Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 September 2005

Motorola wins Sprint Nextel WiMAX trial with pre-802.16e approach

Motorola is soon to start trials of its Wi4 pre-WiMAX equipment with recently merged Sprint Nextel, one of the factors that is pushing the giant vendor to launch mobile gear without waiting for the upcoming 802.16e standard to be finalized.

Motorola has been very keen to gain a foothold in Sprint Nextel, since Nextel is its largest customer, but will phase out its Motorola-supplied iDen cellular network over the coming few years. MotoWi4, a newly announced range that encompasses an upgrade path for the Canopy unlicensed ISP range towards WiMAX as well as carrier class, licensed band products, may be the way to win some replacement business for iDen.

Sprint Nextel is likely to make one of the largest roll-outs using WiMAX kit in the first two years of the technology, since it is obliged as a condition of it merger to use its 2.5GHz spectrum to make a broadband wireless service available to at least 15m US citizens by 2009 ‘ and is almost certain to use 802.16 platforms. It also has strong commercial motivation to act quickly, since it sees broadband wireless as a way to break into the residential market dominated by the Bell operators. Therefore it is the most attractive potential customer for any vendor seeking to build a serious WiMAX business, something that is very important to Motorola, which largely missed the UMTS boat and, with WiMAX, sees a next generation technology where it can take a driving seat rather than battling against Ericsson and other established leaders.

Sprint and Motorola recently announced a WiMAX oriented joint development agreement, although the two cellcos have also tested other broadband wireless technologies in the past two years, including non-WiMAX options such as Flarion-Flash OFDM (now owned by Qualcomm, which runs the CDMA architecture on which the Sprint Nextel 3G offering will be based) and IPWireless.

The prospect of business from major carriers may have spurred Motorola to go back on earlier statements that it would not release pre-certified WiMAX equipment. It has decided to bypass the current fixed WiMAX standard, 802.16-2004, and only support the standard at the mobile 802.16e stage. But certification of products for this specification could not happen until the end of 2006 or even 2007, too long for Motorola to wait if it is to get a foot in major carrier trials. Therefore, Wi4 ‘ like other proprietary offerings with a WiMAX roadmap, such as Navini Ripwave and NextNet Expedience ‘ will attack the mobile, licensed band market immediately and move to WiMAX when that becomes practical.

All this adds to the pressure on the WiMAX Forum to accelerate the process of testing and certifying 802.16e kit in order not to see the standard sidelined by vendor specific offerings and de facto standards, as well as the rapidly evolving 3.5G cellular offerings, EV-DO Rev A and HSDPA.

With certification mooted for early 2007, Motorola’s broadband wireless marketing chief Paul Sergeant said: “We’re not waiting that long.”

Not that the first generation of Motorola pre-‘e’ Wi4 will support full mobility, which faces various technical hurdles such as fast hand-off. Instead, it will support fixed and portable applications. The second generation of Moto Wi4 products, which will be the focus of the Sprint Nextel trial, is expected to become generally available in 2007 and will support mobility from the beginning, first in PC cards, then in PDAs and finally handsets. If the Forum sticks to, or speeds up, its schedule, these could be 802.16e certified by the time they ship, Motorola says, and this would be its preferred option. This gear will be fully carrier class.

The Motorola roadmap for Wi4 highlights the much discussed dilemma for vendors and their customers ‘ if they are focused on mobility for the near term, but mobile WiMAX equipment, particularly the all important laptop card, will not be ready and certified until late 2006, what is the best interim solution in terms of simplicity of upgrade, cost and minimal disruption to the subscriber? Most of the big names are veering towards the so-called ‘e-minus’ approach of offering pre-standard equipment based on the 802.16e standard (not yet finalized, but with most of its elements decided upon), and guaranteeing an upgrade to certified ‘e’ as soon as possible.

However, there are flaws in the plan, for carriers that have a very tight schedule, since initial ‘e’ products, whether certified or not, will support limited speeds and various non-laptop CPE formats. Aware of the potential for other mobile broadband technologies such as EV-DO Rev A or HSDPA to step into the breach, Motorola is one of the vendors talking up what it sees as the killer advantage for 802.16e ‘ its ability to be used as a fixed solution too, and so to support convergence strategies, and enable mobile operators, for the first time, to enter the residential market with an economically viable network.

Andy McKinnon, WiMAX principal for Motorola Europe, argues that 802.16e is a superior solution to the current fixed standard, 802.16-2004, even in a fixed-only environment, since its modulation mechanisms are more adaptive, delivering better service to customers at the edge of a cell. And, of course, it provides a relatively smooth upgrade to mobility once second generation equipment debuts.

The opposite view, branded ‘d-plus’, is that the current standard (formerly known as 802.16d) should be enhanced rapidly to support many of the applications that will be delivered by first generation ‘e’, but a year in advance. Importantly, features such as sub-channelization can be added to improve propagation qualities and portability, and supporters of this view, such a chipmaker TeleCIS, claim the d+ camp will have a laptop solution earlier than their ‘e-‘ counterparts. TeleCIS will offer a chipset for a combined 802.16d/Wi-Fi card shortly and aims to get the Taiwanese chipmakers on board to manufacture it in volume. WaveSat, another pioneering WiMAX chipmaker, is also supporting ‘d+’ in a bid for short term revenue streams ‘ with the luxury of not having to take on the giants from day one ‘ and with the promise of Taiwanese alliances and, therefore, a low cost, PC-based CPE at a very early stage.

This argument will certainly be important for the unlicensed community of WISPs, whose 5.8GHz band will be unsuitable for full mobility anyway, but which want to offer PC-based services as soon as possible to differentiate themselves from Wi-Fi and add value to WLan-style offerings, as that market becomes commoditized.