Apple’s Silicon Valley neighbors are ganging up on it and supporting Samsung in the smartphone giants’ long-running patents battle.
A group of companies including Google, Facebook, eBay, Hewlett-Packard and Dell filed a motion earlier this month with the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, backing Samsung’ bid to have patent infringement damages reduced or dropped altogether.
Initial damages of over $1bn were awarded in 2012 when Apple won its San Jose jury case – the most significant of a long series around the world, in which the score card has been mixed. In March 2013 Judge Lucy Koh ruled this figure was excessive and cut it by $450.5m but later that year, another jury added an extra $290.5m. Earlier this year, the Court of Appeals reduced that figure again, from $930m to $548m, but last month, Samsung asked for a further reduction.
The US companies – rather belatedly, given that Apple’s initial court victory was almost three years ago – claim that, if the damages are allowed to stand, there will be a damaging knock-on effect on other vendors, which may be deterred from investing in R&D. Their petition is an amicus curiae (friend of the court) brief, which is only a symbolic statement of support, but can nevertheless influence judges’ rulings.
The petition, originally uncovered by Inside Sources and reported in the UK’s Guardian newspaper, argues that Apple’s victory concerned only minor innovations, and that modern technology is made up of a huge number of components, many of which are used in multiple products. If the use of any of these components might turn into a lawsuit, companies will be scared away from developing new products for fear of infringement.
“That feature – a result of a few lines out ofms of code – may appear only during a particular use of the product, on one screen display among hundreds. But the panel’s decision could allow the owner of the design patent to receive all profits generated by the product or platform, even if the infringing element was largely insignificant to the user,” the brief states.
It adds: “If allowed to stand, that decision will lead to absurd results and have a devastating impact on companies…who spendbns of dollars annually on research and development for complex technologies and their components”
Google’s support for the largest Android device vendor is a given, and indeed, the search giant has previously been seen helping Samsung behind the scenes of various legal actions. Samsung, and other Android OEMs targeted by Apple’s lawyers, were widely seen as proxies for Google itself, though the two dominant mobile OS providers have generally steered clear of direct conflicts in court.
And though the rest of the coalition may be uneasy bedfellows, each has a reason to fear Apple’s power in services (Facebook and eBay) and hardware (the PC makers). They may also fear the setting of a precedent which could increase their own exposure to lawsuits from rivals or trolls. “The panel’s decision in this case regarding the appropriate measure of damages for the infringement of design patents will have significant ramifications for [the companies filing the brief] and the technology industry more generally,” the brief reads.
In May, the appeals court upheld earlier rulings over Apple’s intellectual property, but reversed the verdict that Samsung violated Apple’s ‘trade dress’ (the way a product is packaged and presented). This resulted in an order for a lower court to review the $382m in damages that related to trade dress, which could now be thrown out. The group of petitioners wants that to be confirmed, and wants the other decisions overturned too.
Apple and Samsung are also involved in another US case, in which Apple is seeking a court ruling to force Samsung to remove some features from Galaxy handsets. That is not involved in the current discussion. The non-US spats between Apple and Samsung have been settled, but their US fight drags on, despite successive attempts at arbitration. Neither company is commenting on the Google-led petition.