber databases; and handle signaling between the network access and the edge.

But all the benefits of virtualization do not remove two hard facts about VoLTE. First, it will require carriers to intensify their RAN build-out – Jim Taiclet, CEO of American Tower, recently claimed that operators will need to increase density by 20% to 30% over time to support VoLTE, compared to circuit-switched 2G/3G voice.

And second, it will need to provide services that users genuinely want, to avoid becoming merely a cost incurred for a dying service carriers just can’t bear to let go.