The past two weeks have seen the release of the first set of quarterly results significantly affected by the Covid-19 pandemic. The first calendar quarter will not reveal the full impact, of course. In many markets, real crisis thinking did not set in until March, and anyway, the situation remains so unpredictable that it is dangerous to read too much into a few weeks’ figures.
However, some general patterns can be observed, and the outlook updates being offered by some companies provide useful indicators.
In general, as we have analyzed before, the industry is bracing itself for short term disruption to supply chains, operator finances and build-out resources, lasting into the autumn. That will be mitigated in some countries, most notably China, by increased investment in mobile networks as part of stimulus programmes, or to help meet increased demand for connectivity and video services. And the fourth quarter of 2020 and first quarter of 2021 should to see some catching-up – for instance, as delayed spectrum auctions take place and access to labour and sites eases.
By the end of 2021, we would expect mobile network capex spending for the 2020-2021 period to be in line with pre-Covid forecasts, though with a far choppier pattern of spending, with greater variations between regions, and between quarters, than in normal times.
However, within that picture of short term disruption and medium term normalization, the fortunes of individual supply chain players are far harder to predict. As is usual during economic upheavals, the gap in performance between weak and strong vendors will be wider, with investors, customers and the overall economic conditions being far less forgiving of any signs of weakness.
This is worrying for companies that have suffered recent setbacks, such as Nokia, since there may be a more constrained opportunity to put things right quickly; and of course for those which are reliant on markets where the bounceback will be slower or more limited than in others. This also casts shadows over Nokia. With China the best source of short term increased spending on mobile networks, it is very bad timing that Nokia finds itself excluded from the current wave of equipment contracts. This is not entirely about geopolitics, although Huawei and ZTE are the big winners from the new awards by China Mobile and China Telecom – but Ericsson has secured business too.
Nor is strength in China enough in itself to ensure resilience – ZTE, after a period of robust recovery from the impact of US sanctions, slid back in its most recent quarter; and from the second half of 2020, we can expect to see US stimulus efforts ramping up, and focusing on 5G (partly to catch up in the ‘race’ with China). That, of course, will benefit non-Chinese suppliers, and potentially the new breed of smaller vendors enabled by open platforms, which may gain specific support as part of the USA’s effort to encourage a homegrown industry based around emerging open architectures.
Certainly, operators’ enthusiasm for open networks, disaggregated architectures and highly automated systems will all be intensified by the prospect of economic pressures ahead. Some, as Telenor has described, will become less cautious about adopting these new approaches, as the promise of lower cost of ownership through open, automated networks starts to outweigh the risks of trusting new technologies and unproven suppliers.
For now, the first batch of results show the disruption associated with Covid-19 accentuating trends that were already visible – such as the latest move in the Ericsson/Nokia seesaw effect, with Ericsson’s new-found stability looking more impressive in the circumstances; but with Nokia falling perhaps more steeply than it might have done otherwise (and facing the reported threat of a hostile takeover, with low stock market values bringing buyers out in the hope of bargains).
But the only firm conclusion at the start of a time of global upheaval is that everything is uncertain, and the best predictions will change. The contrasting outlook on smartphone prospects from Qualcomm (upbeat) and Samsung (downbeat) are just one example of how major players are seeing markets, even ones they dominate, from very different angles.
As in any crisis, the strong will get stronger – the difference from the upheavals of 2002 or 2008 may lie in the type of companies that emerge as strong. There will certainly be a flight of contracts and investments to ‘safe’ vendors, but operators’ intensified need for a new cost base, combined with some government programmes, will also strengthen the trend towards new architectures, driving success for a few emerging suppliers.