Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

25 April 2018

US carriers and GSMA to be probed for alleged eSIM collusion

The latest drama in the long-running saga of the eSIM is an antitrust probe by US authorities into AT&T and Verizon. Accusations, reported to have been initiated by Apple, claim that the two US operators colluded with the GSMA (which represents MNOs worldwide) to force the market to adopt their preferred format for the eSIM (embedded or electronic SIM), thus strengthening their hand against the device/app providers in the battle to control the primary relationship with the mobile user.

The GSMA has been making progress towards eSIM specifications which are largely friendly to the interests of its MNO members in recent years, despite periodic efforts by Apple and others to drive the standards themselves. Pending the outcome of the investigation, the GSMA said it had suspended its eSIM activities.

The New York Times reported that the Department of Justice was investigating whether the two US carriers, and the GSMA, were trying to establish eSIM standards which would make it hard for users to switch between operators. “At least one device maker”, thought to be Apple, has complained that the proposed standards would allow devices to be locked to specific networks.

One of the hoped-for outcomes of introducing an eSIM, to replace the physical SIM cards, was that it could be remotely activated and updated. This would allow non-operators, such as device vendors or enterprise IoT administrators, to assign devices to new networks without intervention by the MNO; or for the user to swap between carriers directly from a menu on the device.

That, of course, could significantly change the balance of power between the network operator and the device supplier by severing yet another tie between the user and the MNO – a relationship which has already been weakened by the brand power of Apple and Google, but has been held together by two instruments of control for the MNO. One is the billing relationship; and the other is the MNO’s exclusive ability to assign and manage the SIM, tying the user to its network (though even that has been weakened by swappable SIMs and multi-SIM handsets).

So a lockable eSIM would help the MNOs cling to their traditional customer relationship where this suited them, while accepting a more open model where manual SIM management would be impractical (mainly with the massive device numbers that could emerge on the Internet of Things).

“Standards bodies are both extremely valuable, and create an opportunity for collusion,” said John Bergmayer, senior counsel at telecoms advocacy group Public Knowledge. “Incumbent firms have shown themselves willing to use every tool at their disposal to block competition.”

In a statement, the GSMA said it was working with leading operators, device suppliers and SIM makers worldwide on global eSIM standards, and these did indeed include the “option” for the eSIM to be locked. However, it stressed that the option would be selected by the user, not the operator.

“In the United States, consumers would have this option,” the GSMA said. “However, [the consumer] would need to explicitly consent to this under specific commercial agreements with their mobile operator, for example when purchasing a subsidized device.”

A Verizon spokesman told Bloomberg that the issue was “a difference of opinion with a couple of phone equipment manufacturers regarding the development of eSIM standards. Nothing more.” AT&T said it was aware of the investigation and has provided information to the government in response to its requests. It added that it would “continue to work proactively within GSMA, including with those who might disagree with the proposed standards, to move this issue forward”.

The eSIM has been one of the most divisive issues in the mobile industry in recent years. Everyone agrees that, with the coming of the Internet of Things, it will be impractical for an operator to be assigning and managing physical SIM cards for every connected device. However, the SIM is one of the last remaining bastions of control for the mobile operator over its customer, tying the consumer to the network, and so MNOs are reluctant to let this go when it comes to human connections.

This has led to a battle to define and control the eSIM, which periodically erupts in a showdown between the MNOs and the device community – which want to supplant the MNO as the primary relationship with the mobile user, and so want it to be easy for customers to move their devices from network to network.

The eSIM is just one aspect of this broader battle to keep control of the customer. In the US, the four national MNOs agreed in 2013 to let consumers use their smartphones on other carriers’ networks once their contracts expired. In 2014, legislation was passed to ensure that customers could switch networks without having to buy a new device. However, the eSIM could make it easier for users in many countries to buy unlocked devices and move them between networks without sourcing physical SIMs or contacting operators.

Google and Apple have both been laying the groundwork for a market in which the connectivity provider is virtually invisible to the user, and can be changed at will, as in WiFi. Google included an eSIM in its latest Pixel model. In 2014, Apple introduced an iPad with a ‘soft SIM’, providing a choice of operators which could be selected by the user online; and Google’s Fi MVNO allows customers to switch between Sprint, T-Mobile and WiFi networks.

However, the carrier-independent iPad is reliant on operators supporting this option. T-Mobile and Sprint do so, but others in the US do not, so Apple warns users: “If you buy one of these models at a carrier, the embedded Apple SIM might be locked to that carrier or disabled.” This may not matter for the relatively small tablet market, but sets a vital precedent for smartphones, no doubt prompting the latest action.

The battle has been brewing for years, and not just in the USA. One of the first major spats was centered on Europe, in 2010, and resulted in a victory for the large MNOs. In that year, Apple tried to bulldoze an embedded SIM card into the industry before it was ready, but was forced to retreat under intense fire from European MNOs, which threatened to refuse to sell an iPhone with a SIM card that Apple could provision remotely.
By 2014, when the eSIM iPad made its debut, times had changed. Operators had accepted that eSIMs would be essential to make it workable to support huge numbers of connected devices. Soon after, many had signed up for the GSMA’s eSIM effort – no doubt hoping that the specs would, at least, have carriers’ interests at heart if they were defined by the MNOs’ own association rather than the device segment.

But there is still a big leap for MNOs, to accept an unfettered handset, rather than seeing the eSIM in devices where they have less control anyway, like tablets, wearables and even cars. These items often do not usually come with their own cellular data plan, or they may be part of a bucket deal in which the primary billing relationship still centers on the handset – that bundle itself tying the user to the particular MNO.

Even then, some operators have resisted the change – Verizon sold soft SIM iPads with its own separate SIM, disabling Apple’s, though of course this is impossible with non-removable eSIMs, which started to appear in some devices, including the iPad Pro, in 2016.

But the smartphone remains the chief source of usage, revenue and opportunity for the operator to communicate with the user and promote other offerings – and that is Apple’s next frontier. A report by Strategy Analytics said: “Short of offering its own MVNO, from a carrier perspective an eSIM iPhone would be the most destabilizing change Apple could make to their existing iPhone business model. With an eSIM equipped iPhone a customer need never directly interact with an operator again, instead provisioning service and switching from carrier to carrier at the customer’s whim. Adding an eSIM to the iPhone would be a direct shot across the bow of carriers. With eSIM, Apple’s grip on the customer will become even tighter.”

While Apple has often been rumored to be considering that MVNO, it has not taken that step, but Google has, in the US at least, with Fi. While, in many markets, Google is loath to challenge the MNOs which still provide the main channel for its mobile services, in its home country it has been far more disruptive, with a series of moves designed to shake up the market and make it more open for a wider range of service providers, as well as pushing the big four to accelerate their deployments.

In the past, it has talked and lobbied vociferously for a change in the structure of the mobile and broadband market, especially in the US, but in reality has worked with MNOs more than it has challenged them. But with the launch of Fi and an eSIM Pixel, it is trying to increase its own power and push the industry towards its own vision. This is one where networks are open to huge numbers of service providers and devices, and where at least some access is free – as long as Google sits at the control center of that ecosystem via its cloud services, its APIs and its brands.

In April 2015, Google launched its Project Fi MVNO service, which has tiny share in the US, but is being closely watched round the world as a potential new model for opening up mobile markets. Its differentiator is software that ensures the device is ‘always best connected’, with the traffic being routed automatically to the best available signal out of WiFi, T-Mobile, Sprint and (since 2016) US Cellular. Fi is important not for its market share, but for the way it blazes a trail towards a far more flexible way to use spectrum and network capacity, with devices able to move seamlessly and intelligently to the best connection; and networks able to support large numbers of service providers on an on-demand basis.

Project Fi’s SIM cards and radios enable a “network of networks”, with the handsets measuring the available connections and switching to the fastest or best quality one automatically. This is a good example of Google’s attempt to build a highly differentiated, and highly Google-centric, user experience for Android, with Nexus as the vehicle. The Fi bundle includes services like Google Hangouts, plus full WiFi functionality, unlimited voice and text, and many internet features.

There are also data-only add-on options for devices like tablets (including iPads), with a flat rate of $10 per gigabyte. Up to nine devices can be linked to each Fi account with the data-only SIMs. There is no upfront charge to connect each new device – another blow to any lingering operator hopes that subscribers would accept a separate data plan per connected device. Most MNOs have moved towards shared plans, in which a certain number of gadgets share a single bucket of data, and these have been a significant source of growth, especially in the US, in the past two years. However, they typically charge about $10 for each new connection.

Extending the GSMA eSIM to all connected devices:

While Google and Apple continue with the long process of reinventing the smartphone rules, the GSMA and its members show greater alacrity when it comes to defining eSIM for the IoT.

For the past two years, the GSMA has been extending eSIM specs to wearables, cars and other connected IoT devices. In 2016, the first eSIM-based roaming between two separate machine-to-machine platforms was demonstrated, as well as a new version of the spec to address consumer wearables. This is a product of the GSMA’s Consumer Remote SIM Provisioning initiative, and allows users to activate eSIMs remotely in fitness bands, tablets or smartwatches.

The GSMA used this breakthrough as a chance to push its credentials as the best body to set these standards, with then-CTO Alex Sinclair saying: “This is the only interoperable and global specification that has the backing of the mobile industry and lets consumers with a mobile subscription remotely connect their devices to a mobile network. This new specification gives consumers the freedom to remotely connect devices, such as wearables, to a mobile network of their choice and continues to evolve the process of connecting new and innovative devices.”

The older, non-consumer strand of the M2M eSIM addresses the opposite situation – where the consumer has no involvement in provisioning a new device and this requires to be done fully automatically.

Another important target for the eSIM is the connected car, where a universal standard would help streamline the manufacturing process globally, and allow MNOs to connect the vehicles more easily to their networks. The eSIM standard has won an influential number of new supporters from this sector, including General Motors, Jaguar Land Rover, Renault-Nissan, Scania, and Volvo.

In theory, an eSIM would allow auto makers to install a single universal unit inside their cars and be able to connect them to cellular networks across the world. This should be a boon to in-market and lifecycle management, which are important for products that can be used for as long as cars are, as it allows the operators and manufacturer to potentially sell services to the new owners throughout the lifetime of the car – raising the revenue generated by a single vehicle substantially.

As the SIM can be remotely managed and provisioned, it can be added or removed from regional cellular networks. This means that cars used in the US could safely take a trip across the border to Canada or Mexico and remain connected – provided the MNOs enable all the background cloud processes that manage roaming to function freely.

Ironically in the light of recent events, it was AT&T, with its Single SIM system which provided thhe first global eSIM-compliant solution.