Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 February 2020

France refuses to ban Huawei, though Orange and Iliad look elsewhere

Following the UK’s decision a few weeks ago to allow Huawei a limited amount of access to the country’s 5G RANs (though not the cores), other European countries are starting to make up their minds too.

However, if operators and Chinese vendors hoped that the results of various national security reviews would bring certainty to their 5G decision processes, they will be disappointed. The UK is reportedly considering a change of policy following furious reaction from the USA at the decision to allow Huawei to be present even in just 35% of 5G and fiber networks. And some European MNOs seem set to choose non-Chinese suppliers for their next wave of procurement, rather than risk having to replace the equipment later because of a new government decision.

The French government has announced its own policy towards Huawei. Finance minister Bruno Le Maire said the country would not bow to US pressure and ban Huawei, but would bar the company from supplying kit for critical national infrastructure, such as military and nuclear sites (also a feature of the UK’s more restrictive approach).

“Huawei will not be excluded from 5G in France. Everyone can have a place on the market, but we will put limits to protect our sovereignty,” said Le Maire. There will be no caps on the amount of equipment Huawei can provide in the French RANs.

However, he did imply that Nokia and Ericsson would be preferred because they are local, saying: “We have two European operators who supply 5G and supply quality equipment. It is normal if we look first if they can provide the solution. And I think our Chinese partners can understand that. But if Huawei has a better offer from a technical point of view or price it can have access to 5G in France.”

The leading French operator, Orange, has already selected Nokia and Ericsson, and Vodafone is removing Huawei core network equipment across its European footprint, presumably anticipating that many governments will restrict Chinese access to the core.

And France’s Iliad Group has selected Nokia for 5G networks for its Free Mobile subsidiary, and also for its Italian MNO, Iliad Italia. This does not necessarily have much to do with geopolitics – Iliad has been a Nokia shop since it launched its mobile operations in 2012 and also selected the Finnish vendor for its first Italian build-outs.

The other two French MNOs, Bouygues Telecom and SFR, have yet to declare their 5G vendors.

In Germany, a paper from Chancellor Angela Merkel’s party has rejected outright bans on any vendor, but has called for tougher security safeguards. The country will make its final decision next month. “State actors with sufficient resources can infiltrate the network of any equipment maker,” says the paper. “Even with comprehensive technical checks, security risks cannot be eliminated completely — they can at best be minimized. At the same time, we are not defenceless against attempts to eavesdrop on 5G networks. The use of strong cryptography and end-to-end encryption can secure confidentiality in communication and the exchange of data.”

It advocates specific measures for the access, transport and core networks, and a five-year timeframe for operators to replace any equipment which failed certification checks. It also called for a multivendor approach to ensure supply chain diversity. All three Germany MNOs use Huawei equipment and would face the cost and disruption of ripping it out, if the country went for a tougher line.

The USA has been threatening allied governments with various penalties – such as reduced intelligence cooperation or trade – if they allow Huawei into 5G networks. But China is now issuing similar threats, leaving governments to try to strike a difficult balance. China recently hit out at Telenor for its decision to choose Ericsson for its 5G network, even though Huawei had been the lead candidate since 2017. It called the change of heart “deliberate discrimination”, and hinted that China might reduce its trading relationship with Norway as a result.

The Norwegian government responded by saying that Telenor had made an independent decision which was not influenced by the government, and did not represent a national policy on Huawei.

“We have explained that in Norway it is the companies themselves who choose their suppliers, and not the state. The same is true in the telecom sector. We are confident China understands our position and accepts our assurances. We also hope the improving relationship we currently have with China will not change,” said Nikolai Astrup, Norway’s digitization minister.