A few weeks ago, Orange revealed plans to increase revenues from its Middle Eastern and African (MEA) operations by 20% between now and 2018. The French telco has always been the most active of the European majors in the MEA region, but in a price sensitive area, that 20% figure will not be achieved organically. In that speech, MEA chief Marc Rennard hinted that Orange was looking for acquisitions, and it is now reported to be in exclusive talks to buy four African business units from India’s Bharti Airtel.
Airtel confirmed that it is exploring the sale of its subsidiaries in Burkina Faso, Chad, Congo Brazzaville and Sierra Leone to Orange, and according to India’s Economic Times, the price would be between $900m and $1bn.
Earlier this month, Orange created a new holding company for its MEA operations, which deputy CEO Ramon Fernandez described as “the basis for our future development in Africa and the Middle East,” adding: “We are in a position to consider adding, on a selective basis, some assets, if we find the right price.”
However, it appears to be concentrating its efforts in fewer markets – particularly the francophone ones in north and west Africa. It recently agreed to sell its business in Uganda (an English-speaking nation in east Africa) to Africell and is thought to be mulling an exit from Kenya, where Orange has complained about an “unacceptable” regulatory climate and the dominance of leader Safaricom (a Vodafone joint venture).
The four Airtel operations in Orange’s sights conform to its new criteria and three have French as an official language. They are all new markets for the French firm, and achieved a combined EBITDA of almost $180m in the financial year to March 31. But there are warnings for Orange in Airtel’s experience in Africa. It entered the region in 2010 when it acquired subsidiaries in 15 countries from Zain (for $9bn plus $1.7bn in debt). It has since moved into two further countries, but its African adventure has hit its profits, resulting in an $183m regional loss in the fourth fiscal quarter.
It also reported a 12.6% year-on-year revenue decline in the same quarter in Africa, despite attracting 10% more subscribers, indicating how tough it will be for Orange to hit its 20% target in an area of declining ARPUs.
Orange will be relying on economies of scale, and cross-border efficiencies, as well as its global purchasing power, to get better results than Airtel. It has long experience in the continent, and is building up massive scale there. It is currently active in 20 MEA nations, and has 110m customers there. This puts its ahead of Airtel, which recently became the world’s third largest MNO by subscriber numbers (though that ranking may revert to China Unicom if Airtel reduces its position in Africa). The Indian firm has 76m customers across 18 African markets. The second largest MNO, Vodafone, is also active in the region, particularly via Safaricom and its South Africa-based multinational joint venture, Vodacom.
One of Orange’s plans to reduce costs involves creating an integrated, virtualized network monitoring system across multiple markets. In the first phase, networks in 10 countries will be managed from two centers in Dakar (Senegal) and Abidjan (Cote d’Ivoire). That could be extended to the Airtel assets if a deal is concluded. Orange also engages in network sharing to reduce costs and Rennard is keen to increase the sharing of towers and masts. “It’s a bit surprising that we are used to sharing submarine cable and we don’t easily share the inland infrastructure. Why? I don’t know,” he said recently. However, unlike some African players including Airtel itself, and MTN, Orange is not planning to sell off its towers.
In fact, Orange has higher EBITDA in the MEA region, despite its price pressures, than in the group as a whole (33% versus 31%) in the first quarter of 2015. In that period, it reported MEA sales of €1.1bn ($1.2bn), up 6.8% year-on-year and accounting for 11.6% of its total revenues. It is targeting an increase in both these figures, by harnessing rising use of value added services, more than by adding new subscribers. Particularly important are mobile money, enterprise data services and mobile messaging. For instance, Rennard aims to boost m-money revenues from about €50m ($78m) last year to around €200m ($312m) in 2018.
“They have two types of markets in Africa,” Guy Zibi, chief analyst at Heavy Reading’s MEA unit Xalam Analytics. “In some of the smaller ones in west Africa, the penetration is still low and there is room for expansion, but larger markets like Morocco and Senegal are becoming a challenge.”