Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 December 2020

Wireless-first becomes wireless-only for local enterprise connectivity

Enterprises now have at least a three-way choice for their local wireless communications as they move away from lingering fixed line options. There is WiFi in its latest version, WiFi 6, private cellular and public cellular. The latter can in turn be split into 5G and 4G, so there is a substantial choice on offer, although in many cases the use case will narrow this down or even point to just one candidate.

There are now though some cases where there is overlap and this is where enterprises should boil down their requirements into capacity, speed, scalability, device constellation and latency needs. The mobile industry can help by not being too didactic and not dismissing WiFi out of hand when it may be the best way forward, at least in the short to medium term, for premises where it is deployed already.

Most interesting are those greenfield opportunities where WiFi 6 and private cellular are both contenders, along with increasingly public networks as 5G slicing comes on stream to enable partitioning for individual customers and use cases.

This can include stadiums and large venues such as hotels, shopping precincts, airports and conference centers, where although there may well be legacy WiFi installed the time has come for a radical overhaul to meet current expectations. In these situations the ongoing pandemic may have bought WiFi some time for version 6 to convince some venues that it is still a contender after past disappointments.

Legions of conference attendees and travelers at airports will have experienced glacially slow internet access over public WiFi which was in part due to lower capacity of the older versions, especially if poorly configured, and partly having inadequate broadband pipes feeding the networks. On that latter count cellular was occasionally at fault, being the provider of broadband to trains for example. Here ironically 5G could give WiFi a lift given that the latter was often not the cause of poor internet performance in that case.

Nevertheless, WiFi 6 may not be sufficient to convince many venues to stay on board and past underwhelming performance may lead many towards private 5G with its promise of faster set up and ready support for advanced features like augmented reality. The challenge facing WiFi in this sector and the importance of WiFi 6 at least in narrowing the gap with 5G can be illustrated by the case of the Stade Velodrome in France, known as the Orange Velodrome for sponsorship reasons, home of the Olympique de Marseille football club but also used for other sports. This stadium was equipped with WiFi by Orange as part of its sponsorship deal for the 67,000-seater stadium in May 2016, with 1,000 hotspots in and around the arena.

But this has been usurped by 5G following a trial in 2019 in which just two antennas were able to serve the whole stadium, which was faster and cheaper to set up than WiFi, while providing more bandwidth per user. The stadium reported that this was able to deliver low latency video at up to 8K resolution with 360-degree view cameras just behind the goal lines, enabling fans to use their smartphones effectively as virtual reality headsets seeing the game from the goalkeeper’s perspective. This supported stop and rewind, allowing users to select replays of their choosing from several angles. This trial took place before WiFi 6 was available and that could have supported similar capabilities, but still requiring multiple hot spots.

A bigger area of overlap between WiFi and cellular occurs among the wider enterprise sectors because of the sheer numbers involved, and here latency as much as capacity and data rate will be critical. This can be seen from our own findings that about half of enterprises will require sub-5ms connectivity by the end of 2022 as a foundation for anticipated new applications, and 80% by  2024.

Whether such low latency will be needed by that many enterprises that soon is almost irrelevant, the key fact being that they are demanding this of new implementations. Even the latest WiFi 6E operating in the less congested 6 GHz band in addition to 2.4 GHz and 5 GHZ will struggle to meet such requirements despite slashing latency compared with WiFi 5, the version still predominant.

One of the highest performing WiFi access points (APs), the Huawei AirEngine WiFi 6, incorporates 5G-powered antenna and algorithm technologies precisely to cut network end-to-end latency down from the previous 30ms but it is still 10ms, double the 5ms identified by so many enterprises as their target to provide the headroom they would like.

Latency becomes even more critical for real time process control in the industrial IoT sector, where approaching 1ms is often the target given the high precision required for some of the operations. In that case 5G is the only show in town and the question then takes a different turn towards public versus private. In the case of the latter there is the secondary question of whether MNOs get a look in.

We have seen how a number of Tier 1 manufacturers, especially in automotive, have cut operators out of the cycle and gone straight to the infrastructure providers to build their own private 5G networks. Toyota, the world’s biggest auto OEM, is a case in point, having started this year building an industrial-grade private wireless network at its manufacturing design center in Fukuoka, Japan, using Nokia products installed with the help of local systems integrator, NS Solutions.

Infrastructure providers have themselves come under pressure from their MNO customers not to open a direct line to enterprises. Nokia broke ranks by pursuing enterprises more rigorously than its rivals, notably Ericsson which has continued to approach the private network market through its traditional operator channels.

Nokia, struggling more to win big operator deals, saw an opportunity to take a lead in this emerging market by going to enterprises directly through a new division, aiming to keep that separate from its operator business. It noted that some larger enterprises were not going to include operators anyway in their private networking plans, so saw little point flogging a dead horse.

To date that strategy has proved quite successful, as Nokia has won some large private network deals, finding Germany particularly fertile ground with Lufthansa and Deutsche Bahn among recently acquired customers.

Nokia believes its direct enterprise stance is good strategy as well as short term tactics, positioning itself as a leader among telcos in this private ecosystem, while taking advantage of the fact that it can bridge the gap with the public 5G network. It is hoping that as others follow these industrial early adopters, Nokia will show up as the most advanced candidate for the business, well positioned to act as systems integrator.

Ericsson, meanwhile, seemingly wrongfooted, has decided to play a longer game looking ahead to the time medium sized enterprises start deploying 5G private networks. Of course the company is not averse to some big deals now but is arguing that cumulatively the mid-size market will generate greater revenues over time and enterprises there will be more open to its approach of offering managed private networks cut out of the public 5G service via network slicing. This approach is not yet ready for prime time in any case, but could look more compelling in a year or two’s time.

Nokia at the same time will have to scale down its approach and no doubt will also start offering network slices as an alternative to dedicated private networks. Both will have to convince enterprises that network slices provide the same level of security and performance guarantee as a truly private network.

Huawei is an interesting case because it initially pursued an approach more like Ericsson’s through its traditional channels, aiming to stay close to its operator customers. But that rather backfired outside China after the various government bans on its kit within public networks. As a result, it is now moving more towards Nokia’s line, certainly in Europe, with some slender signs that is bearing some fruit, despite government pressure on enterprises to keep Huawei out as well.

We saw just last month, November 2020, how the UK research community Cambridge Wireless resisted that pressure by appointing Huawei as its partner for a private 5G test network at Cambridge University’s Science Park. This of course is rather different from a commercial network, but nonetheless represents a rebuke to the UK government from a body with plenty of security expertise, tacitly suggesting that the ban was driven by geopolitics rather than genuine assessment of risk.

There is one other dimension, open RAN, which will offer a vendor neutral approach to private networks that could be taken by operators, enterprises themselves, or other parties such as cloud providers or major systems integrators. But that again is for the future and it is not clear yet how big a force that will become in private networking.