Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 November 2020

Dish risks losing AWS-3 spectrum as FCC rules against it

By Wireless Watch Staff

One of the many challenges on Dish’s path to its full 5G vision is a new dispute about some of its spectrum. The FCC recently ruled that Dish improperly received $3.3bn in discounts on spectrum licences in the AWS-3 auction, which closed in early 2015, and according to US media reports, the company risks having to give up that spectrum.

In a 5G race which revolves so heavily around ownership of midband spectrum – a rare commodity in the USA, at least before the C-band auction next month – this would be a blow. The AWS-3 spectrum sits in the 1695-1710 MHz, 1755-1780 MHz and 2155-2180 MHz ranges.

However, it is not part of Dish’s near term 5G deployment plan, so even a long-running appeals process would not disrupt progress, though it could be a costly distraction and reduce the value of spectrum assets that Dish might look to sell on, in order to boost its 5G roll-out coffers.

In the 2015 auction, Dish acquired licences through third parties or designated entities (DEs), a common practice in the USA, and was able to receive 25% discounts which were available, via bidding credits, to small participants. Dish subsequently tried to recalibrate its deals with two DEs, Northstar Wireless and SNR Wireless, to be able to hang onto the discounts, when these were challenged.

But according to Fox Business News, the FCC has finally made a (non-public) decision on the issue, ruling that Northstar and SNR were actually owned by Dish, not arm’s-length entities. That would mean that Dish would have to pay the full cost of the licences, or relinquish the spectrum for a new bidding process.

Outgoing FCC chairman Ajit Pai, who was an FCC commissioner in 2015, said at the time that giving such a discount to a large operator like Dish “makes a mockery” of the small business discount program.

New Street Research analyst Blair Levin believes a likely appeal could go either way.

If Dish loses, the licences would be re-auctioned by the FCC, and then Dish would pay any difference between $3.3bn and the new sale price.

“We expect strong bidding for the licenses; AWS spectrum now sits at the core of the networks for all three national carriers, and Dish relinquished licenses that fill holes in Verizon’s AWS-3 holdings,” wrote Levin in a client note. “Dish will undoubtedly be a bidder too. We would expect them to bid up to the $3.3bn they bid last time around and either walk away with the licences or with no further liability.”

While most analysts think Dish will end up regaining the spectrum, or at least not having to pay additional fees, there is a worst case scenario which “shouldn’t be entirely dismissed,” wrote analysts at Wells Fargo in a note to investors. “The FCC could theoretically attempt to deem Dish as unfit to own any spectrum licenses and attempt to claw back ownership of the +110 MHz of spectrum Dish currently owns … It’s certainly a long shot outcome, but Charlie Ergen and Dish are not exactly the most popular folks at the FCC right now.”