Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

16 September 2005

EV-DO Rev A trials signal end of the mobile broadband phoney war

In the same week that the mobile WiMAX standard 802.16e was ratified, operators went public with real world deployment plans for the next release of CDMA, 1X E-DO Rev A, which is presented as a fully blown ‘3.5G’ mobile triple play platform, supporting voice, data and video. The coincidence of timing indicates how cut throat the mobile broadband market will become in 2006, with EV-DO Rev A stealing a march on both the 3.5G technology for the GSM market, HSDPA, and on mobile WiMAX in terms of large scale roll-outs. The vendors behind all three technologies will be seeking to talk up the performance of their platforms, but much will depend on timing and how effectively they can squeeze the windows of opportunity for their rivals’ networks ‘ making rapid certification of 802.16e gear a top priority for the WiMAX community.

Sprint Nextel, which announced its mobile WiMAX trials last week, was talking this week about its Rev A plans, providing a case study of how a major operator with multiple spectrum holdings could look to combine the two technologies to deliver broadband services across the in-home, laptop and mobile environments, and with a wide range of applications. Indeed, this is the scenario that WiMAX vendors ‘ keen to gain a portion of the investment of the major cellcos and converged players ‘ like to paint, with the two technologies running in parallel, each optimized for different needs. Ironically, Qualcomm now takes the same view, though it promotes its own OFDM-based technologies such as Flarion Flash-OFDM and the FLO broadcasting network, arguing that OFDM will not quickly catch up with CDMA in terms of high mobility and other functionality, but has its place for very high bandwidth applications and for fixed access.

As well as Sprint Nextel, Japan’s KDDI and Korea’s SK Telecom (both also planning parallel networks using mobile broadband) were presenting their Rev A plans at the 3G CDMA Americas Congress in Miami, Florida ‘ although Verizon Wireless is expected to remain the most advanced deployer of the new release, which offers full IP support for applications such as VoIP, for some time.

KDDI is planning to deploy Rev A in 2006, and is looking to its 3.1Mbps data speeds and IP support for applications such as VoIP and video telephony. Beyond Rev A, president Tadashi Onodera said the company will move to what he called ‘Ultra 3G’, combining fixed and mobile access with an all-IP core, but he was not specific about which technologies he would envisage underpinning that goal. The move to all-IP will be a common one for most major carriers, and the equipment vendors are seeking to carve out a strong position in the platform, with Qualcomm adding OFDM and scalable bandwidth options to its CDMA roadmap, the UMTS community focusing on the DoCoMo-inspired ‘Super 3G’ and on its own OFDM proposals, and WiMAX coming up behind.

KDDI said that it now has over 20m subscribers, with 4.3m of those using its first generation EV-DO network for 3G-enabled services, notably a full song download offering that has seen 5m songs purchased since July.

SK Telecom also spoke of increased EV-DO adoption as handsets become widely available and as users sign up for advanced services such as full music downloads, its movie portal site and mobile gaming. The company’s EV-DO network is now one of the world’s largest, covering 90% of Korea. SKT will next year roll out the pre-WiMAX technology Wi-Bro in its 2.3GHz spectrum to offer portable broadband services and is currently working to position this offering as complementary to EV-DO Rev A ‘ its Wi-Bro adoption is widely seen as defensive against the entry of mainly fixed line carrier Korea Telecom into the mobile world with its own Wi-Bro license. Unlike Sprint Nextel, which is portraying WiMAX in a positive way as a means to take on the DSL telcos in the last mile, SKT has a far larger advanced broadband base to protect and epitomizes some of the new conflicts and challenges that the cellcos will face as they recognize that 3G and 3.5G are no longer the only mobile data options, and that the fixed line and start-up carriers will be able to seize part of the market using WiMAX.

According to Brian Moo King, chief technology officer at SKT, 25% of the company’s revenue comes from data services, with data ARPU standing at $10 on average, but $20 for EV-DO, a figure that should leap further with the new data rates supported by Rev A.

Sprint Nextel’s EV-DO roll-out has only just begun and lags Verizon Wireless’, but CTO Barry West told the conference that it plans to expand EV-DO coverage to 100% of its network by the end of next year, and then migrate to EV-DO Rev A in 2008, a parallel timing with its WiMAX build-out in 2.5GHz spectrum. West also focused on the ability for Rev A to support VoIP ‘ one of Qualcomm’s cleverest recent moves to keep its CDMA carrier base loyal. “We don’t need it, but I prefer to get to VoIP as quickly as possible,” West said.

Like Verizon Wireless, Sprint Nextel is considering rapid moves to delivering VoIP over EV-DO even though mobile voice is still far more efficiently transmitted over circuit switched cellular networks. The thinking is that implementation of VoIP on EV-DO will do away with the need to make another network upgrade, to CDMA EV-DV (Data and Voice). Although originally conceived as a data-only enhancement for CDMA, EV-DO latest iteration, Rev A, can support VoIP, and so EV-DV has largely disappeared off the operators’ ‘ and creator Qualcomm’s ‘ agenda. VoIP is also, of course, part of the convergence plans of the big carriers, including Verizon Wireless’ larger parent, Verizon Communications, and Sprint Nextel with their plans to offer fixed services using WiMAX and some wired lines.

Dick Lynch, Verizon Wireless’ CTO, said recently: ‘VOIP is clearly on the evolution path, and it’s a timeframe where I can start doing preliminary design work now. I’ve said this to every vendor I can get my hands on: ‘Voice is an application, guys’.’

In the short term, there is no real benefit to a cellco in offering VoIP over its main network. For all its advantages in terms of convergence and data services, IP is not inherently suited to all applications, particularly in the mobile world, and various technological compromises are necessary that make it heavy on the network. 3G operators using CDMA EV-DO or UMTS can deliver voice in the equivalent of about 12Kbps of bandwidth, using circuit switching, while VoIP uses anything from 24Kbps to 128Kbps.

The threat to cellcos from VoIP over Wi-Fi or WiMAX comes from the low cost structures and resulting low subscription rates of the service providers, not from the offer of VoIP per se. Until WiMAX is fully mobilized, 3G operators will retain that as the chief advantage of their voice services, regardless of whether they are offering VoIP or cellular voice ‘ provided they can hand off from their cellular networks to Wi-Fi when the customer requires. Even with 802.16e, there are challenges to overcome to enable operators to deliver mobile VoIP efficiently, and meeting these challenges will be essential to the success of future networks, whether mobile WiMAX or the increasingly IP-centric 3GPP2 cellular roadmap.

While the operators focuse on VoIP, the vendors of Rev A are making even grander triple play statements and have their own balancing act to position their various mobile broadband technologies in a complementary way that has the greatest potential to generate multi-platform revenues.

Nortel demonstrated a triple play offering ‘ with VoIP, high speed data and IPTV media services over a single connection over Rev A – last week, claiming the combination of EV-DO with IP Multimedia Subsystem would be ‘as fast, reliable and secure as wireline connections ‘ help make tomorrow’s service aware networks more intelligent, and assist CDMA operators in increasing profit potential by creating new business models and service bundling opportunities.’ Nortel’s first triallist will be Verizon Wireless and its Rev A products will be generally available next year. As well as all-important bundling, it sees key early applications as gaming, broadcasting, multicasting and PTx (Push to Talk, Push to Video and Push to See). Nortel claims peak rates of 3.1Mbps on the downlink and 1.8Mbps on the uplink with half the latency of EV-DO Rev 0.

Nortel, like most major network vendors, is also pursuing convergence and triple play markets with broadband wireless technologies such as WiMAX and Wi-Fi mesh. Its close Verizon relationship is one factor that makes it vital for it to stay in the front rank of CDMA suppliers but, with its history in wireline and wireless networks and its advanced developments in next generation UMTS ‘ particularly its HSOPA OFDM proposals – its real growth opportunities lie in providing converged and flexible options for the increasingly complex requirements of large carriers, whether wired, cellular or even municipal. The same applies to most large equipment makers, with the incentives particularly strong for those that have suffered recent upheaval or lost the initiative in key 3G markets ‘ including Nortel, Motorola and Lucent. All three are well poised to take advantage of the critical battle that will develop from 2006 for the hearts and minds of the operators, as EV-DO Rev A, mobile WiMAX and HSDPA all start to become reality.