Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

25 April 2018

European research institute demoes yet another 5G OFDM option

The Heterogeneous Technology Alliance (HTA) has a lower profile than many technology research institutes, but it was celebrating its tenth anniversary in Brussels earlier this month and focusing on emerging wireless technologies in the context of 5G.

The HTA is an association of four major European research bodies focused on electronics, communications and nanotechnology – LETI of France, Fraunhofer Institute of Germany, CSEM of Switzerland and VTT of Finland.

Emmanuel Sabonnadiere, who heads up LETI, said the strategy for the 3-5 year timeframe was to focus on four segments, including advanced applications for new mobility (the others are advanced data and computing, advanced communication and cybersecurity, and bio-inspired smart medical devices).

He told EETimes that there were several major projects focused on the impact of 5G, including millimeter wave communications, and the “types of devices that put more digital in the front end and closer to the antenna”.

The HTA was involved in creating a 5G prototype which was used for demonstrations at the recent Winter Olympic Games in South Korea, which saw a bus driving at 60 kilometers per hour, receiving data at 5Gbps to allow users to view two sports event broadcasts simultaneously.

One of LETI’s most recent projects is an outdoor “super WiFi” technology, which uses dynamic spectrum access (DSA) to create a flexible solution for broadband access, based on a patented scalable waveform for next generation wireless networks.

“Outdoor Super WiFi” will target difficult environments such as maritime communications and rural broadband, promising greater robustness to interference, versatility and flexibility than conventional WiFi or 4G. Such developments, although based on WiFi and the 802.11 standards, are widely regarded as part of a broader ‘5G’ platform that goes beyond 3GPP specifications. In some areas regarded as central to 5G, such as millimeter wave spectrum, the WiFi community has led the way (in that case, with 60 GHz WiGig standards).

LETI demonstrated its technology last year with a rural broadband application that delivered content over distances of 20 kilometers, using non-contiguous channels. The over-the-air test platform was based on FPGA, ARM processors and an agile RF front end, a platform that has also been used by LETI to test 5G radios.

The organization’s outdoor WiFi design uses a new BF-OFDM (block-filtered OFDM) multicarrier waveform for the air interface, addressing a wide range of requirements with a unified physical layer in the same system bandwidth. This is backwards compatible with OFDM waveforms currently in use in LTE and WiFi, so that the same terminals can be used, but LETI says it overcomes the shortcomings of those implementations.

This fits in with several attempts to develop new waveforms for 5G, based on enhanced OFDM implementations or on new approaches. Many of these are being tested first for fixed wireless and backhaul applications.

For instance, start-up Cohere submitted its OTFS technology to be included in 3GPP’s first 5G standards, Release 15. It failed, but continues in trials with operators such as Telefónica, and has hopes of success in Release 16. OTFS (Orthogonal Time Frequency Space) sits on top of OFDM and claims significantly lower susceptibility to fading, which boosts data rates and reliability.

Some mobile stakeholders were frustrated that the first wave of 5G standards, 3GPP Release 15, stuck with OFDM in the air interface, rather than adopting a more radical modulation technology.  The 3GPP NR Release 15 study item agreed to support CP-OFDM (Cyclic Prefix OFDM) for the downlink in enhanced mobile broadband applications, with the complementary technology, DFT-Spread OFDM, working alongside CP-OFDM on the eMBB uplink. This has some continuity with LTE, which uses OFDM in the downlink and DFT-S OFDM in the uplink, but increases the importance of CP-OFDM.

According to Qualcomm, DFT-S OFDM provides link budget benefits while CP-OFDM supports MIMO spatial multiplexing advantages. It believes there are advantages to using both technologies on the uplink, which can adaptively switch between them to get the best of both worlds.

However, additional standards are likely to creep into Release 16 standards next year, provide renewed opportunities for new approaches from giants like Huawei, to start-ups like Cohere Technologies.

Telefónica has conducted fixed wireless tests used Cohere’s 5G implementation, turboConnect FWA, which was unveiled at Mobile World Congress in February. While the company waits and hopes for acceptance in mobile and IoT standards, it aims to take advantage of the recent burst of interest in FWA, especially in 5G mmWave spectrum, to push OTFS into the mainstream.

Other operators have shown an interest in OTFS. Altice and Telstra are among the start-up’s investors, and it has conducted commercial trials with both those companies, as well as Charter Communications, C-Spire and Deutsche Telekom, all in fixed wireless. Cohere says several more operators are scheduled for FWA trials in the early part of this year.

Cohere stresses that its technology can coexist with OFDM to support smooth migration from current networks, or coexistence between different 5G flavors. That integration could be critical to win acceptance for a technology from a small player. Many observers believe OFDM will be the most efficient option for sub-6 GHz spectrum and mobile broadband use cases, but that alternatives will be needed to optimize performance in millimeter wave bands, or for emerging IoT and ultra-low latency applications.

Larger companies are also hoping to get their favored air interface technologies into the standards in Release 16. For the mmWave bands, China Mobile has validated Huawei’s Filtered OFDM and ZTE’s FB-OFDM in its high frequency tests, but has provided no details of the results as yet. In 2016, Huawei described a “unified” air interface which draws on several approaches at once and allows different sub-bands, within the baseband, to be configured individually for different purposes.

Its design is based on three key concepts – Filtered OFDM (fOFDM), Sparse Code Multiple Access (SCMA) and polar code. Each has a contribution to make to a standard which can be adaptable without compromising on the performance requirements, says Huawei.

Qualcomm’s pitch for IoT applications has been non-orthogonal RSMA (resource spread multiple access) technology, plus a new multiplexing technique which would allow traffic requiring very low latency to take priority automatically and to use RSMA. This technology uses time and frequency spreading and overlaps users in a way that aims to improve network efficiency and power consumption. It can support mobility and downlink meshing, as well as network-assisted mesh on the uplink.