Europe’s 5G initiatives are coming thick and fast now, with the 3GPP poised to kick off its own next generation standards process, and key decisions looming at November’s World Radio Conference. Ericsson has announced a 5G for Europe initiative just two days after the UK’s 5G Innovation Centre (5GIC)- heavily backed by Ericsson arch-rival Huawei – officially opened its doors. But such efforts are still clouded by uncertainties about which new spectrum will be usable and available – many eyes are on high frequency millimeter wave bands, but technical and regulatory issues are likely to persist for several more years.
Ericsson’s program brings together the usual range of academic, industry, public sector and research partners and will focus on projects to define and test real world applications that will be enabled by 5G. It is an expansion of the company’s 5G for Sweden initiative, launched earlier this year.
The big aim is to strengthen the competiveness of European business, said the company. The European Commission, and local vendors like Ericsson and Nokia, believe this will be enhanced if the region can regain the influential position in wireless standards which it held in 2G and 3G. Having lost the initiative to the US and China in 4G, there are many efforts, at EC level and driven by individual governments or vendors, to put Europe in the vanguard of 5G development and deployment.
Ericsson said its new program would “enable industries to digitalize effectively, to create new value and to strengthen the competitive position of European industry”. It will create cross-industry R&D collaborations to integrate IT and wireless into all kinds of processes and services, in order to drive innovative new business models.
Ericsson CTO Ulf Ewaldsson said in a statement: “5G is the next step in the evolution of mobile communication and will be a fundamental enabler of the Networked Society. However, Ericsson needs to work together with industries to understand their specific network requirements in order to realize the full benefits of 5G technologies.”
The networks giant hopes to attract small companies too, and to help them secure early access to new technology at an affordable price, so they can accelerate time-to-market for their inventions and interact with academic research.
‘5G for Europe’ will also deliver industry pilots of potential 5G-enabled solutions in areas including transport and automotive, the internet of things, utilities, public safety, public infrastructure and retail. This sounds reassuringly grounded in real business requirements, though the line-up of participants – many already working with Ericsson on other projects – is initially rather weighted towards academia.
Sign-ups include universities such as Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna in Pisa, Italy; Technische Universität Dresden, Germany; Universidad Carlos III and IMDEA Networks Institute, both in Madrid, Spain; and King’s College, London, UK. However, only four industry partners have been named so far – wiseSense, Weiss Robotics and MyOmega System Technology in Germany and Zucchetti Centro Sistemi in Italy.
While London University is the UK partner in Ericsson’s program, the University of Surrey, 27 miles south of the capital, has the highest profile role in the country’s 5G activities. It announced plans for a national 5G Innovation Centre last year and that has now opened its doors, housing 170 researchers. So far, the centre is backed to the tune of £70m ($108m), £12m from the UK government.
The university claims the 5GIC is “the world’s largest academic research centre dedicated to next generation mobile and wireless connectivity”.
Its director, Professor Rahim Tafazolli, followed the usual line on 5G – that it needs to focus on far more than another speed hike. He said: “While we have already achieved record-breaking speeds, 5G is not only about delivering faster mobile internet. It is a transformative set of technologies that will radically change our private and professional lives by enabling innovative applications and services, such as remote healthcare, wireless robots, driverless cars and connected homes and cities, removing boundaries between the real and cyber worlds.
The partners are international, though one aim of the 5GIC is to create intellectual capital, standards influence and economic benefit for UK companies. All four mobile operators (EE, O2, Vodafone and 3UK) plus BT are taking part, along with the BBC and the regulator Ofcom. The main network vendors involved are Huawei, Fujitsu and Samsung, along with testing providers Rohde & Schwarz and Anite. Other participants are HEFCE, Enterprise M3, Teoco, Cobham, Ascom, Catapult Digital, Roke, McLaren Applied Technologies, Imagination Technologies, ITRI, MYCOM OSI and Ordnance Survey.
The 5GIC has a testbed which is currently based on LTE-Advanced but will be upgraded to 5G as those candidate technologies are clarified, achieving 10Gbps speeds by 2018. An IoT simulator is also planned.
Payam Taaghol, CEO of performance management provider MYCOM OSI, said in an interview with Telecoms.com: “It is significant that service assurance is playing an important part of the innovation around 5G and not being left as an afterthought. The major challenges with a 5G ‘testbed’ network are twofold. First, ensuring that as new 5G elements are designed and introduced into the network, their impact on existing 2G/3G/4G networks is fully understood … Second, there is little value in innovation for innovation’s sake – it has to improve the end user experience. “
Millimeter wave spectrum is one of the ways in which vendors and operators believe they will be able to add significant capacity to 5G networks in order to support that new user experience. This will be an important focus in Surrey, as in other 5G projects, but Tafazolli warned at the 5GIC opening that industry groups will not be able to invest heavily in R&D in this area until the ITU decides on its plans for the spectrum, which will not happen until the 2019 World Radio Conference, which will focus on 5G.
“We do have some activities in this area and are finishing channel measurements, but you do not want to invest a lot of resources in different bands, and it would be good to know what to focus on,” he said at the media briefing. “It looks as though the candidate bands will be between 40 GHz and 60 GHz and we will mobilize resources when we have more certainty. The majority of our work now is applicable to frequencies below 6 GHz.”
Millimeter wave spectrum is seen as a way to enable ultra-dense networks of very small cells, adding high capacity for technologies like Ultra-HD video, as well as being appropriate to new IoT services. The main work so far has been in licence-exempt 60 GHz, where there is a working standard, the WiFi-based WiGig. These high frequencies have also been used for proprietary licensed and unlicensed fixed wireless and backhaul technologies.
Current uses are mainly focused on small cell backhaul (a nascent market), fixed wireless services (once a bubble, but now largely a dead model), and in-home video streaming or other high speed applications (WiGig). But in 5G, supporters believe the use of these frequencies could be extended greatly on the access front.
Several vendors, such as Samsung, are focusing heavily on millimeter wave in their 5G R&D programs, despite the acknowledged uncertainties. And a new program, also UK-based, will explore this area. The €7.3m XHaul Project will be based in Bristol in southwest England, and will focus on backhaul technologies, both millimeter wave and fiber. It is one of many initiatives under the umbrella of the European Commission’s 5G Infrastructure Public Private Partnership (5G-PPP).
The project will use millimeter wave (mmW) modems from Blu Wireless along with fiber optic components in a trial network that will target sub-1ms latency and speeds of up to 10Gbps, by 2018. The test network will be heavily software-defined, using the OpenFlow protocol as a control mechanism.
Field trials are already underway with Huawei, Telefonica I+D, TES Electronic Solutions, the University of Bristol and others.
“Backhaul is a major pain point in networks, so with 5G we want to make sure that it is done more efficiently,” said Mark Barrett, CMO at Blu Wireless. The firm’s current offering is a 60 GHz modem based on its Hydra PHY/MAC with a phased array antenna.
But Barrett warned that the regulatory regime in Europe was difficult for mmWave, especially when compared with the US. Europe currently requires that antenna gain must exceed +30 dBi and conducted power must be under +10 dBm, according to EETimes, which can affect interference. Blu Wireless says its baseband DSP uses a “hybrid software/hardware architecture based on parallel processor techniques” to reduce interference.
The difficulties in these bands were also outlined in a recent FCC filing by Nokia, which highlighted narrow beamwidths, provided by high dimension arrays; high penetration loss; diminished diffraction; and acquiring and tracking user devices within the cell using a narrow beam antenna. Other issues relate to the need for line of sight for mmWave devices, so Nokia pointed to the challenges of mitigating shadowing with base station diversity or by rapidly rerouting around obstacles.
Despite the obstacles, large and small organizations are investing in mmWave R&D. This interest could benefit start-ups in the area. One of those, Siklu, recently secured an $18m Series D round of funding, eyeing wireless gigabit-to-the-home (GTTH) technologies. The firm has raised a total of $50m. It currently makes wireless small cell backhaul systems in the 60 GHz, 70 GHz and 80 GHz bands, and it partners with Alcatel-Lucent in this area. However, it wants to go beyond backhaul into high speed, short range access and believes this will be a building block for 5G.
Another mmWave effort was recently announced by SK Telecom and Samsung, which have included the technology in the operator’s 5G testbed in its Bundang R&D site in Korea.
And in the US, Samsung, Nokia and others are asking the FCC to consider licensing various mmWave bands for 5G, responding to the regulator’s request for comments on this topic. Samsung recommends opening up the LMDS Band (27.5-28.35 GHz, 29.1-29.25 GHz and 31-31.3 GHz), as well as the 32 GHz, 39 GHz, 37-41 GHz and 60 GHz bands for future 5G services. Nokia wants the FCC to consider 71-76 GHz and 81-86 GHz, along with other mmWave options.
In a recent filing, Nokia argues that 5G needs both licensed and unlicensed spectrum, like 3G and 4G, and insists that licensed spectrum is necessary for investment, considering the model for carrier-grade licence-exempt networks remains “unproven”.