Intel continues with its major reorganization as it tries to create a unified framework around its diverse business unit. Venkata Renduchintala, right-hand man to CEO Brian Krzanich and the executive charged with the restructuring, has already axed mobile processors and other struggling activities, and the latest move is to offload a controlling stake in the McAfee security business, which will regain its original brand under private equity firm TPG, which will take a 51% stake.
But this looks like throwing the baby out with the bathwater, since security is so essential to everything Intel is trying to do.
Renduchintala – whose official title is president of the Client and IoT Businesses and Systems Architecture Group – is doubling down on universal connectivity and software control for all kinds of devices. “We’re creating the type of all-for-one, one-for-all mentality that I think is really important inside Intel to transition from a bunch of really healthy siloed businesses and towards an entity,” Renduchintala said in a recent interview.
This is a good move, since Intel’s efforts to provide the processor in every small gadget failed in the handset market despite years of trying – but if it can drive the whole framework for IoT and mobile cloud systems, this will also boost its core server business.
But it is abdicating full control of the critical enabler of mobile, cloud and IoT services – security. When it acquired McAfee, it talked convincingly about the need to embed security capabilities right down at chip level, something rival ARM has pursued with its broad TrustZone ecosystem.
The strategic importance of McAfee was seen in 2014 when Intel launched a reference platform for an end-to-end IoT solution with security at every layer and link. Key to the Intel IoT Platform were two important acquisitions – Wind River and McAfee, both of which seemed vital to its efforts.
The former brought real time OS capabilities and virtualization, among other tools, to the party while McAfee brought security. Ensuring robust security in networks of huge numbers of endpoints is probably the most critical challenge facing the IoT, especially when the devices are transmitting sensitive data back to the cloud. The Wind River and McAfee technology provided a middleware layer to handle device management and security, and software reference designs for a broad range of products from network appliances to CCTV cameras.
Of course, Intel will still use the McAfee but it is questionable whether its future agenda will fit well with that of an investment company – short term profits are not always achievable when devising big picture architectures. Intel will get $1.1bn for its spin-off and McAfee will become an independent firm under its own name (it had recently been rebranded as Intel Security). McAfee was acquired in 2010 for $7.68bn but the new transaction values it at only $4.2bn ($2.2bn plus $2bn debt). In a research note, Deutsche Bank analyst Ross Seymore forecast that it would earn $2.2bn this year with an operating margin of 17%. Overall, this is about 4% of Intel’s revenues and 2% of its operating profits.
Chris Young, the general manager of the Intel security group, will become the new company’s CEO. He insisted: “We will continue to focus on solving the unique demands of customers in the dynamic cybersecurity marketplace, drive innovation that anticipates future market needs, and continue to grow through our strategic priorities.”
In an open letter to investors and customers he said: “We are resolute in delivering our product roadmaps, and this new partnership and pure-play status allows us to invest more and execute even faster to enhance our product and services offerings.”
This move seems a short term one, part of Intel’s radical cost-cutting exercise and its bid to double down on a few core activities. About 7,500 McAfee employees will leave Intel at the close of transaction, expected in the second quarter of 2017. Seymore applauded the decision as “consistent with CEO Brian Krzanich’s increasing focus on Intel’s core areas” such as the data center, the IoT and non-volatile memory – but control of a major security technology, which could enhance Intel’s proposition in all these areas, is a costly loss.
Intel, whose endpoint security is already well regarded, had the chance to dominate one of the most important areas of technology, ensuring security at the network edge once that is supporting huge numbers of connected devices. Last week, Avaya highlighted how tough and strategic this challenge is. It is promising to use hyper-segmentation to fill the security hole at the edge with its ‘Everywhere Perimeter’. This relies on segmenting different applications so that, if hackers get into one system, they cannot easily move onto another.
Mark Randall, SVP of Avaya’s networking unit, pointed to a major hack of retailer Target a few years ago, when hackers stole the data of millions of customers, gaining access via the HVAC control system. Randall says that, had the subsystems been segmented and secured, the attackers would have got into the HVAC system but no further – as it was, once they were in that system, they had got behind the firewall and could proceed to other, more sensitive company databases.
Avaya recently commissioned a survey in which most respondents said they believed end-to-end segmentation was important, but fewer than 23% believed they currently deploy such a strategy, blaming complexity (35%), resource requirements (29%) and risk to the network (22%). Randall told Light Reading that Avaya could address those issues – it can divide a network into millions of segments, with segments running from data centers to desktops. There is also a hefty dose of automation, so hyper-segments can be easily created and removed as required.