The end has been called for WiFi based DSRC for automotive connectivity in the USA as the FCC is handing over its spectrum, some to the rival cellular Cellular-V2X and some to other unlicensed outdoor services. The latter is ample compensation for the wider WiFi movement since it includes 45 MHz of spectrum that could be absorbed into existing WiFi services as they migrate to the latest WiFi 6E version capable of operating in that higher frequency spectrum.
Indeed, that much was recognized by the FCC itself, whose commissioners Michael O’Rielly and Jessica Rosenworcel had been working for years on repurposing the 5.9 GHz band. That the work took so long is indicative of the tensions that have riven this area of spectrum and the tug of war between the WiFi and cellular camps. But now with this compromise the FCC seems to have come down to one page, with Rosenworcel, a democrat, praising her erstwhile republican colleague, O’Rielly, who has now left, for his contributions and movement towards a common position where both sides could derive some comfort.
“He deserves real kudos for his commitment to this subject and the fact we’re even here today is due in large part to his persistence and his belief that we need to find a way forward that updates true safety operations and also makes it possible to expand the use of unlicensed services in the 5.9 GHz band,” said Rosenworcel.
Her reference to safety operations is somewhat historical and misleading in the context of current and emerging automobile connectivity. It dates back over two decades to October 1999, when the FCC first allocated 75 MHz of spectrum in the 5.9 GHz band to be used for what were christened intelligent transportation systems (ITS). This was followed almost nine years later by a similar gesture in Europe when ETSI, in August 2008, allocated 30 MHz of spectrum in the 5.9 GHz band for its ITS.
At that time the focus remained on safety but, as car connectivity expanded, additional uses for that spectrum emerged with autonomous driving coming into view. The era of V2X (vehicle-to-everything) communication was born, with sub-categories including V2V (vehicle-to-vehicle), V2P (vehicle-to-pedestrian), V2I (vehicle-to-infrastructure) and V2N (vehicle-to-network). With C-V2X still on the drawing board while WiFi based DSRC and its European equivalent ITS-G5 were almost ready to go, naturally quite a lot of the auto industry including several leading manufacturers joined this camp.
Among them Toyota, the world’s largest car maker, in May 2018 finally announced that it was starting to deploy 5.9 GHz in vehicles sold under its own and the Lexus brands in the USA, starting 2021. Almost in the same breath, Toyota urged all automakers in the USA to adopt DSRC rather than the emerging cellular C-V2X.
The timing could hardly have been less auspicious because the wheels were about to come off DSRC just when Toyota was nailing its feathers so firmly to that mast. Yet at the time DSRC was still riding high in the USA and Toyota’s endorsement was welcomed strongly by the CAR 2 CAR Communication Consortium, a non-profit organization initiated by European vehicle manufacturers and supported by many equipment and research organizations. In Europe, the EU had been looking to make DSRC mandatory for V2X deployment, and it was that move that began the unravelling process.
As we have discussed in previous issues, that process began in February 2019 when the Next Generation Mobile Networks (NGMN), a lobbying body representing mobile operators and cellular technology vendors, sent a letter signed by board members to the European Commission, the EU’s executive body, calling for a technology-neutral approach in developing the EU’s C-ITS (Cooperative Intelligent Transport Systems) strategy.
Here the NGMN was referring to C-ITS as a generic technology akin to V2X, embracing either WiFi or cellular, or both under a hybrid approach. Coming from the NGMN, this was predictable but could not be dismissed as biased because it was merely calling for an agnostic approach. The EU was then forced to change its stance when 21 of the 27 member states, including France, Germany and Italy with the biggest automobile industries, voted against that European Commission plan to shut out 5G.
The EU then executed a partial U-turn by rejecting its Commission’s recommendation that ITS-G5 should be mandated for V2X, although not rejecting that standard outright. Indeed, the EU’s transport directorate DG MOVE dug its heels in and refused to abandon its backing for ITS-G5.
Meanwhile in the US, the FCC was finally losing faith in DSRC after 20 years of existence, noting that despite all the bluster from automobile makers and a flurry of trials, there were still no serious deployments, which meant that the spectrum allocated to it was being wasted. C-V2X had matured and was now looking a more compelling option than WiFi because it combined communications close to vehicles in the 5.9 GHz band with wider access to the internet and closed services through first LTE and then 5G.
This left FCC chairman Ajit Pai reminiscing over the 1970s song, ‘Give Me Just a Little More Time’, when discussing the recent 5.9 GHz spectrum reallocation. “Well, we have given DSRC a little more time – many, many times,” he said. “Today, at long last, we say, in a bipartisan voice, time’s up.”
Even this was not enough for Qualcomm which, despite having plenty of chips in the WiFi pot, is a strong advocate of C-V2X for automotive connectivity. Qualcomm was satisfied that the FCC decision creates a path for C-V2X to get up on the air quickly, but was still concerned it might suffer from interference from WiFi in neighboring bands.
“We’re very concerned that the ruling does not provide sufficient protection for C-V2X to avoid interference from Wi-Fi, and we plan to continue working with the FCC and other stakeholders to achieve the necessary protections,” said Dean Brenner, Qualcomm’s SVP for spectrum strategy and technology policy.
These issues around C-V2X and many more are discussed in the latest report just coming out from our forecasting arm RAN Research, on the future of automotive connectivity and prospects for the mobile industry.