Terms like beamforming and beamsteering are commonplace in WiFi, but they are highly complex and sometimes obscure technologies. Turkish WiFi specialist AirTies has added a far more prosaic, but equally compelling, concept to the list – Client Steering.
Really, this is little more than letting the network decide which access point, from a cluster of meshed APs, a client device should speak to. However, the timing of when it switches the connection, and why, is hugely significant. AirTies chairman and founder Bulent Celebi talked Wireless Watch’s sister service, Faultline, through its importance at the Connected TV Summit in London last week.
His first slide was a point in time in a Turkish apartment AirTies uses as a testbed, showing how a 20Mbps broadband signal to the home, distributed by what starts as a 96Mbps WiFi capability, soon fell to zero once it travelled through two concrete walls. The devices making the connections were older iPhones with 1×1 antenna/radio configurations.
Next stop was Hong Kong, with a 1Gbps fiber connections in a 70 square meter apartment with thinner walls. This time a top range Asus 802.11ac 3×3 MIMO device, talking to a Macbook Air also with a 3×3 antenna/radio configuration, was getting same-room throughput at 177Mbps. This fell to 108Mbps two or three walls away, but at certain points in a relatively small home, it fell to 0.8Mbps throughput, or virtually zero.
Finally he cited his own Istanbul office with 250 square meters and just stud walls. Using the same 3×3 equipment the Macbook achieved a fantastic 560Mbps in the same room, but through two walls this was down to 15Mbps and after three or four walls, it fell to zero. When a second Mac connection was added to the AP in one of the rooms, viewing a 10Mbps video, the first one fell to 320Mbps in the same room, while in other rooms rates were too low to be usable.
One of the worst things about this, says Celebi, is that when you have a tiny 1×1 client like an iPhone, the beamforming of the AP does such a good job remaining attached and stretching the connection, that when it finally breaks you have to take your device back into the room with the AP in it, to make the initial connection once again. If you stay where you are, it will just say there is no AP and fail to connect.
He then described a field trial of AirTies’ technology with an unnamed tier one US operator. It has the AirTies mesh in it, with three nodes, so effectively three APs, each using the same SSID plus some proprietary algorithms to force devices to connect to the closest AP in the home. These are the Client Steering algorithms.
These three clients are supporting a huge 25 client devices simultaneously. It is a dual-band network, so each AP has both 5 GHz and 2.4 GHz radios. About 13 devices are happy connecting to the 2.4 GHz because of a low workload, and it has a remote monitoring app on trial, which one day will show operators precisely what’s happening at a particular customers WiFi network, from way back in the NOC.
Based on real time reports from this app, it appear that all the devices on the network are happy, in that the 25 devices are ‘pushed’ into making a connection – not with the AP that has the strongest signal, but the one which is physically closest, so the connection is made with the least effort on the part of the AP, leaving it more spare capacity.
The network usage chart shows that all APs are up at just 30% air utilization, so have spare capacity, and yet at least three of these devices are watching HD video and others are also watching slightly less dense video. “We can do this on any AP, not only one using our mesh, and client steering would have applications in Enterprise Aps too,” says Celebi.
In effect, every two seconds the Airties network is taking a look at the stresses and strains on a home WiFi environment and it reallocating APs to clients based on a process of blacklisting all but one AP, so there is only one left to connect to. Obviously the system is also optimized for a client to stay on the same AP for as long as it can, as long as it does not damage the other connections.
In any other AP environment, including Wave 2 Multiuser-MIMO devices, Celebi says that, as people move around that home with 25 connected devices, any one of them, or most of them, might create ‘bad apples’ – clients operating on minimal modulation coding schemes, because their connections are bad, essentially overusing the resources of the AP they are connected to, and denying other devices bandwidth. “25 devices watching video, moving around a home, creates a perfect storm for WiFi, and this would kill any MU-MIMO device too,” he says.
In May this year AirTies won a deal with Singtel for high rise apartment blocks in Singapore, just because these client steering algorithms where on the roadmap. “They said ‘We have got to have that,’ which is why it has been prioritized and is ready for launch now,” Celebi proclaims.