Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 April 2020

Nokia’s Chinese chief seeks to mend bridges with Unicom and Mobile

Markus Borchert, the CEO of Nokia’s Chinese operation, Nokia Shanghai Bell, has written an open letter to apologize for the company’s failure to get much of the recently awarded second phase of 5G contracts from China Mobile.

Ericsson won 11% of the huge award, worth $5.3bn in total, but the bulk went to Huawei and ZTE, unsurprisingly in the context of escalating US/Chinese technology and trade wars, and Nokia was left empty-handed.

In an open letter, published in the official newspaper, People’s Post & Telecommunications News, Borchert acknowledged “a great deal of news and comment about our company’s failure” in the China Mobile deal. He wrote that his firm “accepts and respects China Mobile’s decision” but added: “We need to emphasize that we will continue to serve China Mobile unswervingly. Our strategy, with China Mobile as one of our most important partners, remains unchanged.”

He also wanted to set the record straight about another letter, which was allegedly written by a Nokia Shanghai Bell (NSB) executive to another telco, China Unicom, and which was leaked to business newspaper Economic Observer. The unsigned letter, carrying the NSB logo, was dated March 31 and blamed “drastic price cuts” for the company’s “unexpected failure” to be shortlisted for China Mobile contracts in any of its  28 provinces.

With Unicom currently considering its own next-phase 5G tender, the anonymous writer urged the operator to take into account “the historical service performance of various vendors when formulating their procurement plans, to avoid low cost and low energy vendors gaining a large share, which will affect the long term development of China Unicom’s 5G business.”

“We hereby solemnly declare that the letter ‘Nokia Bell from Shanghai to China Unicom on March 31’ circulating online recently does not represent our position and attitude,” Borchert stated.

NSB is a 50:50 joint venture with Chinese state-owned China Huaxin. It was formed in 2017 after Nokia acquired Alcatel-Lucent. The company made a €47m ($51.1m) loss in 2019 on 20% lower sales of €2bn.