Despite the general industry buzz around robotics, Google’s initiative in this area, called Replicant, has made only halting progress, and the company has now put its Boston Dynamics unit up for sale.
Google acquired the company, which makes lifelike and highly robust robots such as Big Dog, in late 2013, one of a total of eight purchases it has made in this field. However, sources indicate that Replicant – now part of the Alphabet umbrella company which includes Google – has suffered from lack of coordination, leadership and common purpose.
Possible acquirers could include Amazon, which is investing heavily in robotics for warehousing and delivery purposes, though Boston’s inventions might be overkill for that purpose – the start-up was most famous for animal-like creations for military or emergency situations, which could scale walls, jump over obstacles and did not topple over when rammed from the side. Toyota Research Institute has also been rumored as a possible buyer.
Sources told Bloomberg that the robotics push had been a personal enthusiasm of Andy Rubin, former Android chief, who drove the acquisitions and the hiring of 300 robotics engineers, but left Google in October 2014. Since his departure, there have been changes in leadership, and reported failures of Boston and other Google robot teams, in Silicon Valley and Japan, to work well together, partly because Boston has been heavily defence-focused, while Google wants to avoid that sector. The result was a failure to come up with products which would be marketable in commercial applications in the near future.
In December, Alphabet said that Replicant had been folded into the advanced research group, Google X. However, Boston was not included in that move and has now been put up for sale. And other robotics work is not safe either. An insider said that Google X’s chief, Astro Teller, recently told Replicant staff that they would be reassigned to other projects, if robotics do not prove to be a practical solution to the problems Google wants to solve.
Other robot companies acquired by Google around 2013 included six from the US – Autofuss (robot designers), Bot & Dolly (robotic camera systems), Holomni (maker of hi-tech wheels), Industrial Perception (industrial computer vision systems and robot arms), Meka (humanoid robots) and Redwood Robotics (humanoid robots and robot arms) – plus one from Japan, humanoid robot maker Schaft.
Boston Dynamics was by far the largest of these, and its biggest customer had been the US Department of Defense, which funded Big Dog to carry supplies for troops. Boston recently transferred the algorithms used for its ‘unstoppable’ robots – like the self-balancing Big Dog – to its Atlas project, with the potential for use in humanoid robot troops in future.
“The final straw was the humanoid runner that could stay upright even when pushed. That was so contrary to the Google non-defence position that, from what I hear, they just threw up their hands in the air and said Boston Dynamics had to go,” Frank Tobe, chief of the Robot Report, told EETimes.