Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 December 2020

Nokia stabilizes 5G margins but needs to win back customer confidence

The rising pressure on Huawei, especially in Nokia’s heartland European markets, gives it opportunities to replace the Chinese vendor in markets which decide on restrictions in the 5G RAN or core; or to increase its share of multivendor customers. This is true of Ericsson too, but perhaps particularly significant for the Finnish company, which suffered severe 5G setbacks last year, mainly related to its decision to develop its own base station system-on-chip (SoC), a platform that incurred delays and high costs.

To take full advantage of Huawei’s plight, it needs to convince operators that it has a clear and near term plan to migrate to new platforms and address initial teething problems, which were said to be responsible for launch delays in some of Sprint’s markets last year. It may also need to play catch-up with Ericsson in some key technologies where it appears to be lagging, such as dynamic spectrum sharing (DSS – see separate item). And both Nordic vendors will have to pay attention to aspects of 5G where Huawei had taken a lead, so that operators do not feel they are being forced to buy second-best. Some MNOs have expressed particular concerns around Massive MIMO antennas, a technology where Huawei and ZTE are perceived to be leaders.

In the same week that Nokia announced its fourth quarter results – with CEO Rajeev Suri setting out that comeback plan as finances stabilized after a tough year – reports surfaced that Deutsche Telekom had called on Nokia to up its game in terms of 5G performance, if it wanted to replace Huawei in parts of DT’s network.

The Reuters sources were anonymous, of course, but they provided leaked briefing notes written by the operator’s vendor management team, from last autumn, and neither company denied the report. Federico Guillén, president of customer operations for EMEA and APAC regions at Nokia, just said in a statement: “We continue to work extensively with Deutsche Telekom which is one of our most significant customers, both in Europe and the US.”

There was a similar non-denial from DDT, whose board member for technology and innovation, Claudia Nemat, said: “As one of the major European manufacturers, Nokia is of strategic importance to Deutsche Telekom. It is well known that Deutsche Telekom is pursuing a multivendor strategy so that we are not dependent on just one supplier. This is an elementary part of our security philosophy. However, as in the past, Deutsche Telekom will not comment on individual contractual relationships and strategic purchasing decisions.”

In 2017, DT backed away from Nokia in favor of Ericsson and Huawei, so it has limited Nokia installed equipment to build on, which makes a migration to Nokia kit for 5G Non-Standalone more complex and expensive. Either it involves deploying a more resource-hungry NSA architecture option that allows for 4G and 5G base stations from different vendors to share the same LTE core; or it involves a rip-and-replace, which the vendor would probably be expected to pay for, but which would take up to two years.

Of course, the German government has not yet decided on a clear policy on including Chinese equipment in 5G networks. The Merkel government had previously taken the line that better security should be implemented in all 5G, regardless of supplier, and that individual supplier bans were not needed; however, she diluted that tone before the holiday and it may be that Germany follows the UK precedent of imposing quotas on the amount of RAN kit Huawei or ZTE can provide.

The German operators are clearly making contingency plans, with Vodafone and DT being the heaviest users of Huawei kit in 4G. DT has awarded about 70% of its 5G contracts to Huawei so far, with Ericsson taking the rest, so a ban, or a cap like the UK’s (at 35%) would force a change of vendor. Despite the challenges coming from new open RAN suppliers, none of them would be ready, in technology or support network, to provide up to half of a national German macro network over the next two years, so Nokia, and possibly Samsung, are the obvious options.

Documents written between July and November last year and shown to Reuters included a briefing note for DT CEO Tim Hoettges, saying Nokia “must step up” if it is to get back into the DT fold. The notes shows that DT considered Nokia to have performed less well than its rivals in 5G tests and deployments in Germany so far; that its 5G product was inferior; and negotiations were complex and drawn-out for every project.

In November, a briefing note for a meeting between DT executives and Nokia chairman Risto Siilasmaa said “assurances have been received” from the Finnish company, without giving details.

DT used to rely equally on Huawei and Nokia for RAN equipment, with each covering its own region of Germany. But in 2017 Nokia was dropped from new deployments, and now has equipment in only a handful of markets, while Ericsson picked up 30% of DT’s spending.

CEO Suri did not refer to the leaked notes on the Q4 earnings call, but did acknowledge challenges and mistakes of 2019, which have sent the company’s stock down to its current value around $4, from $6.15 a year ago. There were signs of stabilization in the results, however, with a Q4 profit of $618m, up from $223m in Q4 2018. Revenues were flat year-on-year at $7.57bn and operating profit jumped 45% to $881.5m.

In its third quarter earnings call, Suri had said that 5G profit margins had been hit by the high cost of Nokia’s homegrown base station chipset, and that the figures would improve once it completed its transition to cheaper system-on-chip platforms, relying more on merchant partners. It will be too early for that transition to the new Reefshark SoC be visible in quarterly results, but Q4 does indicate that the chipset costs have been reduced already, and other factors are improving margins.

Suri said Nokia will provide quarterly updates on how many of its 5G shipments are powered by the new ReefShark in order to show its progress in reducing 5G product costs. “These new products made up approximately 10% of our 5G product shipments in the fourth quarter 2019, and we expect that percentage to increase progressively over the course of 2020, ending the year at more than 35%,” he said. “We expect to end 2021 at approximately 70%, and to essentially complete this transition in 2022.”

On the earnings call, he added: “We have increased our SoC R&D capacity by about 60% over the past year, and we’ll continue to ramp up in 2020. And for 2020, we have three ReefShark SoCs under development.”

Suri said: “We recognize that we have faced challenges in mobile access and in cash generation. We will have a sharp focus on these two areas over the course of 2020. In mobile access, we expect improvements to be driven by increasing shipments of our ‘5G Powered by ReefShark’ portfolio; product cost reductions; better commercial management; and strengthened operational performance in services.”

Having suspended its dividend to improve its cash position in Q3, Nokia expects to resume a dividend payment once its net cash position increases to $2.2bn, which might happen after the third quarter 2020.

In terms of its guidance for 2020, Nokia expects performance to be flat, excluding China, where geopolitics may come into play. “We have decided to exclude China, given that pursuing market share in China presents significant profitability challenges, and the region has some unique market dynamics,” said the company, though Suri enlarged on that in the call. He said: “We’re not turning our back on China; I want to be very clear about that. We are trying to change our business mix in China. We want to sell more to webscale players, to state-owned enterprises, and with the operators we want to change the business mix towards a higher proportion of core, routing, fixed access, naturally be in the game in 4G, as well as transport. With 5G…it needs to make sense to us on a 3-4 year basis.”

In Q4, total sales in China were down 26% year-on-year, while sales in North America and Europe also fell, but by smaller amounts – 5% and 2% respectively. North America remained Nokia’s largest market during the quarter, with $2.27bn in sales or 30% of the total.

The Networks division grew its revenues by 1% year-on-year to $5.97bn, representing 79% of the entire business. The Software and Technologies divisions declined by 9% and 11%, respectively, year-on-year.

Network operators comprised 84% of Nokia’s customer base during the quarter, and enterprises, which grew 33% year-over-year, represented 7% of its customer base.

Suri said in his statement: “While I believe that 2020 will present its share of challenges, I am confident that we are taking the right steps to deliver progressive improvement over the course of this year and to position us for a stronger 2021.”

February 2020:

 

The second half of February saw the cancellation of Mobile World Congress, the first major sign, in the telecoms industry, of just how profound the impact of the pandemic would be. Of course, the rest of the year saw just about every event go online, as companies adapted to work-from-home policies and travel bans, and usage of platforms such as Zoom skyrocketed. Every company has been affected, even if telecoms was one of the most protected industries – unlike travel, aerospace or commercial property, its core offering was in higher demand as a result of the crisis. But of course the effects were felt – on a personal level for the many people who caught the virus, and on the economic front because of disruption to the supply chain and to spectrum auctions, and the prospect of reduced consumer and enterprise confidence and ability to spend on the luxury side of the mobile industry, such as new smartphones. Perhaps the biggest sign of the scale of the coming shake-up, apart from the MWC cancellation, was when even Apple was forced to cut its forecast as a result of pandemic effects.