Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 March 2019

MWC19: ORAN and TIP bring open networks closer to reality, and to each other

The vision of a new, open, multivendor and disaggregated network was largely epitomized, at Mobile World Congress, by Rakuten, but of course, that is a highly specific deployment by a unique operator in an unusual mobile economy. For most operators, the activities of the various open RAN industry groupings will be more relevant to their own hopes of exploding the current locked-down supply chain.

In fact, Rakuten is not a poster child for any push towards industry-wide standards for an open network, and those will be essential to reduce the complexity and integration expense of rolling out multivendor 5G systems. The Japanese company did refer to Open vRAN, an initiative kicked off by Cisco at last year’s MWC, which has the aim of encouraging multivendor networks, but places one vendor firmly in the role of coordinator and orchestrator of all the pieces.

That suits Cisco, which does not play in the cellular RAN but has a strong opportunity in the core and orchestration. However, it does not have a major professional services operation like the RAN majors, or the IT companies such as Tech Mahindra. So for Cisco – especially at a time when its strategic alliance with Ericsson was collapsing – an ideal compromise was in view. This would be a platform open enough to allow Cisco to play end-to-end in the 5G network, and to simplify roll-out in order to keep the professional services players out and the costs attractive for MNOs; but still sufficiently under the vendor’s direction to ensure it the starring role.

By contrast, the main open cellular initiatives – the ORAN Alliance, Telecom Infra Project (TIP) and the Open Networking Foundation’s (ONF’s) CORD – are all driven by operators, including MNOs and cloud players (notably Facebook, the initiator of TIP). They all have multiple projects, but their core objective is to define open interfaces between the radio head and vRAN; and back from there to core and orchestration. None of these initiatives was name-checked by Rakuten, but they were all active at the show and demonstrating advances which bring their open platforms closer to deployable reality.

TIP announced that it had launched an extension of its existing Open RAN project group, which is defining open interfaces between radio head and baseband, to 5G. The Open RAN 5G NR group will be led by Sprint and Vodafone, while vendor participants will include small cell and vRAN suppliers (Airspan, Altiostar, Parallel Wireless), chip providers (ARM, Intel and Qualcomm) plus Aricent and Tech Mahindra.

The initial focus is one sub-6 GHz 5G NR small cells for outdoor and indoor use cases, with millimeter wave small cells to follow. The aim is to define an open reference design to combine open source software and general purpose hardware, to enable a flexible and modular 5G NR design.

The project group will also develop modeling techniques and a test framework for specific applications and deployment scenarios as prioritized by operator members, and these will apply to either Standalone or Non-standalone 5G NR networks.

In Barcelona, TIP showed off its interoperability enablers in an end-to-end network demonstration which involved several of its working groups – Open RAN, vRAN Fronthaul, Edge Computing and Applications and Disaggregated Cell Site Gateway; along with some specific platforms that have emerged from these groups or from Facebook’s own R&D, including Cassini, CrowdCell, OpenCellular and new technologies for radio access, backhaul, core and network management. The demonstration involved 20 technology providers, and was the first time TIP’s projects were integrated on a single network.

TIP also followed up on announcements it made with Vodafone and Telefónica at its own conference in London in the autumn. There, the two MNOs named the vendors which complied with the terms of an RFI, based on TIP specifications, which had been issued some months earlier. All those on the list were independent or start-up suppliers in the small cell, vRAN and vEPC fields (see inset).

Now the two operators have started working with some of these suppliers on Open RAN field trials. These started in Turkey, where TIP said 25 trial sites were set up to carry commercial traffic from Open RAN macrocells in the 900 MHz band.

The trials are now being expanded to parts of Africa and Latin America. Vodafone is focused on the former region, via its South Africa-based joint venture, Vodacom, and working initially with Mavenir and Parallel Wireless. Vodafone UK also plans to launch a live field trial using indoor 5G small cells based on TIP specs.

Meanwhile, Telefónica is deploying macro and small Open RAN sites in Peru, Colombia and Argentina for pilots.

Both operators, along with Italy’s TIM, are also working to bring another TIP platform, the Disaggregated Cell Site Gateway, to the commercial trial stage, and are currently engaged in lab tests.

Another new project group, chaired by DT and Facebook, is focusing on WiFi. “This is another opportunity where new business models should be shared in the broader community with more people collaborating,” said Clauberg. “Open collaboration in organizations like TIP and in ORAN is becoming more important to drive innovation in the industry… it’s important for us as operators to work with start-ups, established vendors as well as Internet companies, to advance the industry overall.”

The new TIP 5G NR group was keen to play down the notion that TIP is in competition with other open source initiatives, or conventional standards bodies, in driving open RAN interfaces. It said it would coordinate with the ORAN Alliance, 3GPP and others. Indeed, the success of the open RAN vision is likely to rely on a measure of convergence of the open source efforts in the near future – unless one of them clearly becomes the industry’s de facto standard by sheer weight of adoption.

In another sign of crossover between different open groups, Radisys, which is a leading light in CORD, was focusing on TIP and its Open RAN framework in Barcelona, and showed its 4G baseband software running on an x86 common platform, interfacing to a remote radio head from Baicells using the TIP specification.

Deutsche Telekom’s Axel Clauberg, who is also chair of TIP and a leading light in several other groups, has called for greater collaboration between different initiatives. And he hinted at future convergence when he told LightReading recently that Telefónica and Vodafone, as well as being leaders of the TIP Open RAN project, also plan to base their work on the ORAN specifications. That, he intimated, would lead to coordination of efforts, though not a merger of the groups.

“They have not done any specs from the ground up. They have not built architecture but are looking at how the architecture specified by the ORAN Alliance could be built and deployed in a commercial way,” he said. “In this area, TIP would do solutions integration and prove it is possible to build such an open RAN in real life.”

And to gain operator confidence and avoid fragmentation, most stakeholders think it would make sense, once specifications are stable, to put them into the standards process to drive a wide ecosystem. The open movements encourage innovation and so speed up the creation of new technologies, but at the commercial stage, some clear and uniform processes can be very helpful to avoid a fragmented market, and the emergence of semi-proprietary implementations and a new breed of lock-in.

Clauberg said: “I wouldn’t say TIP is competition to 3GPP but it is important to understand the relevance of global standards, because without them we wouldn’t have interoperability. Sometimes there are global standards and you need acceleration and a standard doesn’t necessarily say how you should build something. Opening up the RAN is not covered by the 3GPP but by the ORAN Alliance work and what we’re driving here in TIP.”

But he believes open initiatives are vital to accelerate progress, especially at the start of a technology’s lifecycle, and so to encourage start-ups. He said: “With old-time telecom standards, we have a two-year discussion on use cases and then discussions start about what should be in the standard and then a couple of years later you have the first cut.”

“We’ve clearly proven we’re not just here to watch what Facebook is doing or Facebook’s strategy,” he added, speaking at MWC. He argued that, in rethinking how networks are planned and deployed, there needs to be input from all stakeholders, and that requires an open, collaborative approach like TIP. Operators, equipment vendors and software developers are all making active contributions, he said.

There is often a sense of dual, and perhaps conflicting, purpose at TIP. Facebook’s agenda is clearly to open up the network ecosystem and slash cost of ownership, as it has helped to do for cloud infrastructure with its Open Compute Project. Open, low cost networks will be more deployable in every part of the world and help bring the Internet, and Facebook services, to more consumers, more quickly. TIP’s telco supporters also want lower cost driven by open ecosystems, but clearly need to keep the network architecture and supply chain under their own control, rather than opening the doors to new types of service providers.

Clauberg’s view is that TIP is broad enough to support a range of agendas, and not necessarily hostile to traditional vendors either – they need to change, and will not be able to keep pace with the rapid innovation of the current industry if they work alone. So he believes that open initiatives help to reduce their cost and time to market too, through shared effort.

On the ORAN side, Samsung joined the Alliance. The Korean company, along with Nokia, had contributed code to the xRAN Forum, which was merged with the Cloud-RAN Alliance a year ago to form ORAN. So it was no surprise that Samsung officially signed up for the enlarged group, but highlighted how the company stands to benefit from the shift towards open networks – it has sufficient scale and track record to inspire confidence in operators, unlike some start-ups, but has very limited entrenched position to defend in the RAN, and so little to lose from supporting an open model.

Samsung’s contribution to xRAN was to input to that body’s Fronthaul Specification, which will be incorporated in extended interface work under ORAN. Samsung also worked with Verizon on that operator’s LTE Open RAN initiative, designed to enable multivendor remote radio heads and basebands in 4G (Samsung also supplies both types of equipment to Verizon, which itself joined the ORAN Alliance late last year).

Samsung said it plans to take an active role in ORAN and aims to join working groups that focus on network virtualization, AI-assisted automation, and open standards development.

In Barcelona, ORAN Alliance members showcased six proof of concept (PoC) platforms and promised imminent release of the body’s first would-be standard since its formation – the Open Fronthaul Specifications, which comprise control, user, synchronization and management plane protocols. A long line of operators pledged support, some saying they would introduce the specs to commercial networks from late 2019 onwards, and were already starting on multivendor interoperability testing. Those operators include KDDI, AT&T, Bharti Airtel, China Mobile, China Telecom, Deutsche Telekom, KT, NTT Docomo, Orange, SK Telecom, Softbank, Telefónica, TIM and Verizon.

Among the vendors promising support are Cisco, Fujitsu, HFR Networks, Intel, Keysight Technologies, Mavenir, NEC, Nokia, Pivotal Commware, Radisys, Samsung, SOLiD and Viavi (but not Ericsson, though it has recently joined the Alliance; and of course not Huawei).

The six PoCs were arranged around four themes – intelligent RAN control, open interfaces, virtualization and white box (see inset).

The ORAN Alliance was founded by five operators – AT&T, China Mobile, Deutsche Telekom, NTT Docomo and Orange – and even secured Ericsson’s membership last month, although the Swedish vendor has not contributed code as yet, and may mainly interested in joining to keep a watching brief on a potential challenge to its model.

 

The successful companies in the TIP RFI:

For most compliant end-to-end platform: Mavenir; Parallel Wireless; Altiostar.
For 2G software: Fairwaves; Parallel Wireless.
For 3G software: Mavenir; Parallel Wireless.
For 4G software: Altiostar; Parallel Wireless; Radisys.
For Remote radio head/ radio hardware: Baicells; NEC; Parallel Wireless.
Innovators: ASOCS; Phluido.
Challengers: Comba; Dali; Fairwaves; Vanu.

ORAN Alliance PoC demonstrations at MWC19:

  • O-RAN aligned implementation of Radio Intelligent Controller (RIC) Load Balancing

Predictive load balancing using Smart Radio Fingerprint technology that supports interoperability using ORAN architecture interfaces and established industry elements. This demo was hosted by China Mobile and ZTE.

  • AI empowered User Quality of Experience (QoE)

Predictive user QoE enabled by machine learning microservices chained together, to autonomously recognize traffic types in real time, predict quality and provide closed-loop network controls. Sponsored by China Mobile and Nokia.

  • Open Fronthaul Interface

ORAN’s Open Fronthaul specification demonstrated by several vendors to achieve interoperability between the O-DU (open digital unit) and O-RU (open radio unit). Participants were Verizon, NTT Docomo, KT, SK Telecom, Fujitsu, HFR, Intel, Keysight, Mavenir, NEC and SOLiD.

  • Virtualized O-CU on Akraino edge cloud orchestrated by ONAP

Integration of virtualized CU (central unit) with a community-supported Akraino edge stack blueprint packaged into a cloud appliance. Sponsored by AT&T and Nokia.

  • Programmable mmWave White Box Radio Unit

A mmWave smart O-RU transmitting a 5G NR signal with 100 MHz bandwidth using a 5G Open RAN test platform and a 28 GHz O-RU white box with a beamformed active antenna system to two UEs test emulators. Sponsored by AT&T, Anokiwave, Ball Aerospace, Xilinx and Keysight.

  • Open hardware reference design for sub-6 GHz indoor coverage

Two live demos of white box and general purpose hardware supporting sub-6 GHz indoor coverage scenarios for both 4G and 5G. The first sponsored by China Mobile, Lenovo and Baicells; the second by China Telecom, Intel and H3C.