Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

10 July 2015

Smartphone sector’s Q2 turmoils are not all down to China

The smartphone industry is experiencing a bad second quarter. The poor results emerging from the old-school vendors (Samsung, Sony, HTC) are partly down to competition from new rivals, but not entirely – even Chinese superstar Xiaomi has failed to hit some of its targets so far this year and has seen sales growth slow since the glory days of Q414. And tablets are certainly not compensating for handset slowdown in the way their manufacturers once hoped.

There are bigger forces at work than single-quarter issues like Samsung’s apparent miscalculation of the number of curved screens it needed for its new flagship, the Galaxy S6 Edge. Upgrade cycles are lengthening as consumers divert their disposable cash towards other devices like wearables, and as operators in mature markets dump subsidies; China is reaching near-saturation of its smartphone base; globally, the pool of featurephones to upgrade is reducing; price wars are affecting everybody’s margins.

“Vendors in China will have to win replacement buyers and improve the appeal of their premium offerings to attract upgrades,” Gartner analyst Annette Zimmermann said in a statement, as the research firm forecast slower than expected growth across the consumer electronics space, including PCs, tablets and smartphones (the firm has reduced its shipments growth predictions from 2.8% to 1.5% for 2015, with cellphones slowing to 3.3% growth).

All this is already showing in the big vendors’ performance, increasing the pressure for them to seek new sales and higher profits in other categories – in chips, for instance, for Samsung and Sony; in wearables and smart home devices for just about everybody, even Apple (which is somewhat immune to the factors depressing the smartphone segment, but not entirely).

Tablets are certainly not the cure that they were expected to be after the launch of the first iPad five years ago. If smartphone upgrade cycles have lengthened, those for tablets have always been long, given that they are considered luxury, rather than essential, items, and are usually unsubsidised (often WiFi-only). In the past year, even sales of the iPad itself have slowed, which highlights just how hard it is to come up with a new form factor with anything like the growth potential of the smartphone (the smartwatch won’t be that magic device either, as the Apple Watch’s early sales pattern indicates – see separate item).

Against this gloomy backdrop, Samsung announced that it expects its seventh quarter in a row with a year-on-year profit decline, with smartphone pressures the main cause. This is particularly concerning for the Korean giant because Q215 was meant to be the time when the new Galaxy S6 and S6 Edge restored its fortunes. The latter model managed to do something very rare these days, and offer a genuinely new design and user experience – but its curved edges make the screen difficult to produce and Samsung said it had struggled to meet demand.

That is a nice problem to have, compared to the lukewarm consumer uptake of some apparently well-designed smartphones, like the HTC One. HTC reported a Q215 loss of $260m – after four straight quarters when it was back in the black – and said it was closing some of its manufacturing/assembly facilities because of falling sales. These were particularly blamed on low demand for its high end models, like the One M9, as well as weak performance in China.

However, Samsung needs to address its supply issue quickly, before the next big thing hits smartphone markets and eclipses the S6 Edge. The company expects to report operating profit down 4% year-on-year to about KRW6.9 trillion ($6.1bn), below analyst expectations, on sales which will also fall short at KRW48 trillion ($42.3bn), down 8.4% on the year-ago quarter. Analysts had looked for KRW53 trillion.

Sources told The Wall Street Journal that Samsung initially expected to sell four Galaxy S6 smartphones for every S6 Edge, because the latter is $100 more expensive, and it planned around that, but in fact saw demand split about equally between the two handsets, leading to excess inventory of the S6 and shortages of the Edge.

The Korean firm has better resources than most rivals to address such issues, given its high level of control over its supply chain and its broad-based production and distribution facilities. It says it righted the supply problems as of the end of June, reorganizing its plants, mainly in Vietnam, to focus on the S6 Edge and its screen. That could help drive a recovery in Samsung’s results in the second half of this year.

Analysts estimate the company shipped 71m to 76m smartphones in the second quarter, with the two Galaxy S6 phones accounting for just over 20% of the total.

Meanwhile, one beleaguered smartphone vendor is refusing to contemplate defeat. Sony, which has been repeatedly rumored to be planning an exit from cellphones, insisted this week that it would “never ever” give up on the handset market. The main reason is that smartphones are essential to connect to many other devices, increasingly acting as a hub or controller for smart home, connected car and audiovisual products.

“Smartphones are completely connected to other devices, also connected to people’s lives, deeply,” Sony Mobile Communications’ CEO Hiroki Totoki told Arabian Business magazine. “The opportunity for diversification is huge. We’re heading to the IoT era and have to produce a number of new categories of products in this world, otherwise we could lose out on a very important business domain In that sense we will never ever sell or exit from the current mobile business.”

This seems to contradict remarks made in February by Sony CEO Kazuo Hirai that he would “not rule out considering an exit strategy” for Sony’s mobile and TV units. According to Gartner, Sony was only the tenth global smartphone player in 2014, with 37.8m smartphones sold, about the same as in 2013. But Totoki insists the worst is behind Sony. He said the huge loss that Sony’s mobile unit made in 2014 was largely an accounting issue, caused by the writedown of goodwill, because of the high price the Japanese company paid in 2012 for Ericsson’s 50% stake in their former joint venture. “We had to write it down and it made a substantial loss for the company. But this was an accounting loss and did not impact our cashflow. Our cash flow is very healthy,” he said.

Last fall Sony took goodwill impairment charges of around $1.44bn on the mobile unit. For the current fiscal year, that unit expects an operating loss of around $319m, while the company as a whole forecasts an operating profit of $2.6bn.