The FCC might think that opening CBRS and 6 GHz spectrum, and succeeding in getting the C-band auction over the line, would be enough effort on the spectrum front for a while, but it still has plenty of other contentious issues to address, not least the fate of the 12 GHz band.
Here, Dish Network has been lobbying for four years for 5G to be permitted, supported by various IT players, notably Michael Dell of Dell Technologies. But it is opposed by another group led by AT&T and Elon Musk’s SpaceX, which want the spectrum to be allocated to satellite.
Sources say the FCC is hoping to make a ruling before year end, but that may be challenging, since filings from the different stakeholders suggest the disputes are intractable and escalating.
Dell-financed RS Access, which owns 12 GHz licences, is however calling for a decision, writing in a filing: “The time has finally come for the commission to issue a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM).” That would lead to a formal consultation process and the potential for a final settlement in mid-2021.
Dish wrote in its own filing: “Given the twin national imperatives of bringing spectrum to its highest and best use while unleashing spectrum for broadband connectivity, issuing an NPRM will allow debate to move from hollow rhetoric to the types of pragmatic solutions the country needs to accelerate 5G investment and innovation.”
Dish’s interest is in being able to add its significant 12 GHz holdings to its upcoming 5G network in future, enabling it to add capacity despite its shortage of millimeter wave frequencies in bands such as 28 GHz. AT&T, which with Verizon has the best position in mmWave spectrum (28 GHz and 39 GHz), clearly wants to keep Dish at a disadvantage in capacity terms, and it also uses part of the band for its DirecTV satellite TV service, a does SpaceX for its Starlink satellite Internet network).
AT&T and SpaceX are supported by, among others, satellite operators Intelsat and SES, plus the bankrupt OneWeb (see separate item), and Kepler Communications.
In 2016, Dish petitioned the FCC for a rulemaking to permit 5G services in the 12 GHz band, with sharing allowed between mobile broadband and the incumbent users, providers of direct-to-home (DTH) satellite services – the largest being Dish itself, which has licences in the band covering 75% of the population, and DirecTV. But later, Space X put forward an alternative proposal to use the band for Starlink.
SpaceX has called for a quicker resolution in its favor than an NPRM would allow, on the basis that its services will bring broadband to underserved rural Americans, but this summer, Dish argued against that, saying such a move would “permanently foreclose use of the band for terrestrial 5G”. This, it said, would be against public interest at a time when usage of satellite TV is falling, and “especially when SpaceX seeks thousands of megahertz of other spectrum suitable for its planned uses … Moving forward by initiating a neutral rulemaking on the 12 GHz Band will provide an opportunity for all stakeholders to weigh in on the Petition and address any interference concerns.”
A lobby group led by Public Knowledge and the Open Institute at New America said in July that the 12 GHz band provides an opportunity to adopt a sharing framework that “greatly expands the availability of spectrum for both fixed and mobile broadband deployments with midband propagation characteristics significantly better than the millimeter wave bands at 24 GHz and beyond”.