We have paid a great deal of attention recently to the bid by the Japan-China-Korea axis to take a lead role in the intellectual property of fourth generation networks, and so to reduce their dependence on western patents and suppliers. The other Asian superpower, India, has been less aggressive, at least in the past few years, about creating and driving standards, but now it is indicating that it, too, wishes to take a leading role, in order to boost its own telecoms industry outside the home market, to reduce its telcos’ costs and increase the level of GDP derived from communications. In this quest, it is increasingly likely to ally with Korea and China.
In the late 1990s, Indian governments favored creating homegrown technology and standards in order to disadvantage outside vendors ‘ but at the cost of incompatibility with global standards (an approach now out of vogue, in general, though emulated by China with its creation of specific standards for 3G, wireless security and other platforms).
The current Indian administration has been the most ambitious to date in seeking to adopt next generation networking technologies at an early stage, bringing more of the population into the digital economy and stimulating the overall national economy by leapfrogging many more established nations in communications terms. Now it is setting out the development roadmaps that will underpin these aims, working with key partners from outside its borders but also looking to create an industry and a driving force of its own.
The Indian ministry of information technology has published a report on its key R&D programs in 2004-5, showing a strong focus on wireless technologies and affordable computing.
The programs include developing very simple, low cost messaging terminals that could extend wireless communications to poorer communities; an operating system for smart cards; and various building blocks for an ambitious perpetually available mobile communications infrastructure, with Wi-Fi and WiMAX key elements.
The ministry recently set up the Center for Excellence in Wireless Technologies (CeWIT) in Chennai, a public-private initiative to promote R&D in fixed and mobile technologies and create next generation wireless platforms. CeWIT will address issues of achieving last mile access at low cost in order to incorporate more of the country into the digital economy, and how to strengthen India’s global role in creating next generation systems by improving its intellectual property base, and therefore its ability to help drive standards. This in turn could reduce its burden of royalty payments to outside vendors.
Another project, this one implemented by the Indian Institute of Technology in Madras, is working on mesh peer-to-peer technologies for rural Wi-Fi-based networks that would solve the last 25 kilometer access problem in rural India.
Another initiative is MeTel, a low cost messaging terminal targeted at villages sharing a Wi-Fi connection.
While India is stepping up its activities in R&D that can be exported as well as exploited internally, it still lacks the advanced vendor community to commercialize these technologies abroad. It offers a low cost manufacturing base, but so far this has benefited western companies ‘ especially since rules on foreign investment in India were relaxed ‘ as much as the native suppliers, which remain unsophisticated in terms of handset design or large operator support capabilities. Like the Chinese manufacturers, which have been going through a similar cycle from mere cost efficiency to innovation and quality, the Indian vendors will develop rapidly, but the country, for now at least, remains dependent on outside ventures to get its technologies into the wider world.
It tends to favour non-US partners in many instances, and is working closely, at government and supplier level, with counterparts in Korea and China. A key focus is likely to be WiMAX, with Samsung and Intel both working intensively on encouraging Indian adoption of the technology. So far, Samsung seems to have made the most headway, and it is widely believed that, had its Wi-Bro technology failed to be harmonized with the 802.16e mobile WiMAX standard, India would have gone with Wi-Bro. This would have been an even greater blow to WiMAX, in the short term, than a Chinese decision for the Asian platform, since India is far more aggressive about implementing broadband wireless access on a wide scale within a short time period than China is.
The other key partner in WiMAX ‘ and especially the bid to combine that network with very low cost user equipment, an effort that lies at the heart of plans to extend access in India ‘ is Alcatel. The French company has extended its alliance with the center of wireless development in India with a formal joint venture that could position the French company strongly once the Indian broadband wireless market expands.
The vendor has formed a venture with the Center for the Development of Telematics (C-DOT), the Indian Government’s telecoms technology center, to design and develop products related to broadband wireless and WiMAX. The new company, called CDOT Alcatel Research Center, will be 51% owned by Alcatel and 49% by C-DOT.
The Indian Cabinet approved the scheme within five months of the signing of the original memorandum of understanding with Alcatel, as part of its aggressive plan to bring broadband access to a higher percentage of the population and even to seek to leapfrog more established wireless economies with ‘4G’ deployments.
The Chennai-based company will be a global R&D center for broadband wireless products with a primary focus on 802.16e and on applications for rural, urban and suburban Indian markets, though much of the expertise could be exported abroad and will clearly be fed back into other Alcatel activities, such as its quest for a very low cost subscriber unit.
While such ventures may help decide the market pattern for the infrastructure market and ‘ as in China ‘ allow companies like Alcatel to retain their influence even as the homegrown vendors mature, the real vendor goldrush centers on handsets. Also echoing developments in recent times in China, the handset makers wish to target the potentially massive consumer market evolving in India while taking advantage of its low cost manufacturing base.
Samsung is the latest phonemaker planning to set up a plant in India, both to lower its overall costs and to target the market ‘ growing at the rate of 2.5m cellular subscribers per month, an dnow up to 63m in size – from a local base. Samsung has been investigating possible locations near Mumbai.
Nokia opened a cellphone factory near Chennai last month and LG is building one in Ranjangaon in the west of the country. Motorola is also considering such a move, as are various white label phonemakers. Motorola is particularly sensitive about the Indian handset market, where it has failed to make the same impact it did in China. It has only single digit market share, which CEO Ed Zander referred to last week as ‘unacceptable’.
At an investor conference in New York, he admitted: “I’m still not happy with India’.
Motorola is traditionally strong in emerging markets and holds the market lead in Russia, which will be important for the eastern European and central Asian markets. It is also making a strong showing in the nascent sub-Saharan African bases. But in India it faces not only its traditional competitors but the Chinese manufacturers, such as ZTE and Ningbo Bird, which see India as a natural first base for their plans to become global players. As they build manufacturing bases there, they can also save up to 10% in export and shipping costs as they start to target Europe and the Americas.
With Ningbo Bird launching models in India that undercut even its local suppliers by 10%, the threat to Motorola and Nokia in this market clearly comes from China and Korea. Against a background of increasingly close trade links and exchange of technology and skills, India and China, despite their radically different cultures and difficult historic relations, see the chance to pool their respective strengths and build a new technology power base. India’s desperate economic and social need to find a financially viable way to bring communications to the bulk of its vast and dispersed population will drive its advanced R&D and create ground breaking platforms that will then be ready to export to the rest of the world, particularly other emerging economies. While some traditional suppliers, such as Alcatel, will retain a strong position, others will find their world shrinking over the next decade with the new ambition of the eastern suppliers.