Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 November 2020

TMO is cautious on key 5G enablers – mmWave, O-RAN and DSS

By Wireless Watch Staff

T-Mobile USA is rolling out its 2.5 GHz 5G network at high speed, looking to take advantage of its headstart in midband spectrum before its rivals strengthen their own position in these key bands during the upcoming C-band auction. But while acquiring Sprint brought TMO this treasure trove of beachfront 5G airwaves, the operator has not taken on board Sprint’s former experimental approach to new technology.

While Sprint was renowned for taking bets on emerging technologies, with mixed commercial results, TMO has been more conservative, and relied on its powerful marketing propositions to achieve the increases in revenue and market share of recent years. It remains cautious, voicing public doubts about some of the most fashionable 5G-related innovations that other operators are currently talking up, including dynamic spectrum sharing (DSS – see separate item), and open RAN.

Neville Ray, TMO’s vocal president of technology, said open RAN was “not ready for prime time for us”, though he acknowledging, in a speech to the virtual BCG and New Street 5G conference last week, that it made sense for greenfield operators.

He told New Street analyst Jonathan Chaplin that TMO now has 37m people covered with 2.5 GHz 5G services and will increase that to 40m by the end of November and 100m by the end of the year. The operator would not be able to achieve that pace of roll-out with current, early-stage open RAN technologies, Ray said, because in that environment, “you have to do a lot more heavy lifting as the operator” and “whose neck do you choke when things go wrong? Your own, right?”.

He also questioned whether the capex savings that new entrants like Rakuten and Dish are touting would materialize for all operators – “that’s a big TBD,” he added. “O-RAN for me is interesting at this point in time but there’s a host of unanswered questions”, including those concerning depth of R&D, and system integration.

By contrast, at the same event, Dish’s chief commercial officer Stephen Bye argued that a major network roll-out always requires a great deal of integration effort by the operator, because it involves many layers from RAN to BSS. “Each of those components need to come together and really, this comes down to disciplined execution,” Bye said.

“It really is an integration exercise and I would contend with an open architecture, we have much more visibility at every layer and within each of those interface points within each of the vendors so we can actually manage that more effectively … The notion that it creates an integration challenge is overplayed by people who have a vested interest in trying to manage the entire ecosystem.”

Ray is also far more cautious about another much-hyped 5G enabler, millimeter wave spectrum, than Verizon and AT&T, whose lack of midband assets forced them to make a virtue out of necessity and deploy 5G first in high frequencies. TMO also has mmWave holdings, though fewer than the big two telcos, and is adopting a “three-layered cake” approach to 5G, with low-band (600 MHz) build-out for coverage, 2.5 GHz midband for capacity and mmWave (26 GHz) for very high capacity hotspots and for residential fixed wireless.

But Ray said at the same investor conference: “Don’t get me wrong, millimeter wave has its place, but the idea that this millimeter wave thing is going to deliver a phone in your hand wherever you go with multi-gigabit speed, it’s mythical.” He added: “Millimeter wave is where you finish rolling out a 5G network. It’s not where you start.”

He claimed that TMO has one of the USA’s largest mmWave networks in New York, but “its propagation characteristics are incredibly limited, despite all the work we’ve done and the industry’s done in contrast to other spectrum sources”. The most interesting use case remains in-building capacity for places with high concentrations of people such as stadiums.

“I think expectations have been somewhat mismanaged. … We’ve got to be really clear with consumers what we’re delivering and how we’re delivering it because this noise and kerfuffle that’s out there isn’t helpful at this point in time,” Ray concluded.