As the wave of operators deploying VoLTE (voice over LTE) round the world finally surges, WiFi Calling is getting ever-closer to a true mobile experience. The IMS-based WiFi voice technology could arm wireline carriers with a new weapon in building WiFi-first offerings to threaten the MNOs, but it is also being heavily used by those mobile carriers to fill the gaps in their VoLTE systems.
In all these cases, though, evidence of a direct business model for voice is thin on the ground. As over-the-top alternatives like Skype improve in functionality and quality, and are being integrated right into mobile platforms, carrier voice is looking increasingly defensive – something operators can’t quite bring themselves to abandon, because users expect to have the voice option, even if they rarely use it and don’t pay for it; or because they are dreaming of building a rich set of services, particularly for business users, around IP communications.
The latter route has some potential – technologies like RCS (Rich Communications Services) have shown how mobile operators can emulate the IP-based functions of enterprise systems, such as video calling and unified mailboxes, and a single number for all connections. However, the OTT systems are including these features too, so it remains questionable how much business users will be willing to pay for enhanced VoLTE, especially when suppliers like Cisco are adding mobile-first support to platforms such as Webex.
The mobile operators will not give up their traditional fatted calf willingly though, and that means pushing as quickly as possible towards VoLTE, now it is finally in the commercial mainstream, and away from the compromises of circuit-switched fallback.
The first phase of VoLTE roll-outs was largely seen in the US and Korea, and the latter, as usual, provides a gold standard for how the 4G voice platform can be placed at the heart of a rich array of added value, IP-based services, whether built around the GSMA’s RCS or the carrier’s own platforms. But few operators elsewhere are likely to be able to justify such high investment in the voice/communications system, and many of the second-wave VoLTE projects are looking more like tick-box exercises, with costs kept low by filling gaps with WiFi Calling.
According to the GSA (Global mobile Suppliers Association), VoLTE is currently available from 25 operators in 16 countries, including the US, Japan, Korea, Italy, Spain, Germany, Hong Kong, Singapore, Indonesia and Canada.
As deployments mount up, operators in competitive countries like the UK will not even have a very long period to differentiate themselves around VoLTE. 3UK succeeded in getting to market first, but Vodafone and EE are not far behind (and have their own new services, which may well appeal more than VoLTE to consumers and business users).
3UK’s new service is branded 4G Super-Voice and is available at no extra cost – the Achilles’ heel of VoLTE, which is expensive and complicated to deploy, especially if the carrier does not already have an IMS, but has no direct additional revenue attached. Carriers will have to hope that the improved voice and messaging experience, and the (also expensive) advertising of the new facility, will both attract and retain subscribers, and tempt them away from Skype and onto higher usage cellular plans.
The UK’s fourth MNO is running VoLTE on its 800 MHz spectrum, which it is deploying for the first time since acquiring the licences in the 2013 auction. This spectrum will also help improve indoor penetration and wide area coverage for its 4G network, which has previously been focused on higher density areas.
At launch, 4G Super-Voice is available to 50% of the population, including 75% of the citizens of London, Edinburgh, Exeter and Birmingham. The company has also begun rolling out VoLTE in Cardiff, Manchester and Liverpool, with the aim of providing 65% population coverage by the end of the year.
“By the end of the year, one million of our customers will have access to better indoor coverage and be able to use their phones in more places than ever before,” said CTO Bryn Jones, in a statement, and that figure should rise to 5.5m by 2017. Customers with supported handsets will be able to use VoLTE via a software update, though initially only the Samsung Galaxy S5 works with the service. Other devices, including the new iPhones, will be added later this year.
WiFi Calling is proving, counter-intuitively, an important tool for VoLTE providers. It allows them to reduce total cost of 4G voice deployment since it can be used to fill gaps in coverage – at least for users who are not moving around while calling. That means a carrier can avoid the biggest economic challenge of rolling out a voice network, the need to achieve wide coverage on day one. Instead, VoLTE build-out can be staggered, and targeted at areas of high value like business centers, and gaps can be filled with WiFi Calling or, for mobility, CSFB.
As with data, there is an offload element to voice too, and carriers may move lower value voice and messaging traffic to WiFi in order to preserve the QoS of VoLTE, and minimize the amount of spectrum they need to use for increasingly unprofitable voice services.
The Hutchison subsidiary also offers a WiFi Calling app called Three InTouch, although unlike rival offerings this is not integrated with the phone dialler.
3UK will not have the VoLTE market to itself for long. EE had planned to launch the service earlier this year but has now delayed that, though it could still go live before year-end. Like 3UK, this will mark the first time it will use its 800 MHz spectrum, which offers superior coverage to support voice – it currently relies on 1.8 GHz with fallback, as well as its newly launched WiFi Calling.
And Vodafone is testing VoLTE on its live network. It has also missed its initial target of launching commercially during the summer, highlighting the technical challenges of rolling out this technology. Vodafone has not offered a revised timing, just saying: “We will provide a further update on our launch plans soon.” The other UK MNO, Telefonica O2, is less urgent about 4G voice, and will only start its trials of VoLTE during the current quarter.
Tom Bennett, director of network services and devices at EE, told Telecoms.com that the VoLTE launch was close. “Our VoLTE service is now live, for a multiuser, multi-device internal trial,” he said. “We’ve been testing it with a small group for the last few months, and the larger trial will help us optimize the network to reach the necessary performance. We will make VoLTE available to our customers when the reliability of the service is as good as our current voice service. We’ll only launch a new voice service when it’s on a par with, or better than, what customers are currently using. Ultimately, we can get VoLTE to a dropped call rate of just 0.1%, but it’s not there yet and voice is the thing on your network that you have to protect the most.” That has entailed waiting for the activation of the 800 MHz spectrum, which supports better coverage and indoor reception.
The interview indicated that, for many operators, VoLTE is more about network efficiency than new revenues or customer loyalty. Bennett said CSFB was performing well and EE supports HD Voice on 3G, so “for us, VoLTE is about being more efficient with how we manage traffic in our network – LTE is inherently more efficient than 3G.”
EE and Vodafone have both launched WiFi Calling, and this will become more functional thanks to a new announcement from Ericsson, which has added multi-device functionality. That will support simultaneous calls over several devices, and the ability to transfer a call between devices while in progress – a critical disadvantage of VoWiFi compared to cellular. This will be a significant step forward in WiFi voice functionality for MNOs or WiFi-only providers, and will be commercially deployed by year end, says the vendor.
Ericsson’s WiFi Calling suite taps into the evolved packet core, IMS, user data management and OSS/BSS platforms to add value. “While natively integrated WiFi Calling in smartphones has been commercially available for some time, both consumers and operators can benefit from extending this functionality to multiple devices,” the OEM’s head of product area network functions, Andres Olin, said.
In its latest UK Mobile Consumer report, Deloitte said it expects to see a growing proportion of calls carried over VoWiFi, VoLTE and over-the-top VoIP. “OTT VoIP may impact operators’ bottom line in the long term. However, VoLTE could offset a potential decline in revenue, even if consumers do not end up paying more for VoLTE services,” the research company said.
However, other innovations on EE’s network are likely to prove more important to customer awareness and the business model than voice. The company is trialling 4K video on its LTE network, as it moves increasingly into the rich content environment even before its proposed merger with BT. And last week, the UK’s largest MNO launched an LTE machine-to-machine service called EE Connect.
This is a management platform for provisioning and monitoring connected devices and M2M applications.
“Every day, the strength and reliability of our 4G network allows businesses to develop innovative connected products and services that improve our lives,” said Gerry McQuade, chief marketing and sales officer at EE Business, in a statement.
EE ended the second quarter with 2.1m M2M connections, up 13.6% on the year-ago period. It is targeting EE Connect with increasing that number to over 4m by 2017 when it will have 90% LTE coverage in the UK.
However, it is playing catch-up with Vodafone, which is the world leader in M2M services, according to Machina Research, followed by AT&T.