Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 September 2005

Broadband wireless gets serious in Europe’s 3.5GHz spectrum

The greatest single boost to licensed spectrum WiMAX came with the ruling that Sprint Nextel are obliged to build an extensive network in its 2.5GHz spectrum as a condition of merger (see separate item). But the hopes for volume economics in the early years still revolve around the 3.5GHz spectrum used for broadband wireless in Europe and many non-US territories, including parts of Latin America, the fastest growing region for broadband wireless.

This is why the first WiMAX profile to go through certification testing is 3.5GHz and users of this band will be the first to have access to guaranteed interoperable gear, with the price improvements that should bring. This has led to accusations that the WiMAX Forum is ignoring the license-exempt part of the market, focused on 5GHz, and that it has taken a European bias. But, while the Sprint Nextel trials may accelerate the creation of standard profiles for 2.5GHz, the spectrum used in the US, the Forum has to prioritize on sectors that have the greatest potential to achieve volume quickly and therefore to attract large vendors and further investment in the standard. The 3.5GHz band is still the favourite in this respect, partly because the average customer spend in licensed frequencies will be higher than in 5GHz, and partly because of the rush of interest in reactivating this spectrum, which has lain dormant in many countries since the last broadband wireless bubble burst.

This is particularly clear, currently, in Europe, where regulators are holding a string of auctions and other allocations, as the last set of licenses expire, or as the authorities issue additional ones to stimulate new broadband services. WiMAX has been a key catalyst for this, and there have been plenty of trials in west and eastern Europe. However, these are now starting to turn into larger commercial roll-outs, especially as the largest economies ‘ the UK, France, Germany and Italy ‘ gear up to expand availability of spectrum in the 3.4-3.6GHz band from 2006.

However, expansion will also breed consolidation. As WiMAX makes the delivery of services in 3.5GHz a more attractive commercial option for carriers, there is pressure to deploy on scales that may prove too much for many start-ups. And the bigger names are getting interested in 3.5GHz again, which will push up prices of spectrum in countries where the auction method is used, or lead to acquisitions of smaller spectrum owners (particularly before spectrum trading comes into force in the next few years across Europe).

This consolidation began this week in France, where Iliad has snapped up Altitude Telecom, the only current holder of a national 3.5GHz license (although more should be awarded next year).

Iliad is a French competitive carrier best known for its fixed line triple play service provider Free, which has 1.3m customers, but it is now seeking to expand its coverage and add a future mobile element to its bundles via WiMAX, with the acquisition of Altitude, a deal valued by the media at ‘tens of millions of euros’. Iliad’s share price rose nearly 3% to €35.46 on the news.

The purchase could be good news for WiMAX in the longer run, if Iliad brings the same aggressive marketing that it did for Free to the wireless service. Altitude has some early deployments in areas such as Le Havre, and has been trialling VoIP technology. However, Iliad said it did not expect to announce major deployments until the technology is stable, which could be a few years. This hints at the dark side of the new interest of the larger carriers ‘ the temptation for them to buy up frequencies in order to mothball them, or offer just limited services, to remove a competitor for their core services. This behaviour plagued the US wireless market for years, and is only just starting to be reversed as the FCC becomes more assertive ‘ as the Sprint Nextel ruling shows ‘ in insisting that spectrum holders must deploy services in their bands, or forfeit them. It is essential that European regulators take a similar stand, if they are serious about making broadband wireless a serious third arm, alongside DSL and cable, in the high speed access market.

With the larger regulators gearing up for new auctions, there is bound to be something of a goldrush. Iliad chief financial officer Olivier Rosenfeld said that his company made its move because the upcoming 3.5GHz auctions may well be regional only and this could be its only chance to gain a national license.

Existing license holders, also aware of impending new entrants and heightened competition are also accelerating their activities. Over in Spain, 3.5GHz national license owner Iberbanda, which has been gradually creating its network, using Alvarion and Aperto equipment, mainly in rural areas, is stepping up its expansion program.

This month it will run pilots, to be closely followed by commercial services, in 30 rural areas in the Navarre region of Spain, including Valle de Eg”s, Valle de Erro, Aezkoa, Ezcabarte and Luzaide-Valcarlos.

The Navarre regional government’s broadband infrastructure program aims to offer a new telecoms network to rural areas that have no adequate infrastructure for fast internet access. The program requires €8.73m of investment, and aims to cover around 75,000 residents in 886 communities. The cost of connection, installation, equipment and maintenance is free until 31 October. Internet access will be 512Kbps to 4Mbps.

Meanwhile, in the UK, one of the biggest on-off stories in broadband wireless is UK Broadband, the subsidiary of Hong Kong’s PCCW that owns national 3.4GHz holdings in the UK. Having entered the market with aggressive plans for nationwide roll-out of its IPWireless-based service, it then pulled in its horns and opted for a gradual expansion that has only reached the Thames Valley region west of London. Recently it has been widely rumored to be looking to sell its spectrum ‘ possibly to BT ‘ once frequency trading is allowed in the UK in 2006. Now it has flip-flopped again, with plans to bring its service into the capital city.

This could represent a new confidence in the demand for broadband wireless, perhaps stimulated by the recent trials held by BT and by national 3.5GHz license holder Pipex, using pre-WiMAX technologies. It could also show UK Broadband rushing to launch in London before that market becomes overcrowded, since several broadband wireless providers, such as Libera, are now setting up shop in the capital.

Or it could, as the Pipex trial is widely regarded, be a ploy to increase the perceived value of its spectrum prior to putting it on the market.

Whatever the motivation, the company says it will begin its London push later this month, though it will ‘continue to take a prudent approach by implementing a phased roll-out program’.

The technology used in UK Broadband’s Netvigator service is the UMTS TDD-based offering from IPWireless, which is an alternative to WiMAX in frequencies around 3GHz but can also run in unpaired 3G spectrum.

One of the key issues that has faced UK Broadband has been interpretation of the terms of the license, as to whether it is permitted to offer mobile services. This will be the critical litmus test throughout Europe in terms of the real value of the 3.5GHz spectrum. While there is huge pressure to bring broadband fixed access to rural areas, and this will provide good opportunities for many smaller operators, the longer term promise and the appeal to larger carriers rest on mobility, but 77% of the world’s 3.5GHz spectrum, and most of Europe’s is allocated for fixed wireless only. So far, the UK regulator has proved one of the most rigid in sticking to this interpretation, perhaps because of the location of Vodafone’s headquarters ‘ the large cellcos have lobbed intensively against a relaxation of the rules on mobile broadband.

But other regulators, such as Austria’s, recognize that the world has changed since the license terms were originally formulated and that they may need to update the rules as licenses expire and are reallocated, or merely take a flexible view on enforcing them, especially where wording is vague ‘ as it often is, since at the time of writing, there was no consideration that 3.5GHz would be used for mobility. So rather than being specifically banned, mobile services are, in many cases, just not specifically permitted, giving the regulator more latitude. According to Maravedis, 13% of countries surveyed have loosened up their requirements for fixed only services at 3.5GHz.

Germany will be a particularly interesting case (see separate item) as its regulator plans to open up significant new swathes of broadband wireless spectrum in the 3GHz band, with a light licensing approach that could well permit mobility ‘ and set a precedent that would be hard to ignore elsewhere.

The need for mobility in 3.5GHz would be lessened somewhat if the 2.5GHz 3G expansion bands in Europe are made technology neutral, enabling operators to run WiMAX as well as UMTS-based networks in them. These lower frequencies would support full mobile services more effectively than 3.5GHz because of their superior propagation qualities. A combination of technologies in 2.5GHz would be good for the customers in terms of offering a choice of broadband mobile services. But whichever technology was used, it would almost certainly still be in the hands of the 3G carriers or other large telcos, which would have the resources to afford these expensive licenses. This would actually reduce the value of the 3.5GHz holdings and the opportunities for expansion by independent carriers, since the holders of 2.5GHz would be able to offer mobility more effectively and would be likely to have deeper marketing and deployment pockets.

Buying 3.5GHz for more than fixed and nomadic access is, therefore, a big gamble in Europe, especially if the prices rise significantly.