The European Commission has two months to decide whether to allow the takeover of Telefonica’s O2 UK arm by CK Hutchison, owner of 3UK, and if it does, what conditions will be imposed. One of the most likely demands will be for the merged entity to divest some of its infrastructure for a new entrant, or at least to earmark a large proportion of its capacity for new MVNOs – these kind of remedies have already been seen in other markets where a merger led to a reduction in the number of MNOs, such as Germany, Ireland and Austria.
CK Hutchison, for its part, is offering increasingly big concessions – as well guarantees to open up wholesale access, freeze consumer prices and step up infrastructure investments, it went even further in its annual results statement last week, saying it would be prepared to keep O2 and 3UK as separate operations, as long as it was allowed to sell a stake in the enlarged company to a new investor. (Last May, shortly after first agreeing the O2 takeover, Hutchison announced a deal to sell a 33% stake in the combined business to five institutional investors for £3.1bn on clearance of the merger.)
For all this flexibility, there is still a real prospect that the deal will be blocked – or more likely, that the conditions imposed by the EC will be so onerous that Hutchison will walk away, as happened to TeliaSonera and Telenor in Denmark.
But perhaps, in focusing on separating its subsidiaries, Hutchison, and the European Commission, are barking up the wrong tree. Hutchison sees 3 Group as a key player in Europe’s ongoing consolidation, especially as the unit is starting to deliver results from its parent’s long and patient game of investment and acquisition. Last week, the company announced that 3 Europe’s EBITDA had risen by 12% year-on-year in fiscal 2015, to HK$17.4bn ($2.2bn), though revenue fell by 4% (however, in local currencies, revenue would have risen by 10%, it said).
One factor improving its margins has been greater scale following its purchases in Ireland and Austria. Now it says a UK deal, as well as its plan for an Italian merger with VimpelCom’s Wind, would “create sufficient scale and capacity for delivering significant operational efficiencies and enhancing network quality and innovations in these markets, and in turn, generating accretive earnings to the group”.
However, it could achieve even better scale through its wholesale activities. The idea that strong competition is only ensured by having a reasonable number of companies deploying their own mobile networks is an old-fashioned one. Competition, as the over-the-top players have demonstrated, rests in services more than in networks. Some MNOs remain focused on achieving competitive edge through their networks, via superior quality of experience, but increasingly the economics of the one network/one operator model will make this non-viable for most players – especially the new entrants that competition regulators are keen to enable, often with scant regard for whether they can afford the vast costs of spectrum and infrastructure.
It will become more common for operators to differentiate their QoE via software – for instance, using ‘always best connected’ systems to transfer users to the optimal link, even on a WiFi or third party network; enhancing the intelligence in the packet core, edge gateways and BSS, and virtualizing those elements to increase agility; supporting hyper-personalization via big data. In that context, the cost of the actual network, with regard to the differentiation it delivers, will become excessive and MNOs will increasingly look to share their build-outs, or turn to neutral hosts to expand their coverage and capacity; and at the same time, to generate more revenues from a wider range of MVNOs and wholesale customers, to offset the declining profits of consumer data.
All this suggests that the EC should pursue the open MVNO platform more aggressively, when it considers merger proposals, than the totem of ‘four MNOs per market’. And that suggests Hutchison itself should step up its own wholesale and network-on-demand activities, and give one of its potential crown jewels, the Hue MVNE (mobile virtual network enabler) a far more strategic role.
Hutchison launched Hue a year ago and it was immediately rumored to be the future basis of expanding Google’s US-based Fi MVNO around the world. Hue, like other MVNE services, offers a single point of entry for MVNOs which want to “create global coverage quickly and easily” across Europe and Asia. Parent group Hutchison Whampoa operates, via various subsidiaries, in Austria, Australia, Denmark, Hong Kong, Indonesia, Italy, Ireland, Macau, Sri Lanka, Sweden, UK and Vietnam, and it will also look for deals with other MNOs outside that footprint.
“Today’s mobile wholesale market is fragmented and new entrants to mobile are often challenged with needing to understand market nuances and regulations in different countries,” said Jarrod Nink, CEO of Hue, at the time. Services to MVNOs will include mobile network access, customer care, billing and provisioning, as well as liaison with third parties such as credit agencies.
It is easy to see how such operations could evolve into more flexible, marketplace-style virtualized platforms in future, bringing the traditional MVNE out of the shadows and into the starring role in the network of am MVNOs.
Some vendors are certainly developing the kind of tools which will enable this. XCellAir, a new company formed to market a network-as-a-service platform created by InterDigital, will start by providing tools to manage bandwidth across WiFi and/or cellular small cells, but has a far broader vision of a virtualized NWaaS future. In 2013, Amdocs unveiled a platform to help smaller MNOs set up and provision MVNOs far more quickly and flexibly. And back in 2010, Redknee offered some hints about the future with the announcement of Redknee Cloud, a fully hosted billing/customer care system for supporting MVNOs on an on-demand basis.
Such roots will grow far more quickly when combined with the emerging technologies of virtualized, hosted and cloud-based back office systems. These will start by making it far quicker and cheaper for network owners to set up MVNOs, and will end up by placing the real power in the mobile access business in the hands of the cloud provider, which will often not be the MNO. Companies like AT&T and Hutchison aim to perform both those roles, but they will need to watch out for Google, Amazon, Microsoft, HPE and IBM.
Hutchison, however, has the resources, and the boldness, to invest in the cloud platforms to provide an end-to-end network as-a-service offering to rival those envisaged by the IT and web giants. Combined with its MNO units, this could deliver far greater business expansion than acquiring additional mobile capacity and customer base in individual European markets like Ireland, Austria and potentially the UK. It could be a truly global activity which could support new revenue streams for those MNOs but also provide a way to do business in other markets, via a web of partnerships – a sort of club of national MNOs which could rival the multinational giants in coverage, but with a wholesale focus that would support an entirely different cost base, minus the customer acquisition and support costs of the retail-focused operators.
Carriers which are not in the premier league, globally or in the largest mobile markets, need to think this laterally if they are not to be merely also-rans, squeezed between the infrastructure scale of the biggest MNOs and the agility of the OTT challengers. Sprint was thinking in this way a decade ago, aiming to out-manoeuver AT&T and Verizon with a heavily wholesale-driven model and by sitting at the heart of a mesh of partnerships with web, cable and wireless providers. It lacked the technologies or the corporate drive to achieve its goals, but Hutchison, with its deep pockets, and armed with emerging technologies like virtualization, could be a different story.
An expanded Hue activity for the Hutchison group would fit well into the changing landscape of mobile network deployment and control. This is detailed in the latest data module within Rethink Technology Research’s RAN data service, which offers five-year forecasts in highly targeted topics, based on surveys of over 100 mobile operators about their infrastructure and service plans. The latest is entitled ‘Mobile network ownership and MVNO/wholesale models’ and is published next week (for details please email John Constant on [email protected]).
The findings reflect that the economics of traditional mobile network ownership are becoming extremely tough – so much so that less than half (44%) of macrocells will be deployed and managed by a sole MNO by 2020, and even fewer small cells (22%). Instead, the cells will be built and managed on a shared basis, or by third parties (neutral host providers and non-MNOs such as cablecos, often harnessing new shared or lightly licensed spectrum).
The traditional model, in which a single company invested in exclusive spectrum licences and then built its own network single-handed, is under strain now the capacity of that network needs to be increased almost constantly to keep up with user demand.
Added to that, to achieve return on investment at all, operators need to support a wider range of revenue generating services, to compensate for the worsening ratio between capacity expansion and consumer willingness to pay for data – not to mention the diversion of their spending towards over-the-top providers. But to support the more promising new services – from enterprise grade voice/rich communications to smart cities to the Internet of Things – operators need to take on a new variety of competitors, and to invest still further in their networks.
At the access level, the mobile networks need to behave very differently to support the ultra-low latency and power, and the ultra-high coverage, required by many IoT applications. And the bigger the range of services the operator needs to deliver to its diversifying base, the more complex its IT systems need to be, to support flexible, on-demand billing, service delivery, policy enforcement, security, and the agile launch of new offerings.
Emerging technologies such as virtualization will certainly help, but all these demands on the operators’ purse mean that the single-MNO network will increasingly become a thing of the past as the market moves towards 5G.The capital and operating costs will increasingly be shared, sometimes with direct RAN sharing deals, but also with broader support for wholesale and MVNO models, with rising use of unlicensed spectrum, and with reliance on third party neutral hosts to expand into new areas, especially indoors.
Many operators have been hesitant to pursue RAN sharing, neutral host or extensive MVNOs, fearing that they were enabling their competitors – lowering the barriers to next generation networks for other MNOs, and providing the infrastructure for non-spectrum owners, such as cable or OTT operators, to move into mobile and multiplay services themselves.
But increasingly, MNOs see those new challengers finding other ways, such as WiFi-first, to add wireless services to their portfolios, and the benefits of tapping them for revenue are starting to outweigh the risks of cannibalizing the traditional sources of income. Indeed, some operators can be expected to veer towards a wholesale-dominated model in future, avoiding the conflicts of interest between direct and MVNO revenues, and avoiding the costs of acquiring and supporting end users.
There will be a massive diversification of service providers, driven by the new economics of the mobile infrastructure, and by the rising need for specialized services to address the many specific applications of the business IoT and of the multiplay. This diversification will be stimulated by various trends:
- Increasing government and regulatory acceptance of active infrastructure and spectrum sharing in important markets like India. In some countries, like Mexico, this is going as far as a state-mandated wholesale network to be shared by all the MNOs in order to kickstart 4G services.
- Government enforcement of more MVNO-based competition, as seen recently in China and as a result of some European Union operator mergers (e.g. Germany and Ireland).
- Densification around small cells will encourage MNOs to move to shared or neutral host models. The cost and complexity of acquiring sites, backhaul and power for thousands of cells per city will threaten to wreck the business case unless these costs can be shared. Some operators feel more willing to experiment with new approaches outside their precious macro layer, as they plan a brand new layer of infrastructure. And for non-MNOs, small cells will often provide new opportunities to control their own mobile systems – for instance, by deploying or sharing these cells in a shared or unlicensed band like 3.5 GHz, relying on an MNO’s anchor network only for wide area roaming.
- Virtualized on-demand platforms which can support a wider range of service providers and enterprises on a pay-as-you-go basis, as pioneered by AT&T, SK Telecom and others. These will reduce the cost and complexity of supporting MVNOs, both for the MNOs themselves or the rising tide of MVNEs. This will drive a move away from a few rigid and long term MVNO deals per carrier, to a more flexible system in which providers can access and pay for capacity as they need it and at the best available price.
- In the 5G era, virtualization and orchestration will enable the concept of ‘network slicing’, in which each provider can be allocated its own virtual slice of the mobile network, for as long or short a period as required.
This data module tracks the rise of these new approaches to mobile network deployment and service delivery, which will revolutionize the competitive landscape and the economics of the MNOs by the next decade – with subsequent impact on the whole supply chain, and on the availability of new offerings for consumers and enterprises.
It examines the widening variety of organizations which will deploy and manage macrocells and small cells as a result of the trends outlined above, with breakdown by region. Then it studies the diversity of service providers which will be managing and monetizing each mobile connection between now and 2020, highlighting the declining number which will be directly controlled by the MNO, and the type of platforms – from neutral host to SCaaS (small cells as a service) to full virtualization – which will enable the new market mix.
Deployment and ownership of small cells by 2020 (% of total installed base)
For more information about Rethink’s RAN Service, a series of forecasts and data modules addressing different aspects of mobile network and service deployments, please email John Constant on [email protected].
